mkmusic1995
03.22.23 | The almost complete lack of love for "Red Right Hand" and songs off of 'Your Funeral My Trial' surprised me quite a bit! Hope you guys enjoy! |
JohnnyoftheWell
03.22.23 | this is not a disaster
too few from Tender Prey / poor showing from NMSWP / ig no Hollywood, but otherwise tight? |
GhandhiLion
03.22.23 | Decent results other than the Ghosteen song |
Colton
03.22.23 | 30 is 1 |
Colton
03.22.23 | but it's hard to rank an artist of perpetual 3.4/5s |
Pangea
03.22.23 | i don't really get the o children love but nice picks all around. I love the diverse picks and good album representation! |
porcupinetheater
03.22.23 | Wild seeing more tracks off The Good Son than any other record, and 3 in the top 10
Dig the suprisingly good showing from PtSA though |
TalonsOfFire
03.22.23 | I guess pretty good representation of their career, even if there’re too many earlier tracks for my taste. But my top 5, maybe even top 10 are all here so that’s nice. Mercy Seat is a worthy #1, transcendent and amazing song. |
EyesWideShut
03.23.23 | A man of too many classics but damn Millhaven is by far one of my least fav Cave songs. Omalleys Bar, Kindness of Strangers >>> |
rabidfish
03.23.23 | what? it's mostly songs from tender pray and the good son, that's kinda biased as fuck. |
Gyromania
03.23.23 | we no who u r forever underrated |
EyesWideShut
03.23.23 | As I Sat Sadly By Her Side |
Pangea
03.23.23 | why are you singling out tender prey rabid? debut, push the sky away and skeleton tree all have 3 tracks as well. the good son is the only album with more than 3 tracks (which kinda suprises me, didn't think that album in particular would get the most love) so i think it's pretty well balanced generally |
Demon of the Fall
03.23.23 | having only heard the Tender Prey through to Let Love In era (plus Dig / Ghosteen, briefly) Henry's Dream looks a little under-represented here, no? |
Demon of the Fall
03.23.23 | although I'm currently experiencing the eternal ongoing struggle of actually ranking anything / haven't even rated any of these 4 albums yet - all rather good at least |
mkmusic1995
03.23.23 | I agree with those that are surprised to see so many 'The Good Son' songs in the top ten. I didn't realize people loved that record so much. |
GhandhiLion
03.23.23 | Rightfully so |
mkmusic1995
03.23.23 | It is fantastic for sure |
porcupinetheater
03.23.23 | Good Son is prob bottom 4 Cave albums tbh, along with Dig / Kicking / Nocturama |
porcupinetheater
03.23.23 | Also a bit surprised that Loom of the Land got the nod over John Finn’s Wife / Straight to You
All are stellar though |
mkmusic1995
03.23.23 | I was shocked that Straight To You wasn't near the top as well. Seems like an essential listen for most Cave fans |
deathofasalesman
03.23.23 | some pretty bad takes in these comments yea
:] |
GhandhiLion
03.23.23 | Yeah good son is easily top 3 |
EyesWideShut
03.24.23 | Good Son is probably top 1 |
Demon of the Fall
03.24.23 | Good Son is officially #1 out of the 6 Cave's I've heard to be fair, although tomorrow it'll be Henry's Dream or Let Love In again |
mkmusic1995
03.24.23 | Good Son is probably top 4 for me
|
TalonsOfFire
03.24.23 | Good Son is excellent, one of their better albums, but not sure it’d make my top 5. Especially considering tracks 6-8. I’m surprised Straight to You and Sat By her Side aren’t here, totally deserving. |
Demon of the Fall
03.24.23 | What’s wrong with Lament? |
TalonsOfFire
03.24.23 | Nothing, Lament is great actually, it’s more the other 2. |
