IAmScott
11.26.19 | Go see 6 live and you'll change your mind in about 6 minutes.
Would agree on 2 and 3 tho |
DDDeftoneDDD
11.26.19 | I don't get the hype of 1 for sure.
2 is not really a hype..I think for lovers of the genre it can go from 3.5 to 4...but nothing more...it just delivers imo...
3 is brilliant...I'd get the hype even if it wasn t my type of thing.
4 I get that you don t get the hype...
Never listened to 5.
I dont get the hype of 6 too...but ok...I surrendered to ppl who enjoy (unlike 1)
|
cold
11.26.19 | Hype deez nuts |
alamo
11.26.19 | simple all these bring high levels of tonal musicality |
Demon of the Fall
11.26.19 | Are some of these even that hyped here, particularly looking at 1 and 2? Architects' averages aren't exactly blossoming.
Agreed hard with 6. I really like 3. I can see why people like 4. |
madrigal30
11.26.19 | agreed on 1 and 3 but the rest are cool |
DoofDoof
11.26.19 | I struggle with 4 too |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.26.19 | 3 is a mathcore band playing post-rock and is pretty good for what it is but a little overhyped. Goes hard live though and the band's discog is really fun
4 you can take or leave, Chelsea Wolfe doing doomy things with an acoustic guitar is Chelsea Wolfe doing doomy things with an acoustic guitar
6 is one of the more overrated albums here in the last few years. Some great ideas and sounds and an excellent step for that band *on paper* but the stakes and suspense aren't there unless you're the kinda person who considers the Seer to be actively unsettling or whatever |
madrigal30
11.26.19 | i mean, it's physically unnerving to people who aren't much into noise/whatever-you-want-to-call-it. it was my first experience with the genre and i lve it, it's more on the nose and active than the Seer so idk if that's a great comparison |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.26.19 | Oh yeah, I'm glad it's given that kind of atmosphere and sound palette wider exposure! Think good things can come of certain albums being overrated for sure. The Seer is mainly a point of comparison bc I'm similarly indifferent to much of its creepiness and austerity |
AnimalsAsSummit
11.26.19 | if i made this it would be 1000 artists long or more. im done trying to understand this site. |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.26.19 | I would enjoy reading that list tbh |
DoofDoof
11.26.19 | 1. Brand New
2. Weezer
3. Coldplay
4. Thank You Scientist
5. Dance Gavin Dance
...and on and on
yeah it would be easy |
butt.
11.26.19 | 4 and 6 ruuuuuuuule |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.26.19 | Are Coldplay and DCD really that rated here though? |
butt.
11.26.19 | dance cavin dance |
botb
11.26.19 | 1 was good until post hollow crown, now they’ve written the same album like 6 times.
2 is actual ass
3 and 4 slap
5 hasn’t done anything listenable since 2015 imo
6 is amazing |
Josh D.
11.26.19 | pretty much agree with the list |
butt.
11.26.19 | never understood the love for 3. never. |
Relinquished
11.26.19 | I wonder if it's cuz of all of the previous records these had all released prior to accrue cred and love |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.26.19 | 3 is a more expansive and less exciting version of Grievances which is, by virtue of Sput logic, underhyped :[
(wow ninja post Wolfe, basically agreed) |
Relinquished
11.26.19 | >lists the records he doesn't "love"
>wonders why they're "overrated"
>lumps in the artists/bands in the as equally "overrated"
>ignores context |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.26.19 | Oh fek the description says "Some [B]artists[/B] I think sputnikers overrate" list is silly and I am more silly for not reading it why can't descriptions have larger fonts dammit mx |
DoofDoof
11.26.19 | someone's upset |
Relinquished
11.26.19 | prob your mom wondering why you don't call more often |
cazzill
11.26.19 | I suppose I mean just overall overrated rather than just sputnik but still.
Out of all the new wave of hardcore bands, Knocked Loose for me are the least compelling. I'm fairly certain their guitarist is in Inclination as well who I think are by far better.
The love for that Rolo Tomassi album will forever be a mystery to me.
|
DoofDoof
11.26.19 | surely you were supposed to say 'prob your mom wondering why I don't call more often'
either way, top marks |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.26.19 | gentlemen please |
Relinquished
11.26.19 | I wanted to go for straight guilt than a high school school jab |
StarlessCore
11.26.19 | Agreed all r whack |
Relinquished
11.26.19 | I see you slandering my name frogmaster |
Tundra
11.26.19 | agree with 1, 5 and 6, disagree with the rest |
Egarran
11.26.19 | Birth of Violence has some dead zones, but Hiss Spun is so good.
