AlexKzillion: a7x vs. slipknot

AlexKzillion 06.06.23	who will win sput? you must CHOOSE
InfernalDeity 06.06.23	Slipknot self-titled alone gets them the crown
JohnnyoftheWell 06.06.23	a7x by a country mile not sure how this is even a discussion
Ryus 06.06.23	slipknot by a country mile not sure how this is even a discussion [2]
Rowhaus 06.06.23	knot 100%
Wildcardbitchesss 06.06.23	ya Johnny is right pack it up boys
Ryus 06.06.23	Slipknot self-titled alone gets them the crown [2] really not even a debate for me tbh
Tundra 06.06.23	Dont have enough knowledge about the debuts Slipknot Slipknot Avenged Avenged Slipknot Avenged Slipknot Did not expect it to be that close lol
Flugmorph 06.06.23	wow nice parallels very good list thank you
neekafat 06.06.23	Finally a good take from johnny
JohnnyoftheWell 06.06.23	"Slipknot self-titled alone gets them the crown" tolerable argument, but jfc the thought of listening to Slipknot's discog end-to-end makes my toenails curl. a7x at least have thrills, spills and a hint of desire to cater to an audience beyond teenage mallgoers
Pikazilla 06.06.23	a7x by a country mile not sure how this is even a discussion [3] slipknot is just dumbfuck music for angry prepubescent kids
Tundra 06.06.23	"slipknot is just dumbfuck music for angry prepubescent kids" So is converge yet you eat that up what do??
Ryus 06.06.23	ok he was wrong but u didnt have to say that
AlexKzillion 06.06.23	lmaooo
Storm In A Teacup 06.06.23	1. A7X not even close 2. A7X not even close 3. Slipknot not even close 4. Tie 5. A7X 6. Slipknot not even close 7. A7X but i havent listened to the newest Slipknot
Storm In A Teacup 06.06.23	"slipknot is just dumbfuck music for angry prepubescent kids" So is converge yet you eat that up what do?? Holy shit tundra with comment of the year
Rowhaus 06.06.23	"So is converge yet you eat that up what do??" so savage lmfao
Storm In A Teacup 06.06.23	Im so jealous i didnt say that. Glorious comment.
Flugmorph 06.06.23	tundra won the internet today everyone clap soyjack emoji posted
Ryus 06.06.23	______________777777777777777n447____________ __________71777_________________777__________ ________7u7_________________________77_______ ______u7______________________________11_____ ____74______77777______777777777________3____ ___1n_____________77777__________________6___ __u7______7777777_______7777777777_______n7__ _17______717777_______________777_________4__ _q_____71______77__________777____7n7_____5__ _57___77________73________77_____7777_____3__ 708377777775557777ndnuu17n777777777777777400n 78d______11_1n5nn7787____87_777nn1n7_____5d8n _dd_____41_7880__7d8_____dn75_30d7757____448_ _187_____77777777770_____73_77777________079_ _14d777111nnnuu54q47______n77777777777777d_6_ _17_777777_________________________________4_ _17______________u_________________________3_ _17__________7577____________7u7__________71_ _4____________4____________77_47__________73_ _6_____________71177______71n7_____________q_ 1u____________7___7nuu1_______7____________13 97__________11__5q778_706uu5n7777777_______79 67_______717_756d7__8__b7_3u583____7n_____77d 9777____4___78d_6571877d7_uu14q05__u7____7144 66747___6__70888888888880dd0d88887_6__n_77467 19d777__77_58888888888888888888887_4_57_47d7_ _7bn5774___38888888888888888888887__37__764__ _7bd51_u7__58888888888888888888887__b_7nndq7_ 1d1467779__5888888888888888888880__7n_7u46ub_ 7u__d77_n7_788888888888888888888b__6_75667_61 _5__7d7774__688888888888888888884__6_7b6___47 __u_7747_d__7d8888888888888888887__673d5___b7 ___nn17b74____b88888888888888887__7q5b777745_ ____753nqq_____508888888888880n___78q17n7u7__ ______u3q8_______d88888888047_____7q___1_____ _______74817______7533554u________7577___7777 _________d0777__77___1_7_77_7___73097________ _________7461777u__7731_5_71_nu47d01_________ ____________4u647177311_17uu715b64___________ _____________n_6145ub4d5345u46557____________
AlexKzillion 06.06.23	do you guys think an m shadows solo album would be better or worse than corey taylor's?
