anarchistfish
02.24.26 | List is digs
Next on my list:
White Lotus
Devs
The Leftovers
The Last of Us
Arcane |
budgie
02.24.26 | aye fuckin LOOOVE midnight mass so fkn good easy 10/10 likewise |
Emim
02.24.26 | Agreed on rick and morty and fallout.
Can't wait for Invincible and Daredevil next month too. Hoping Daredevil returns to its former glory |
AlkemestRedux
02.24.26 | Yeah Midnight Mass is a top tier show. Absolutely loved everything about it.
Have you watched From? Also an awesome show and you'd probably like it based on your watches. New season comes out in April too. |
anarchistfish
02.24.26 | Yeah I've seen From. Enjoy it but was getting a bit frustrated by the latest season. They need to advance with it or it's gonna be another Lost
Dark is my GOAT TV show for reference
Invincible is also on my list |
Rowan5215
02.24.26 | From started out so strong but it got dumb extremely quick. definitely another Lost
absolutely hated Alien Earth, Noah Hawley has had the biggest falloff of any TV writer I can think of since Chris Carter |
Sharenge
02.24.26 | hate the show, love the xeno |
anarchistfish
02.24.26 | Didn't realise it was the same creator as the Fargo TV series. Definitely not in the same league but what makes you guys hate it? |
DoofDoof
02.24.26 | Much prefer Silo to Fallout gotta say.
Silo 7/10
Fallout 4/10 |
anarchistfish
02.24.26 | Can always count on you for dumbfounding opinions Doof |
anarchistfish
02.24.26 | Oh forgot I had also watched Andor finally. Both seasons probably strong 9/10s but I think enough has been said about it and it isn't controversial to say it's probably the best SW media since Empire |
el_newg
02.24.26 | I got a few months of Apple TV thingie for free so im trying to get through the shows on there. so far Pluribus was good but wayyy too slow, Mythic Quest (at least season 1) was painfully unfunny, Dark Matter was ok and Silo S1 was fine. obv gotta watch Severance and also wanna check Shrinking, heard its good.
I've watched From and think its fuckin stupid, you never get any answers to a single mystery that gets raised, and the characters are just morons. why do I still watch it expecting any resolution? |
DoofDoof
02.24.26 | Silo hits that 'claustrophobia' note...I'd compare it more to ('a more mature version of') Snowpiercer than Fallout.
Fallout is just trashy to me, Amazon just can't get it right too often...I guess the Boys has its moments. |
DoofDoof
02.24.26 | Best shows on Apple are Foundation, Slow Horses and Pluribus (I actually think Vince Gilligan is a genius of pacing). |
Rowan5215
02.24.26 | "Definitely not in the same league but what makes you guys hate it?"
absolutely couldn't stand the grown actors pretending to be kids stuff, got so old by episode 2 and it was just insufferable by the (really bad) finale. felt like there was interesting stuff happening on the edge of each episode but the Peter Pan shit constantly overshadowed it. Kirsh was a great character and Olyphant carried the cast as he often does
also thought it was the lamest xeno onscreen apart from the CGI Covenant one. just ran around like a dog and did all of the killing offscreen instead of being an intelligent predator and actually adding some tension. tbh though Fargo s4 was so ass I can't be objective about his work anymore lmao |
anarchistfish
02.24.26 | Don't think I finished Fargo S3 but S1 was elite (Billy Bob Thornton as possibly my fave TV villain ever) and S2 was really good too
Also need to watch Snowpiercer. The film was always a fave of mine |
Christbait
02.24.26 | Midnight Mass and Fall of the House of Usher are Flanagan's best works. I adored both of them so fucking much. As a guy who loves convincingly delivered monologues, I ate up Midnight Mass.
