jsanchez: Black Metal Classics

EyesWideShut 09.04.09	why would u describe old mans child as "Melodic death metal" on a black metal classics list ?
plutosatanclubhouse 09.04.09	cradle had a good riff every now and then back in the day but their songwriting was really haphazard and dani's vocals are holyshit annoying imo
BallsToTheWall 09.04.09	1.meh 2.good 3.great 4..... 5.good 6.ehhh 7.havent heard 8.awesome 9.meh 10.Great. List is either overtly melodic or super mainstream or crap. Needs moar grim and kvlt.
illmitch 09.04.09	what balls said
Bullitt 09.04.09	Only heard 2,3 and 10.
jsanchez 09.04.09	Super mainstream Black Metal doesn't exist. And yeah, i admit it, most of this stuff is really melodic. Only 3, 8, 10 are the only true BM atmospheric albums. Fixed the typo under Old Mans Child CD. * at Balls: How can you say 1 is just "meh". Don't give 7) a try since the sound is more Death than Black.
BallsToTheWall 09.04.09	Melodic black metal sucks. it's considered faggotry for a genre built on such grim ideas to be watered down and overly produced in purple. Fuck this shit, listen to Basilisk, Grand Belial's Key, early Primordial, Darkspace, Forest Silence, Branikald, Forest, old Nachtmystium, Megiddo, Arckanum, and you didnt even mention Bathory............... I'm suprised and glad to see Catamenia nowhere near this list.
myhigherpie 09.04.09	ya list is epic fail. I mean, come on. It has post-sventevith behemoth.
Lunarfall 09.04.09	sons of northern darkness >>>>>>>>>>>>>> at the heart of winter
R6Rider 09.04.09	what do you think of the first 2 in flames albums Balls?
Lunarfall 09.04.09	in flames has never been black metal, although the first album has some black metal traits
R6Rider 09.04.09	I disagree
jsanchez 09.04.09	Saying In Flames is Black Metal sucks way more than this list. Ohhh, wait i made this list, lol. Balls, Id like to see your top 10 black metal list so I can go and listen to some of it. And no way In Flames first album has Black Metal traits (If you mean Lunar Strain). And if you where a true BM purist you would even listen to In Flames to begin with.
R6Rider 09.04.09	oh yeah I forgot, In Flames suck now, so that must mean that everything they ever recorded is void
jsanchez 09.04.09	No really, i love In Flames first 2 albums and Clayman. They are not Black Metal however.
BallsToTheWall 09.04.09	I'm not a purist. I just like good music.
jsanchez 09.04.09	Then we will have to disagree, Melodic Black Metal is good music to me at least.
BallsToTheWall 09.04.09	You should like Pantheon I then. They are melodic b.m, that's actually pretty good, and they have acello player which adds a nice dynamic. Katatonia's frontman sings on Ascending. Amazing song.