JohnnyoftheWell 06.06.23	i do not ever want to know the answer to that question the difference between good and bad angry music is that only one holds up for a listener that ain't in the middle of a seethe themselves too bad tundra is too caught up in a state of permabutthurt to ever have a hope of understanding this
ConcubinaryCode 06.06.23	a7x by a BAT country mile!
Ryus 06.06.23	a7x wish they could write somethin as good as wait and bleed
Storm In A Teacup 06.06.23	They did it is called 'God Hates Us'
Flugmorph 06.06.23	on september 11th 2001
Storm In A Teacup 06.06.23	"the difference between good and bad angry music is that only one holds up for a listener that ain't in the middle of a seethe themselves too bad tundra is too caught up in a state of permabutthurt to ever have a hope of understanding this" Weak analysis. You just implied Converge is so bad even someone in a current rage still understands Converge sucks
Storm In A Teacup 06.06.23	Which tbf is true converge sucks but i know you werent trying to make that point. Fizzail
Ryus 06.06.23	slipknot would be even better if they had 9 more guys i think
JohnnyoftheWell 06.06.23	"You just implied Converge is so bad even someone in a current rage" honey i implied that people in a current rage don't know head from ass, by which correlation that's a pissier reply than i expected
AlexKzillion 06.06.23	i looked up slipknot's lineup and i am shocked they replaced the garbage can dude
JeetJeet 06.06.23	(Sic) alone >>> most of A7X's discog
Rowhaus 06.06.23	they should do the world a favor and converge themselves with silence
JohnnyoftheWell 06.06.23	can literally feel the force of rowhaus' keyboard stuttering while he spat that one out
AlexKzillion 06.06.23	i made a top 25 a7x list last week prior to the new album and i had to make a ton of hard cuts. i spent many sleep filled nights thinking it through does slipknot even have 25 good songs? i'm not sure they do. johnny what do you think?
JohnnyoftheWell 06.06.23	sorry some brain on the sleep token thread just told me debate was bad, my input from now on is off the cards
Ryus 06.06.23	slipknot choruses rule. i forgot how good they were. great pop music fr
ArsMoriendi 06.06.23	C'mon guys if you're gonna listen to this kinda stuff at least put on like SoaD's s/t instead
AlexKzillion 06.06.23	will concede wait and bleed has one of the best metal hooks ever, especially at the end of the song when they put corey's best cookie monster vox under it yum
Ryus 06.06.23	soad mostly sucks but id put them in a comfortable second behind slipknot "sugar" is a top tier banger at least
ArsMoriendi 06.06.23	tbh I'd honestly take Incubus over Slipknot too
ArsMoriendi 06.06.23	Sugar rules! though Peephole and DDevil are prob even better
SteakByrnes 06.06.23	a7x
JohnnyoftheWell 06.06.23	SOAD bricks on Slipknot for real, but post-Science Incubus is a bland mall band and has no place in any metal discourse ever
Rowhaus 06.06.23	"can literally feel the force of rowhaus' keyboard stuttering while he spat that one out" yeah I pound these keys like stephen king on a coke bender
Ryus 06.06.23	corey taylor>serj stankian
TheAntichrist 06.06.23	a7x no doubt
MoM 06.06.23	“do you guys think an m shadows solo album would be better or worse than corey taylor's?” Better. Probably wouldn’t feel much about it, but still better
JohnnyoftheWell 06.06.23	"corey taylor>serj stankian" this is a bottom 5 ryus take and you know it
Ryus 06.06.23	serj is annoying af and that band is basically uniformly mid ill defend this until i die
AlexKzillion 06.06.23	let ryus cook
TheAntichrist 06.06.23	life is but a dream beats anything slipknot ever made
normaloctagon 06.06.23	slipknot by a country mile not sure how this is even a discussion [8] here for this thread though
Ryus 06.06.23	thank u norma i thought i was going crazy
PotsyTater 06.06.23	Definitely slipknot but also Jesus fucking Christ
ArsMoriendi 06.06.23	tbh I only know 1 Avenged Sevenfold song cuz of Rock Band 2
Drifter 06.06.23	slipknot can suck me. i love a7x!
