ClearTheLane
02.08.09 | yes, a big YES to 10. It definitely is an amazing album, and if it was made in the late 80s it would be seen as one of the best shoegaze albums ever. |
Mendigo
02.08.09 | "Despite the fact that no pre-Dark Side era album could even come close to match up with Piper At The Gates of Dawn"
Despite the fact that I generally dislike overrated/underrated lists, I actually like A Saucerful of Secrets MORE than The Piper at the Gates of Dawn
actually this list is not that bad at all (especially because you have 9 on here, which finally IS a really overrated album). |
The Computer
02.08.09 | I saw 10 in concert with Nine Inch Nails, but I can't find that dang album. 9 is overrated cause it has only 2 good songs. I like how you say A Sacerful and Final Cut and Division Bell are underrated cause they are. DSOM Is overrated. |
Nagrarok
02.08.09 | This is better than the previous one. |
Phantom
02.08.09 | Where the hell did you get the idea that Trivium and Emmure are liked enough to be overrated. Certainly not from here. |
BallsToTheWall
02.08.09 | Aresx is overrated for continually making the most retarded lists this side of sputnik. Stop now, your far behind as it is. |
aresx
02.08.09 | :'( |
Spamue1G
02.08.09 | I hate you for 8, and love you for 1. 9's pretty good tbh. |
AliW1993
02.08.09 | better than the other one, though 9 rules |
ninjuice
02.08.09 | comment for 8 is retarded.
and it looks like you're considering half of Pink Floyd's catalog to be underrated. |
Yotimi
02.08.09 | 9 is the most overrated album of all time imo. It marked their transition from awesome to horrible for me. |
Douchebag
02.08.09 | lol are you TRYING to piss me off! :(
Not only did your last list diss my all time favourite album, but you said 2 of my top 5 metal albums are overrated! (Painkiller and Black album)
At least powerslave or number of the beast ain't here! |
kygermo
02.08.09 | I absolutely love Floyd, but Piper is and never was for me. Just cant get into it. I find it to be a tad immature and I prefer the warmer floyd with Gilmour anyday. Saucerful is a great album, considering they didnt know how to really write songs yet. Disagree on Painkiller, though. |
Phantom
02.09.09 | 'comment for 8 is retarded.'
I only just read it and....oh sheeeeeeeeet. AOJB is the best Killswitch album and no I don't whore 'core' music. |
Diarrhea
02.09.09 | you're a despicable person. |
72haha72
02.09.09 | I disagree with 8, I think it is really good for metalcore standards. And it came out before metalcore became the new nu metal.
I agree with 9, I don't think it blows, it's just average
|
TheBumbino
02.23.09 | i TOTALLY agree with you the black album ugh one of the most overrated albums ever... |
gaslightanthem
02.23.09 | srsly alligator you're blind love for metallica is ridiculous |
illmitch
02.23.09 | i don't know any of the underrated albums but i agree with basically every single one of the overrated albums
gj |
MopHeadOvMetal
07.20.11 | The Respect Issue is overrated in a way, just 'cause FELONY gets more of the hate.
The Respect Issue was terrible
FELONY was just unoriginal |
Pyosisified
07.20.11 | was this really necessary |
BigHans
07.20.11 | Youre a colossal idiot for 3, 8, and 9.
And the Crusade isnt overrated its almost universally panned. |
BigHans
07.20.11 | wait nevermind list is 2 years old |
BallsToTheWall
07.20.11 | Oh Hans. |
BloodSweatandBeers
07.20.11 | at least 4 and 9 are right |
