cirq
06.22.09 | thomas erak > these dudes |
Zip
06.22.09 | List is right. |
Avirov
06.22.09 | Is this really uncommon knowledge around here? |
Douchebag
06.22.09 | Agreed with 2. 1 is ok, nothing special really. never heard if 3 or 5 and 4 is pretty fun, and is more of a showman than a guitarist. |
hectorkemp
06.22.09 | Number 1 is a load of balls. Sure he was a mediocre, overrated guitarist, but early Metallica makes me jizz. haha |
myhigherpie
06.22.09 | G
E
N
E
R
I
C
LIST |
brainsheldis
06.22.09 | As a (pretty good if I do say so) guitarist myself, I always disagree when people say Kirk Hammett is overrated. I know this will probably fall on deaf ears but it's my opinion so, whatever.
I know he uses the E pentatonic scale on almost every song, and I know he's not the fastest by any means, but goddammit he just puts out some of the most sonically pleasing solos I've ever heard. Every solo just fits in perfectly with the song, with just the right feeling. While other shredheads just wank around or sweep pick like mad, Kirk knows just what notes to place where. If you mean overrated in the technical department, sure I definitely agree. If you mean overall, I definitely disagree.
Just my two cents, I love Kirk. |
Spare
06.22.09 | because petrucci is a very good guitar player. oh wait this guy said that 5 was a good guitarist but just writes shit songs so yeah i guess petrucci should be here but idgaf |
Prometherion
06.22.09 | Good call on 1. The guy gets way too much credit. |
ConorMichaelJoseph
06.22.09 | Kirk isn't the most overrated guitarist in the world. Synyster isn't either because almost nobody who actually knows squat about guitar thinks he is good. I've never heard much praise for Angus Young. I'd put Satriani, Slash and Hendrix in instead of them. |
Bullitt
06.22.09 | Kirk isn't overrated, go to hell. |
Bullitt
06.22.09 | "Well, can he stand up to the likes of John Petrucci or Jeff Loomis?"
Can they write the unforgiven, or disposable heroes. Didnt think so, speed doesnt equal good music, sorry. |
stephenhannibal
06.22.09 | This list could use a ton of names... but the ones you have are great.
I have never known anyone to like Synester Gates.... |
cracksinthepavement
06.22.09 | List needs Slash. |
Shredzilla
06.22.09 | John Petrucci isn't on the list because his guitar playing is not just wanking around all the damn time. Listen to his work on Another Day, In The Presence of Enemies Pt. 1 and and Under A Glass Moon tell me he's not a well rounded and impressive guitarist.
He specializes in many techniques, not just one, which is what makes him such an effective guitarist. And yes, anything Petrucci has written with Dream Theater is ten times better than anything I've heard from Metallica. Disposable Heroes is hardly their best song.
Oh, and about the list. I completely forgot about Slash. I also think he's ridiculously overrated. I might edit the list, but I'm not sure. Angus Young is still quite overrated, especially amongst a lot of my guitar students. |
robertsona
06.22.09 | metalz |
ninjuice
06.22.09 | Hammett writes fantastic riffs and solos in what used to be one of the best metal bands ever = he is not that overrated.
Jeff Buckley is probably more overrated than these guys. |
Bullitt
06.22.09 | Dream theater better than Metallica?! HAHA!! |
ConorMichaelJoseph
06.22.09 | Just because a band is overrated doesn't mean its members are. I agree with Ninjuice. Also, I'd imagine a lot of your students are kids younger than yourself, so their opinions are hardly worth taking into consideration when compiling a list of overrated guitarists. Though I'll hand it to you that slash is over-appreciated. |
PuddleSwimmer
06.22.09 | agree with Benzum |
ninjuice
06.22.09 | "LOLLLLL that is the most retarded thing i have ever heard. get out"
He's right.
U get out. |
combustion07
06.22.09 | Hendrix wrote amazing music if anyone else says anything otherwise I will kill them with my bare hands. |
ninjuice
06.22.09 | lol musical genius. |
Shredzilla
06.23.09 | I'm glad everyone has different opinions on this. I love the the fact that I can debate this. But seriously, Kirk Hammet is sucked off by way too many guitarists. I mean, for goodness sake! He was one of the first guitarists to be inducted into the Guitar World magazine guitarist Hall of Fame. David Gilmour is still not on the list! Come on' guys! That's quite ridiculous. |
scissorlocked
02.15.10 | that list is funn!!!Although hammet has written many memorable songs,and comparing angus to syn gates or herman li is not fare.He was just a simple guy that wanted to rock and didnt mind using the same riffs over and over again.He is more considered as a cult figure.On the other hand herman li is just trying to play faster and faster.His songwriting abilities are very bad. |
Greenman
02.15.10 | Needs Dimebag. |
Hyperstation
02.15.10 | I've always thought Slash kind of sucked |
Yazz_Flute
02.15.10 | I agree that 1 and 3 are overrated but they're both very talented. I disagree with 5 wholeheartedly though. |
Deviant.
02.15.10 | There's 1 thing about this list that strikes me as amusing listmaker, and that is this: i'm 100% sure that all the guitarists on this list all play the guitar BETTER. THAN. YOU |
Greenman
02.15.10 | They damn well better be better players than him. IT'S THEIR FUCKING JOB!!! |
Spec
04.08.10 | How could 3 be overrated if no one even knows who he is?
He's underrated more than anything and DOES showcase a creative style of guitar playing. Also go in a forum on sputnik and say angus young is amazing and see if anybody agree's. Its no secret that angus isn't a great guitar player, it is his stage precese that makes him great. |
Spec
04.08.10 | And the guitarist from Dragonforce... really? Everyone knows he blows donkey ass |
heatherwaterman
04.19.10 | You asshole! why would you make such a stupid list? You cannot compare one guitarist to another, each one has their own unique style that makes them awesome! Kirk Hammett is an amazing guitarist! and i agree with Deviant1769 100%!! and how can u compare Kirk to John Petrucci or Jeff Loomis? the best guitarist ever! if he were better than them, then they wouldnt be the best obviously! |
Ire
04.19.10 | stfu syester gates rulzzzz
he cann uh uh uh
yeah |
CoRpSeSlAyEr
04.19.10 | i actually just went to a rusty cooley clinic and might i add u could not be more wrong about him |
ShadowRemains
04.19.10 | "Needs Dimebag."
greenman, you son of a bitch
|
PearlDrummer20
04.24.10 | Angus Young is overrated!? Have you ever seen him in concert? he can shred amazing licks, man! |
TBliss
04.24.10 | Definately Kirk Hammet. All my favourite Metallica solos were played by Hetfield. |
Lambda
04.24.10 | Disagree with 5, agree with 2 |