Doibhin69
11.20.18 | ik this has been discussed tons of times before but these albums are on my mind right now so I couldn't resist. Pet Sounds for me but beatles are a far superior band with a better discography imo |
Minushuman24
11.20.18 | Pet Sounds for sure. If it were Magical Mystery Tour, it would be a different story. |
ArsMoriendi
11.20.18 | Sgt. Peppers < Pet Sounds < Magical Mystery Tour < Smiley Smile
I wish other people loved Smiley Smile the way that I do |
J() Alexander
11.20.18 | Pet Sounds. |
Minushuman24
11.20.18 | I gotta resume my Beach Boys run through, stopped after Pet Sounds. |
deathschool
11.20.18 | Pet Sounds [6900] |
SandwichBubble
11.20.18 | Pet Sounds [∞] |
Doibhin69
11.20.18 | The Smile Sessions > Smiley Smile |
TheLongShot
11.20.18 | Pet Sounds is a hard 5, Sgt. Pepper is in the 4.5-5 range but I round up because I’m overly generous when it comes to Beatles albums (: |
Hendoi
11.20.18 | I prefer Sgt Peppers as an album but Wouldn't It Be Nice, God Only Knows & Caroline, No are some of my favourite songs ever written. |
Drifter
11.20.18 | Sgt Pepper |
Frippertronics
11.20.18 | Pet Sounds and it ain't even a contest |
Flugmorph
11.20.18 | pet sounds is the woke snob pick so ill go with that |
naughtcturnal
11.20.18 | pet sounds |
Storm In A Teacup
11.20.18 | Both are good but Sgt Pepper |
Royl123
11.20.18 | Pet sounds |
BigPleb
11.20.18 | Sgt Pepper's and it ain't even a contest |
Doibhin69
11.20.18 | oh btw you guys i'm going to edit my other lists and count votes for them when I can |
Mendross
11.20.18 | Pet sounds |
bach
11.20.18 | Pet sounds you can’t disagree |
zakalwe
11.20.18 | Peppers |
Mendross
11.20.18 | Come on. The harmonies... endlessly and original hahaha |
manosg
11.20.18 | Sgt Pepper's |
Trifolium
11.20.18 | Sgt Pepper's and it ain't even a contest [2] |
Zig
11.20.18 | Pet Sounds |
DominionMM1
11.20.18 | pepper |
Sowing
11.20.18 | sgt pepper |
Rowan5215
11.20.18 | shouldn't we compare with the actual best Beatles album to make this fair? cos otherwise Pet Sounds takes it by a landslide |
Trifolium
11.20.18 | Agreed, it's not even their best. Still better than Pet Shop Sounds for me though. |
Dylan620
11.20.18 | Pet Sounds |
guitarded_chuck
11.20.18 | pet sounds is the woke snob pick so ill go with that [∞] |
BerryGarlicia
11.20.18 | beach boys suck the most ass ive ever heard
so sgt peppers |
Divaman
11.20.18 | Sgt Pepper |
Doibhin69
11.20.18 | Votes so far if more come. I thought sgt peppers was going to win honestly. |
Sinternet
11.20.18 | easily pet sounds on the strength of it's musical quality
i'd argue pepper's is the more important album in history though |
Winesburgohio
11.20.18 | Pet Sounds |
mandan
11.20.18 | I haven't heard Pet Sounds in full (as far as I recall), so can't really make a fair vote.
Beach Boys don't seem to be my kinda music though, I prob like the Beatles more (although most likely I've never heard a full BB album). |
TheLongShot
11.20.18 | "i'd argue pepper's is the more important album in history though"
Probably an accurate statement, although Pet Sounds definitely inspired several songs off of Revolver and likely was part of what gave the Fab Four the push to create Sgt. Pepper-like material in the first place |
ArsMoriendi
11.21.18 | "The Smile Sessions > Smiley Smile"
Common opinion, but I strongly disagree |
Doibhin69
11.21.18 | I was thinking Rubber Soul vs Pet Sounds but this makes more sense I think |
Friday13th
11.21.18 | Pet Sounds
|
Amiracle94
01.07.19 | Sgt. Pepper's is an excellent album but it has a few weak spots that hold it back imo.
I relate much more to Brian Wilson's introspective lyrics and the emotion, unorthodox production and harmonies on Pet Sounds are something that remain unmatched to this day. Pet Sounds is one for the ages.
I am also very biased because Pet Sounds is my favorite album of all time.
Therefore, Pet Sounds. |
theNateman
02.17.19 | [2] pet sounds is G.O.A.T.P. |