Ryus
03.08.23 | not expecting a lot of love for this ranking |
JohnnyoftheWell
03.08.23 | shit band, but agree with the order of everything i know here (drop MPP to Time Skiffs level and it's a smash)
might try 3 or 5 at some point |
Ryus
03.08.23 | its americana u wouldnt get it u bong
i could see 3 getting a jotw 3.9 |
Pheromone
03.08.23 | ryus where r u from |
Ryus
03.08.23 | nyc |
Pheromone
03.08.23 | do ars n roberts ever invite u round for tea |
WeepingBanana
03.08.23 | Band is horrible but 9 was always my fav |
Ryus
03.08.23 | @phero i tragically moved away and will be moving even farther away soon |
tectactoe
03.08.23 | 9 so low hurts my soul but it's good seeing 1 so high. |
SomeCallMeTim
03.08.23 | I see you liked their freak-folk-ier side
1 has some of my favs on it, just an awkward album |
fogza
03.08.23 | i like 9 it's good on melba toast |
Ryus
03.08.23 | idk what that is i thought we had already established this was an american thread
|
DoofDoof
03.08.23 | 9 is 1
Fall Be Kind would be top 4 too |
Ryus
03.08.23 | damn yall really love 9 that much
honestly it kinda feels like an awkward transition album to me. still like it but i dont think i'll ever love it. for reverend green is maybe the only amazing song on it. peacebone and fireworks are overrated imo.
and yeah fall be kind is definitely amazing, certainly my favorite of their EPs. it would probably come in 3rd or 4th for me |
fogza
03.08.23 | you would love melba toast Ryus unless you wouldn't. |
Ryus
03.08.23 | it looks like zwieback and ive used that in pie crust before and it is good |
fogza
03.08.23 | if you like crispness then melba toast is your bag |
izakaya
03.08.23 | "shit band" no u.
spirit > feels > SJ are top 3. want to like Ark and CS way more than I actually do. |
Ryus
03.08.23 | i respect spirit as a top pick, it may be the one album of theirs that still feels like it has some growing to do for me. |
izakaya
03.08.23 | spirit definitely took a while to click but yeah when it did was a clear favourite. once you get used to the lo-fi sound, it's got some of their catchiest and most heartfelt stuff.
listened to it daily on walks in lockdown last year. |
foxblood
03.08.23 | good ranking honestly, never heard 10 and 11 but I assume there is no reason to. 2 is probably 1 but any of the top 4 could be 1 |
Ryus
03.08.23 | 10 has some great tracks but definitely not one i'll be listening to often. particularly like "cherokee" |
Veldin
03.08.23 | Happy to see Centipede higher up, but Strawberry Jam seems remarbkly low |
YoYoMancuso
03.08.23 | 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, and 11 are all 11 |
Ryus
03.08.23 | best band agreed |
Jasdevi087
03.11.23 | Ryus while I am willing to forgive any and all transgressions for having Campfire Songs so high, I need you to accept that we are living in a Strawberry Jam supremacy universe and you must immediately move it above centipede hz |
Ryus
03.13.23 | i didnt realize the strawberry jam cohort had this many members |
Jasdevi087
03.13.23 | we are legion |