I've tried Fallout twice and cannot get into it. Doesn't mean it's a bad show, just not a show for me. |
Retter42
02.24.26 | Midnight Mass was awesome. If yo have ever played Bloodborne, you will notice many similarities. |
Zac124
02.24.26 | Was a little disappointed with the new Rick and Morty season tbh. Its fine and definitely more consistent than season 7 but season 7's highs are some of the best episodes in the entire show. And no episode in season 8 came close those highs apart from maybe the last episode. |
anarchistfish
02.24.26 | Would have to rewatch but yeah the last few seasons have been mainly 7 or 8 bad to decent episodes and then 2 or 3 absolute bangers, whereas season 8 was mainly just a collection of good episodes with no real duds
I don't remember thinking any of last season were all timers though |
anarchistfish
02.24.26 | And yeah I really have to get over it and just play Bloodborne and the rest in that case |
AlkemestRedux
02.24.26 | Definitely understand the hesitancy with From. I think this next season will indicate if they know how they're going to end it, but it's also one of those shows where waiting until the end to decide whether to watch it is absolutely warranted. |
anarchistfish
02.24.26 | If From Season 4 dithers anymore I am ready to give it up yeah. I hate mystery box shows that milk themselves with no direction, hence my love for Dark and Westworld S1 (which could and should've ended there) |
Zac124
02.24.26 | For me it was the spaghetti, evil morty and the hole episodes. Evil Morty episode is just a great story episode. It nicely mirrors Rick Potion #9. Spaghetti and the hole are just pinnacle Rick and Morty for me. Strange sci-fi concept filled with dark humour whilst having some emotional stakes even though it never takes itself too seriously. |
DoofDoof
02.24.26 | 'From' is probably the best 'guilty pleasure' show out there right now? |
Kimm
02.24.26 | If only there was a website called mediasnobs.com that specifically held space to review TV series
😇
...I love 2, may need to do a binge soon.
8 held my interest long enough. Tried to get into 10 but it just didn't click for me. |
anarchistfish
02.24.26 | I could crosspost to mediasnobs and just start reviewing there yeah |
Kimm
02.24.26 | Hell yeah!
*My apologies for the snark tho, sometimes I think I'm being cute when really I just sound like an asshole 🙃 |
trilo
02.24.26 | From started off so interesting but fell into the same trappings as basically every other mystery box show with the added detriment of nothing ever fucking happens. I wouldn't even care if they just kept stringing the mystery along for a few seasons if stuff happened but S2 was so boring and I heard S3 was just as bad if not worse. S4 would need to be straight heat for me to consider slogging through it again |
DoofDoof
02.24.26 | I never felt From had a lack of stuff happening, it's hardly The Last of Us in terms of interminable nothingness between the action. |
anarchistfish
02.25.26 | There's lots happening, the problem is it just doesn't really go anywhere or tell us anything. Every reveal just serves to compound the mystery and make us cry in terror about what a bewildering and awful world it is which we already knew in season 1. That dithering/milking of an awful world gets exhausting to watch (also why I gave up with Handmaid's Tale eventually). We have very little further knowledge of how the world works compared to the end of S1 bar a couple of things that didn't need two seasons to reveal.
Dark was wrapped up by now and (likely) had far more to explain from the offset. From Season 3 was where a lot of us really started to think "oh no they actually don't seem to know where they're going with this" hence the frustration |
trilo
02.25.26 | yeah like i said nothing happens. too much filler. the central hook is the mystery and any time spent not on that is under greater scrutiny than other types of shows. if the side characters and plots were super compelling it wouldn't be a problem, but a mystery box relies on anticipation with a promise to the audience there's going to be a payoff. anticipation quickly becomes frustration if you can't either answer the questions or justify time spent not answering questions. From suffers from both. my memory of S2 is you could cut a few episodes and nothing would change and the reception i've seen of S3 seem to indicate the same issue, if not worse. there's a really good show in there if they were 6-7 eps per season but like a lot of streaming shows it's stretched thin |
DoofDoof
02.25.26 | 'Dark was wrapped up by now and (likely) had far more to explain from the offset.'
Dark was the ultimate time travel show to the point I feel it is redundant for time travel being used in any film or show now, but it did get close to impenetrable at some points in Season 2. What I like about Dark is it had one of the most satisfying endings in all TV that wrapped it all up with a bow and made logical sense within the established framework meticulously set up.
I'm gutted they canned 1899 as I thought that had a lot of promise too.