Pikazilla 06.06.23	comparing 'verge to slipknot, who are basically a gimpsuit circus violence act, and implying the latter is better is one of the shallowest takes I've seen all year
Christbait 06.06.23	I've fucked with Slipknot for like 20 years at this point. Never got tired of them. I got real tired of A7X though.
porcupinetheater 06.06.23	Are we implying that Converge is shallow rage music and not the collegiate angst synthesis of freshman 15 heartbreak and one of the many art classes where the professor's got a hard on for Deleuze?
Storm In A Teacup 06.06.23	Yes porc. More accusatory than simply implying.
DavidYowi 06.06.23	Thread has immense 2009 energy
porcupinetheater 06.06.23	I love Jane Doe and tbh it might be worth losing Jane Doe if it means also losing all the 600 degrees of free associative borderline-non-sequitor baggage attached to every time it gets brought up in any semi-tangential entry level hevy muzick discussion (which is all of them)
Shemson 06.06.23	For nostalgia I’d still play Slipknot self titled and Iowa and I’d sing along to tracks off Vol 3 and the one after because they have some good choruses. For nostalgia I’d play Waking The Fallen but that’s about it. Haven’t listened to either of their last two albums I don’t think because… well I don’t really think about them anymore except for nostalgia.
Koris 06.06.23	I like Slipknot, but... a7x by a country mile not sure how this is even a discussion [∞]
veninblazer 06.06.23	A7X have higher highs and lower lows
ShadowRemains 06.06.23	who cares listen to grotesque /pissbore
BAT 06.06.23	Slipknot across the board, but I've admittedly only ever heard awaken/city. I've just assumed they sounded like the black album for the past 15 years
Rowhaus 06.06.23	"comparing 'verge to slipknot, who are basically a gimpsuit circus violence act, and implying the latter is better is one of the shallowest takes I've seen all year" I'd take gimpsuit circus violence over melodramatic simpcore crap any day of the week
Koris 06.06.23	@BAT: check out The Stage, they went in a more progressive/conceptual direction with that one. Really good stuff
Storm In A Teacup 06.06.23	Honeyofthewell
Storm In A Teacup 06.06.23	😃😃😃
chemicalmarriage 06.06.23	The clown that beats the shit out of the garbage cans should make a solo album beating the fuck out of those cans for a half an hour
ArsMoriendi 06.06.23	Is Slipknot just Insane Clown Posse but less hip hop, but still slightly hip hop cuz turntables n' stuff Slippalos
chemicalmarriage 06.06.23	Start with the classic metal cans then work in some rubbermaid, screaming in between the cans. will be artistic as fuck
Purpl3Spartan 06.06.23	Did not have pika getting absolutely cooked by tundra on my bingo card but I’m here for it
Purpl3Spartan 06.06.23	A7X tho let’s be real yall
bellovddd 06.07.23	both bands are shit now. but slipknot was once good. so I guess them.
mryrtmrnfoxxxy 06.07.23	slipknot
Dedes 06.07.23	A7X>Slipknot A7X>Slipknot Slipknot>A7X Slipknot>A7X A7X>Slipknot (rocky album but gives me nostalgia mountain dew call of duty gamer vibes so eh???) A7X>Slipknot idk what either album sounds like but you will not convince a song with "Nobody" is anything above a 1.5 But since it was previously mentioned if this was a SOAD comp they'd both get pubstomped
Storm In A Teacup 06.07.23	@arsfriendiendi no not all
JDubb 06.13.23	Loved their first album, but SOAD doesn’t compare to either the Knot or A7X for discography
mryrtmrnfoxxxy 06.13.23	if this was a SOAD comp they'd both get pubstomped [2]
anarchistfish 06.13.23	Slipknot
bellovddd 07.18.23	slipknot had at least one good album... A7X.... well.
Emim 07.18.23	Let's rate them based off their fan base in which case they both lose
bellovddd 07.18.23	^hard agree there.
SMOKEDOPE 07.18.23	this is an epic battle of the millennium