Zac124
11.04.25 | Top 6 are all fairly equal. The order could change any day |
Hawks
11.04.25 | 6
11
5
3
9
8
4
12
2
1
7
13
14
10
15 |
Zac124
11.04.25 | Interesting ranking. Silent Waters really grew on me this discog run. Previously it would be around 9th or 10th spot. |
Keyblade
11.05.25 | 6 and 5 are 1 & 2 for me. haven't heard the top 2 but I remember being really lukewarm on 3 |
Muzz79
11.05.25 | prefer later Amorphis but no.1 will always be Tales |
Dromasta
11.05.25 | I respect Skyforger at 12. I've seen so much love for that album, and to me, it's not bad, but I feel like it gets more love than Silent Waters in many cases. I remember listening to Silent Waters and fucking loving it, especially after Eclipse, which I also think is a great album. That one especially doesn't get enough praise. Skyforger was a disappointment for me back then, and I have the same opinion of it after re-listening recently. I don't understand how any fan of the band would rank that higher than SW. Skyforger does have some excellent, catchy tunes, but it was a regression, and a very safe record. |
Keyblade
11.05.25 | Skyforger does have some bangers for sure |
Hawks
11.05.25 | Skyforger rules, but is definitely mid-tier Amorphis. |
Thibs
11.05.25 | Elegy is often overlooked. Love that album |
Veldin
11.06.25 | Amazing band! I’ve been working thru their discog lately |
Zac124
11.06.25 | Glad I'm not the only one that thinks Skyforger is a bit eh. And yes Elegy is fantastic. |
Dromasta
12.28.25 | ^^^^ Glad I'm not the only one either because I've seen some people jizz their pants over it. It's fine, solid 3-3.5 |
Hawks
12.28.25 | Skyforger rips. |
MeatWolf
12.28.25 | Skyforger is a bit by the numbers, has a somewhat sterile production and also is a snoozefest in the middle. Sure has its moments, first four tracks are gold, but probably is my least favourite of Joutsen along with Halo.
I wonder how Circle could have sounded with different production. Probably the strongest album songwriting wise, Into the Abyss and My Future are both 11/10 songs, but the chainsaw sound gets to me by the end of it. |
