DavidYowi
04.21.20 | The best thing about TDEP is that no one can agree on which album is their best. Every list I've encountered has been radically different from one another.
My ranking:
1. Dissociation
2. Miss Machine
3. One of Us Is the Killer
4. Calculating Infinity
5. Option Paralysis
6. Ire Works |
JokineAugustus
04.21.20 | Almost the total opposite order for me |
Emim
04.21.20 | I can't imagine putting Calculating Infinty last |
JokineAugustus
04.21.20 | Yeah I can't either. It's still their best |
Wildcardbitchesss
04.21.20 | Last for me too tbh.
The band went on to do much better things imo.
And yeah that’s the marks of a great band, there’s no definitive ranking. Not many bands can make consistently great music while evolving with more with each release for 20 years straight. |
UglyFace
04.21.20 | I would put Calculating at the top and Option at the bottom... the rest are hard for me to work out. |
JokineAugustus
04.21.20 | I think One of Us is far and away their worst. |
deathschool
04.21.20 | 1 is the worst one!! |
JokineAugustus
04.21.20 | CI>IW>OP>IRONY>MM>>>>>>>>>>>>>OOUITK |
el_newg
04.21.20 | good band |
DDconjoined
04.21.20 | To be fair, he had these all ranked 8-10. I think it is pretty close, but I love Ire Works and Option above the rest. Such a great band, lucky to have seen them down in Tasmania on their final run. |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.21.20 | Swap 1 and 6, and this looks acceptable. Phone Home for fave on MM is a weird take lol |
Wildcardbitchesss
04.21.20 | so is Horse Hunter. I love the song but Mouth of Ghosts is always gonna be my favorite on Ire Works. |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.21.20 | Nah Horse Hunter fking rips, that track is an easy top 5 on Ire |
JokineAugustus
04.21.20 | The Runnin Board > 43% burnt |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.21.20 | ^good take
4th Grade Dropout>either |
BenThatsMyJamin
04.21.20 | Band is so good I could always see any album being considered 'best' on any given day EXCEPT for One of Us |
cold
04.21.20 | Delete this user |
Demon of the Fall
04.21.20 | If it wasn’t for the included scores, I would’ve assumed you hit ‘reverse order’ by mistake. Nice to hear a different perspective though.
CI > OP > MM > IW > Dis > OOU
One of Us is the only album of theirs I actively don’t like. |
AxeToFall93
04.21.20 | Dis > OOUITK > OP > MM > CI > IW
How can someone not like One of us? |
botb
04.21.20 | One of us is easily their worst album but it’s not a bad album |
StarlessCore
04.21.20 | terrible ranking, like absolutely terrible |
Ziggity
04.21.20 | Demon with that spot on ranking. |
JokineAugustus
04.21.20 | All these horrible Ire Works rankings |
conesmoke
04.21.20 | Such a consistent band... I think CI is my fave. It's not fair though because CI is the outlier in terms of style |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.21.20 | has this been deleted yet
demon done good, don't fully agree but also that should be written in the stars as word and truth
One of us is easily their worst album but it’s not a bad album [2] (apart from ire is worse psst)
|
Wildcardbitchesss
04.21.20 | Dissociation > Option Paralysis > Ire Works > Miss Machine > OOUITK > Calc
|
