Friday13th
07.25.19 | Voting ends Saturday! |
TheNotrap
07.25.19 | Wobbler is my winner
Congrats to all prog mates |
Friday13th
07.25.19 | It's a tough one for sure. Both are high 4s which I'm tempted to give a 4.5. However, I think Pulsar is the more original of the two, so I'm voting Pulsar.
1-1
Friday
Notrap |
e210013
07.25.19 | Wow, what an unexpected vote my friend. I always thought that Goliath would beat David easily. Lol.
Still, I never thought that before. But maybe you're right. "Halloween" is undoubtedly a true original album. Now that I'm thinking about it that is probably why I always felt a big and "strange" fascination by it.
You will make me listen to both albums again before my last decision. Besides, I rated both albums with 4.5. |
Divaman
07.25.19 | Two truly worthy finalists. I'm excited to see how it plays out. I need to give both another listen, as I'm still totally sure which way I want to go. |
Jethro42
07.25.19 | That was the outcome I was expecting. Good luck to both of the finalists!... |
SharkTooth
07.25.19 | Wobbler by far |
Friday13th
07.25.19 | 1-2
Friday
Notrap
Sharktooth |
Zig
07.26.19 | I have to go with Pulsar, those classical qualities really got me. |
Friday13th
07.26.19 | 2-2
Friday
Zig
Notrap
Sharktooth |
MrSirLordGentleman
07.26.19 | I'll go with Wobbler |
Friday13th
07.26.19 | 2-3
Friday
Zig
Notrap
Sharktooth
Gentleman |
Divaman
07.26.19 | It's not an easy call, but I have to go with Wobbler. |
Friday13th
07.26.19 | 2-4
Friday
Zig
Notrap
Sharktooth
Gentleman
Divaman |
e210013
07.26.19 | It's not an easy call because both albums are great. But once I always loved the mystery, the dark mood and the classical influence on "Halloween" I must choose Pulsar's album. Besides, I can't betray an album that always gave me great pleasure and that was chosen by me as my knight and that so brilliantly reached the final. |
Friday13th
07.26.19 | 3-4
Friday
Zig
e21
Notrap
Sharktooth
Gentleman
Divaman |
Jethro42
07.27.19 | I still think From Silence To Somewhere is very busy, and sometimes too many layers interlace, and it almost provokes conflicts between instruments themselves and/or vocals. We can hardly breathe in places. The approach of the band is vintage's era symphonic prog, but they don't reinvent anything, and they insist for too long for each themes we can find.
I have more pleasure to listen to Halloween as a whole. It got an ethereal atmosphere, it's dark, haunting and has a dreamy nature, and i'm more used to that album. it's more of an easy listen with a constant suspense for intriguing outcomes. I think Pulsar might be influenced by Genesis, and Gazpacho might be influenced by Pulsar.
At first. I thouhgt I would choose Wobbler, but Pulsar has more replay value for me. Wobbler is a fantastic band for their structures, musicianship and execution,but it's like they have not enough room to content all the music notes.
i'm choosing Halloween. |
Friday13th
07.27.19 | 4-4
Friday
Zig
e21
Jethro
Notrap
Sharktooth
Gentleman
Divaman |
MrSirLordGentleman
07.27.19 | I didn't expect this to be a tough match tbh |
bgillesp
07.27.19 | Easy vote for 2 this time |
Friday13th
07.27.19 | 4-5
Friday
Zig
e21
Jethro
Notrap
Sharktooth
Gentleman
Divaman
bgill |
TwigTW
07.27.19 | I’m really not sure which to choose. I'll give them a quick spin and report back shortly. |
hansoloshotfirst
07.27.19 | my vote goes to Pulsar. |
Friday13th
07.27.19 | 5-5
Friday
Zig
e21
Jethro
hansolo
Notrap
Sharktooth
Gentleman
Divaman
bgill |
TwigTW
07.27.19 | Ok, I'm going with Wobbler (shocking, I know). |
Friday13th
07.27.19 | 5-6
Friday
Zig
e21
Jethro
hansolo
Notrap
Sharktooth
Gentleman
Divaman
bgill
Twig |
Divaman
07.27.19 | Very close. After a couple of rounds of coasting, we're experiencing Woblash. |
Casavir
07.27.19 | Gonna go with Pulsar but it was close. |
Friday13th
07.27.19 | 6-6
Friday
Zig
e21
Jethro
hansolo
Casavir
Notrap
Sharktooth
Gentleman
Divaman
bgill
Twig
We have a nail-biter! |
TheIntruder
07.27.19 | Tough decision. Great final. It was close but I go with Pulsar. |
Divaman
07.27.19 | Not sure if we're going to get Papa's vote this time. He's been MIA since the beginning of the week. |
Friday13th
07.28.19 | 7-6
Friday
Zig
e21
Jethro
hansolo
Casavir
Intruder
Notrap
Sharktooth
Gentleman
Divaman
bgill
Twig |
Sabrutin
07.28.19 | Tough to compare albums with such different natures. Pulsar's is more unique but right now I can't help being more captured by Wobbler's tightness. So I'm voting for Foxlight. I mean, Wobbler. |
Friday13th
07.28.19 | 7-7
Friday
Zig
e21
Jethro
hansolo
Casavir
Intruder
Notrap
Sharktooth
Gentleman
Divaman
bgill
Twig
Sabrutin |
Friday13th
07.28.19 | Hey guys, I'm going to leave town tomorrow, so we really need to settle this today! |
Scheumke
07.29.19 | I vote wobbler! Did that vote break the stalemate here or am I too late? Sick how close this finals is. |
Friday13th
07.29.19 | 7-8
Friday
Zig
e21
Jethro
hansolo
Casavir
Intruder
Notrap
Sharktooth
Gentleman
Divaman
bgill
Twig
Sabrutin
Scheumke
Could be the tiebreaker! I'm gonna be on the road most of today, but I'll accept any votes by the end of today and then I'll call it. |
Divaman
07.29.19 | Going somewhere good, Friday? |
wham49
07.29.19 | sorry thought I already did. I go with Wobbler. hard call, Pulsar has grown on me |
Friday13th
07.29.19 | 7-9
Friday
Zig
e21
Jethro
hansolo
Casavir
Intruder
Notrap
Sharktooth
Gentleman
Divaman
bgill
Twig
Sabrutin
Scheumke
wham
@Divaman nah, I'm taking the bar exam out of state.
|
Divaman
07.29.19 | Oh. Well good luck w/that. My bro is a lawyer. |
Papa Universe
07.29.19 | I'm back and I'm Wobbler. |
Divaman
07.29.19 | There you are, you lovable lug! I thought you had another fracking heart attack. Very happy you're back. |
Friday13th
07.30.19 | I think that's the final blow, Papa!
7-10
Wobbler is the WINNER! |
Papa Universe
07.30.19 | Finally someone who deserves it. |
e210013
07.30.19 | Yeah, finally someone who deserves it. Personally, I think it fit well on both. These are the only two albums I gave 4.5. Still, due to it overwhelming route and its amazing quality, Wobbler is a great and fair winner.
Congrats Gentleman. Great choice pal. Cheers. |
TwigTW
07.30.19 | Damn, posted in the wrong thread... |