Agree with the rest. |
Pikazilla
11.26.19 | Chelsea Wolfe and Daughters are amazing. Fuck the rest. |
Drifter
11.26.19 | Agreed on 5 |
butt.
11.26.19 | pika finally types a true and coherent sentence |
JeetJeet
11.26.19 | Definitely agree with 6. The hype for 5 used to be warranted tho but Earl has been on some bullshit lately. |
butt.
11.26.19 | jeet once again types a false and incoherent sentence |
SteakByrnes
11.26.19 | Jeet is that boi do not slander him you arrogant fool |
JeetJeet
11.26.19 | lol Steak its fine. He listens to Lil Nas X so its not like his opinion really matters. |
hal1ax
11.26.19 | agree on 6 for sure. shit bores me |
Zorg
11.26.19 | 6 feels like The Jesus Lizard rehashed. |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.26.19 | Incredibly wrong take but also the Jesus Lizard >>> Daughters so whatever |
GhandhiLion
11.26.19 | @Zorg
I'm a JL fan and I strongly disagree. Daughters are as similar to JL, as JL are to the Birthday Party. |
Sinternet
11.26.19 | wahh everything i don't like personally is overrated |
Sinternet
11.26.19 | literally the stupidest fucking word in the english language |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.26.19 | Liking something personally must be fun
*sniff* |
Sinternet
11.26.19 | neck yourself if you use that word unironically |
GhandhiLion
11.26.19 | ironically |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.26.19 | 1. Irony
2. Art-pop
3. Pretentious
4. Overrated
5. Melodic
6. Objective/subjective
7. Neck
8. Nice
9. Tonal
10. Experimental/complexity
there's a top 10 for most abused words for y'all in which context sint overrated overrated nice |
GhandhiLion
11.26.19 | where is nice? |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.26.19 | amended |
hal1ax
11.26.19 | Where is ‘objectively / objective’ |
botb
11.26.19 | Also needs “avant-garde” |
Sinternet
11.26.19 | 3 is 1
4 is 2 |
Sinternet
11.26.19 | avant-garde/experimental yeah |
butt.
11.26.19 | every word on that list
is overrated |
Zorg
11.26.19 | It's mostly the vocals, I hear Yow in them. |
JohnnyoftheWell
11.26.19 | Art-pop is the new avant garde but experimental yes fairs |
Source
11.26.19 | good list. could use about 50 other entries but yeah |
GhandhiLion
11.26.19 | How is art pop abused? |
BallsToTheWall
11.26.19 | 2 and 3 slap hard af. Definitely Wolfe’s weakest. |
garas
11.26.19 | Good list. |
Tyler.
11.26.19 | 5.0 classic
Cult of Luna and Julie Christmas Mariner
Danny Brown XXX
Deftones Around the Fur
Fever Ray Fever Ray
Five Pointe O Untitled
GZA Liquid Swords
Iron Maiden The Number of the Beast
Linkin Park Hybrid Theory
Method Man Tical
Nirvana MTV Unplugged in New York (DVD)
Nirvana MTV Unplugged in New York
Rage Against The Machine Rage Against The Machine |
dbizzles
11.26.19 | B O D I E D |
Cimnele
11.26.19 | amended |
cazzill
11.26.19 | You admiring my 5's Tyler? |
dbizzles
11.26.19 | Yes. That's what he is doing. |
brainmelter
11.26.19 | High levels of admiration |
SteakByrnes
11.26.19 | Sugar Ray > Fever Ray |
onionbubs
11.26.19 | 6 bad |
GhandhiLion
11.26.19 | Sister Ray>> |
Source
11.26.19 | billy ray cyrus>>> |
Zorg
11.26.19 | Naked Raygun >>>> |
Source
11.26.19 | talk talk>>>>> |
Pikazilla
11.26.19 | 3 is fucking trash agreed |
Zorg
11.26.19 | "talk talk>>>>>"
That aint it. |
JayEnder
11.26.19 | https://youtu.be/yFYz9W_ErhM
You might change your mind on 6 after watching this. |
sonictheplumber
11.27.19 | never heard of em |
Morningrise767
11.28.19 | None of these artists are "that" hyped tho |
Egarran
11.28.19 | ^ctrl+f sinternet |
wutang4ever
11.28.19 | doesnt the word "hype" imply that the albums listed are popular? |