The Handmaid's Tale went on far too long agreed, never watched the final season (I'm assuming there has been a final season). |
DoofDoof
02.25.26 | 'From' is a bit padded but I feel the scope and world building has been pretty effective mostly.
It's like Twin Peaks....if you answer the main mystery you'll need an equally good or better mystery to replace it (which is why half of Season 2 of Twin Peaks is absolute garbage). Easier to tease it along? |
el_newg
02.25.26 | dont you dare say From is like Twin Peaks ever again :'( |
anarchistfish
02.25.26 | I actually found Dark S3 a bit harder to follow. Dark S2 is probably my favourite season of TV ever
I agree it feels redundant to get another time travel show now though 12 Monkeys is on my list
From S4 will be revealing as to whether it's actually headed somewhere or they're gonna milk this towards a half baked finale once everyone gets bored and the hype dies |
FurtherDown
02.25.26 | ad Noah Hawley conversation - Fargo S02 and S03 are probably my favorite pieces of TV ever (not that I watched that many shows tbh), S04 wasn't good but I recommend S05, felt like a return to form, thematically very resonant to the current times.
Based on the reactions I'm not gonna watch Alien: Earth though. |
anarchistfish
02.25.26 | Alien Earth has got its moments for sure |
Rowan5215
02.25.26 | I'll peep s5 but I have very little trust left in him at this point lol, the ending of Legion sucked hard too. agreed Fargo s2 and 3 are goated, Thewlis' character in 3 is one of the best tv villains oat |
trilo
02.25.26 | S5 of Fargo is great yah, not quite S3/S1 level but a return to form after S4 |
DoofDoof
02.25.26 | 'dont you dare say From is like Twin Peaks ever again :'('
they both have a central 'golden goose' mystery - TP answered it's own one at the end of S1, From still hasn't really answered it's equivalent, though it's expanded the scope of the mystery. I don't have a major problem with From, though it doesn't rank in the pantheon of greats or anything like that. |
DoofDoof
02.25.26 | 'From' came out just as The Walking dead was confirmed as almost unbearable to watch...that's more the hole it filled for me. |
anarchistfish
02.25.26 | I think I gave up on Walking Dead around season 4 |
TheSupernatural
02.27.26 | I found Silo great and Fallout season 2 a mess that I ended up dropping after a few episodes. Not the first I've heard of people bouncing off Silo, but I'm a sucker for a mystery in a setting like that and I thought they managed it very well. Probably should have only been 6-8 episodes per season though. |
Winsomniac
02.27.26 | itt: uncultured fiends that haven't yet converted to The Apothecary Diaries SUPREMACY. |
VlacDrac
02.27.26 | Needs more Sopranos |
omgbecky
02.27.26 | Love to see #11 on your list, but I really came for the show reviews. Sad to hear about Silo though, I love end of days type shows/movies, but most of what I’ve heard about this show is negative :c |
trilo
02.27.26 | yeah Silo is agonizingly slow it's a shame |
DoofDoof
02.27.26 | If its a choice of too slow (Silo) or ADHD packed (last few episodes of Stranger Things?) I prefer slow. |
anarchistfish
02.28.26 | The beginning and end of Silo S1 were decent enough but there was a solid 4 or 5 episode run in the middle where I nearly gave up. Even Fallout handles its mystery payoffs better and those are barely the point half the time
Still haven't seen Stranger Things S4 let alone S5 |
omgbecky
02.28.26 | Feel free to ruin this for me, but is Rashida Jones in a lot of Silo? From the clips I've seen she gets killed off p quick. I don't watch much TV, but I'd be willing to watch the show if she doesn't get killed off. Also, have you watched Barry? It's funny in a Righteous Gemstones kinda way. |
anarchistfish
02.28.26 | I think I have seen Rashida in two episodes
I have not seen Barry |
Rowan5215
02.28.26 | Barry is so good |
anarchistfish
03.01.26 | I decided to just rewrite my review for Midnight Mass on mediasnobs
https://mediasnobs.com/reviews/midnight-mass-limited-series-henri
I like that I can rate by season unlike IMDbad or letterboxd
Idk how to translate my ratings though. B- should sound more bad considering it's equivalent to a 2/5 on a 9 point scale |