Titan50
06.12.09 | All are at least a 3.5 rating (probably)
Also, if anyone could link me to where I could download their B-sides album Lipstick Traces, I'd be grateful |
AliW1993
06.12.09 | aw man, im in the middle of doing know your enemy. my rating is less than 3.5 though so i suppose they will be different. i actually think that the holy bible is really overrated, gold against the soul is my fav manics album. |
Titan50
06.12.09 | Know Your Enemy wasn't supposed to be a "good" album, it was supposed to break their fanbase, similar to Angel Dust and In Utero
Also, it'd be interesting see a slightly negative Holy Bible review, you should do that |
AliW1993
06.12.09 | its not bad, im gonna give it a 3 cos theres some really good songs on it, some of it is just really dull and it's too long imo. i might review the holy bible after i've listened to it a little more, but i've had it for ages and it hasn't grown on me at all. |
Titan50
06.12.09 | bump :) |
Chewie
06.12.09 | God damnit I need 1, fuck |
VeryPleasantNeighbor
06.13.09 | I'd have Send Away the Tigers a little higher than the two albums before it, but other than that I more or less agree with the order.
It would be great to see a non-5 review of Holy Bible, even though I'm of the opinion that it's basically a perfect album. |
Titan50
06.13.09 | "God damnit I need 1, fuck"
It's part of a 2 for 10 offer at HMV. I think all of their albums are
"I'd have Send Away the Tigers a little higher than the two albums before it, but other than that I more or less agree with the order."
Your Love Alone puts Send Away the Tigers down for me. It's one of their worst songs imo |
Asiatic667
06.13.09 | 1,4,5 are absolutely fantnificent, The Holy Bible is like my 2nd favourite album!
10 is great too, I've just started listening to it-- definitely a wicked album
Manics need more attention on this site. |
Titan50
06.13.09 | 10 isn't part of the list :p |
Asiatic667
06.13.09 | well why'd you include it doofus |
Titan50
06.13.09 | Read description, doofus |
Asiatic667
06.13.09 | your description doesn't change the fact that it's on the actual list |
Titan50
06.13.09 | Cry me a river :) |
Asiatic667
06.13.09 | Who's crying?
The whole thing started because I said OK Computer is great |
Titan50
06.13.09 | And I agree wholeheartedly |
