bighubbabuddha
07.02.24 | 6 is 1 |
tectactoe
07.02.24 | 6 is 1 [2] |
DistantDylann
07.02.24 | Final Cut is mediocrity that tries too hard to be The Wall part 2, and Roger treated his bandmates like crap |
BAT
07.02.24 | division bell > final cut.
and i like the live half of ummagumma |
DistantDylann
07.03.24 | Material that doesn't flow consistently as a story, ahs recycled ideas and a lack of Rick Wright that takes away from the overall experience |
evilford
07.03.24 | Top 3 are where they belong, albeit rearranged but there is no way in the name of Zeus' butthole that the final cut is a 2/5, album has more soul than all post-waters floyd albums combined |
el_newg
07.03.24 | "and Roger treated his bandmates like crap"
but I thought you separate the art from the artist and don't let it ruin music for you |
BAT
07.03.24 | honestly when it comes to final cut it does just sound like a 80s waters solo album, more of a stop gap between hitchhiking and radio kaos. personally: I think the 80s output of both waters and gilmore is underwhelming as hell and neither of them really best the other. division bell vs amused is probably the best contenders for post-wall Floyd.
annnnnd : the wall doesn't really scratch the Floyd itch for me, iconic album but coming off of animals it just lacks the vibe of 70s Floyd. |
DarkSideOfLucca
07.03.24 | Its weird how they used to be in my top 15 or so bands of all time but nowadays I cannot fucking stand Pink Floyd at all
It's like everything I don't want to listen to |
BAT
07.03.24 | lol, really mostly just go back to like echoes/dogs/time/and the Barrett stuff[crazy guitar work for the 60s.] I've lost a lot of respect for waters over the years and think he just kinda took too much credit for what makes the band recognizable. |
NudeTayne
07.03.24 | legit thought these were all gonna be 5's for a meme at first glance lol |
DarkSideOfLucca
07.03.24 | I just don't like how they sound literally nothing like Suffocation
Like maybe they can try sounding A LITTLE like Suffocation? |
Jurtz
07.03.24 | 5 will always hold a special place in my life.
It was my first encounter with Pink Floyd. |
e210013
07.03.24 | Nice ranking Dylann.
My ranking is probably:
1 - Wish You Were Here
2 - The Dark Side Of The Moon
3 - Animals
4 - The Wall
5 - Meddle
6 - Atom Heart Mother
7 - The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn
8 - A Saucerful Of Secrets
9 - The Division Bell
10 - Obscured By Clouds
11 - More
12 - The Final Cut
13 - A Momentary Lapse Of Reason
14 - The Endless River
15 - Ummagumma |
BitterJalapenoJr
07.03.24 | Top 4 is spot on although sometimes Animals can claim first place. I'd move The Wall down a bit and more Atom Heart Mother up. |
