Doibhin69
09.12.18 | My favorite Radiohead album is Kid A regardless. |
ramon.
09.12.18 | effigy of the forgotten |
calmrose
09.12.18 | OK Computer easily |
Flashmobba
09.12.18 | description [2]
super super close though |
Larkinhill
09.12.18 | Siamese Dream. Love OK Computer though. But it was an easy choice tbh. |
neekafat
09.12.18 | Smashing Pumpkins are like one of my favorite bands but OK Computer is def better
if it was Mellon Collie vs OK Computer that'd be harder for me tbh but OK Computer is just so fucking consistently awesome |
Kompys2000
09.12.18 | Uhh Probably Siamese Dream over OK Computer, but Radiohead over Smashing Pumpkins overall |
engleprunt
09.12.18 | Siamese Dream for shozen |
Opturus
09.12.18 | what a weird versus
OK Computer obviously though |
Wubs
09.12.18 | Haven't even heard Siamese Dream, but I pretty much know Ok Comp is best. |
davesthesay
09.12.18 | Siamese Dream is a brilliant 90s album, but OK Computer is timeless. |
Zeuzo
09.12.18 | lmao OKC no comparison |
sixdegrees
09.12.18 | siamese dream |
CugnoBrasso
09.12.18 | I would definitely choose Mellon Collie over OK Computer, but in this case OK Computer wins. |
BenThatsMyJamin
09.12.18 | Siamese Dream is probably more people's personal choice (in an 'In Rainbows' kinda way) but OKC is the objective winner really |
SymbolicInTime
09.12.18 | I never understood the appeal of Siamese Dream. It was very okay. Cherub rock and Today rip but |
Larkinhill
09.12.18 | Very okay??? What about Soma, Geek USA and (especially) Mayonaise??? |
50iL
09.12.18 | Siamese for me |
Larkinhill
09.12.18 | Mellon Collie trumps both though (but still only slightly). |
guitarded_chuck
09.12.18 | siamese dream |
SymbolicInTime
09.12.18 | Mayonnaise and Greek USA are alright. Don’t really like Soma. It’s not that I dislike that album by any means, just never personally understood what made it a classic.
|
Disorderly
09.12.18 | Hmmm. Probably Siamese personally, but OK Computer is the better album. Silverfuck sucks. |
DaarrthVadr
09.12.18 | OK Computer all the way. |
Kompys2000
09.12.18 | "Silverfuck sucks"
I mean it's the best song on the album but okay. |
StallionMang
09.12.18 | ok computer by default bc it doesn't have a song as bad as disarm |
BenThatsMyJamin
09.12.18 | ^real talk |
Larkinhill
09.12.18 | @Stallion and Ben Disarm is fucking great wtf?!
@Disorderly and Kompys Silerfuvk certainly doesn’t suck but definitely not the best on the album. Probably one of the weaker tracks but still great.
@TheWonder man different strokes and all that, but I don’t understand how someone can dislike Soma and think Mayonaise is “just ok”. Mayo is arguably their best song. I usually agree with you on music, so that’s why I’m particularly perplexed here. Do you like Mellon Collie more? Or just don’t get the Pumpkins in general? |
BenThatsMyJamin
09.12.18 | Disarm sucks donkey dick
Nah for real tho I can see how ppl would enjoy it but to call it one of their best songs (as some people do) is a disgrace when you look at some of the masterpieces that exist on that album. It's downright disrespectful. |
ArsMoriendi
09.12.18 | I prefer Siamese Dream by far honestly |
ArsMoriendi
09.12.18 | Geek U.S.A. an Mayonaise are better than any cut off OK Computer |
ArsMoriendi
09.12.18 | OK Computer's closer is better than Siamese Dream's though... |
JoeTex
09.12.18 | okc |
SymbolicInTime
09.12.18 | @Larkin I prefer Mellon Collie, but even most of that album is just okay to me. I just never really “got” the pumpkins, yeah. I haven’t given Mellon Collie a fair spin in several years though so maybe I’ll have to give that one another shot sometime soon. Just spun Siamese a couple months back though. It’s mostly Billy’s voice, honestly. |
iglu
09.12.18 | I probably play SD more than OK rn but I'd still go with OK Computer |
butcherboy
09.12.18 | Jesus Lizard - Goat |
Doibhin69
09.12.18 | soma or mayonaise are best songs on SD easily |
Artuma
09.12.18 | ok computer, not a hard choice |
Kompys2000
09.12.18 | Butch coming in with some cold hard facts |
TheCharmingMan
09.12.18 | butch [3] |
Log S.
09.12.18 | Holy fuck some awful opinions in this thread
In any case, this thread is my second favorite album of all time versus my third |
Log S.
09.12.18 | (Siamese Dream) |
Dylan620
09.12.18 | OK Computer but Siamese is an all time top 20'er |
Log S.
09.12.18 | "OK Computer's closer is better than Siamese Dream's though..."
Hard disagree
Luna is one of the purest songs in their entire catalog. Beautiful song |
Dylan620
09.12.18 | "Luna" is perfect yeah |
Larkinhill
09.12.18 | @ Log S what’s your number 1 album? |
butcherboy
09.12.18 | if those two are his second and third, then nevermind is obviously #1.. account could be an mtv bot.. |
StallionMang
09.12.18 | "OK Computer's closer is better than Siamese Dream's though..."
luna is one of the best songs on its album, the tourist is one of the weakest |
SitarHero
09.12.18 | Siamese Dream fosho. |
Nero
09.12.18 | Siamese dream no doubt |
Log S.
09.12.18 | Nevermind's not even my favorite Nirvana record, lol
In any case, the Japanese version of this album is the shit - it's got Pissant at then end & individual pages devoted to those postcards that were sized down to fit 2 panels in the US pressing |
Log S.
09.12.18 | to be honest I hold onto SD for largely sentimental reasons since it (along with OKC) had a HUGE influence on what I went on to listen to/look for in music then afterward - there are albums I'm currently enjoying more than both but I gotta give credit to both on my all-time lists & whatnot, and sentimentality or not the record kicks ass |
Larkinhill
09.12.18 | And what’s your number one though? |
DrMaximus
09.12.18 | Siamese Computer |
dunnope
09.12.18 | Mellon collie |
neekafat
09.12.18 | Don't forget Disarm y'all |
CugnoBrasso
09.12.18 | Zeitgeist vs pablo honey tho |
Doibhin69
09.12.18 | zeitgeist is fucking terrible although jimmy's drumming is great as usual |
Disorderly
09.14.18 | @Kompys2000 Hell no. On no planet is that the best song on the album. There are so many better songs: Mayonaise, Soma, Disarm, Geek U.S.A., Luna, Cherub Rock, and basically everything else. That song could've been awesome. It had a great riff, but they drag the song on for too long, and that "Bang, bang, you’re dead, hole in your head" section is awful. It's easily the worst song on the album, which is actually one of my favorites. |
onionbubs
09.14.18 | neither is the band’s best but i guess okc |
Kompys2000
09.14.18 | @Disorderly Agree to disagree I guess. I could listen to the main riff for an hour and not get bored, and those drum fills kick more ass than anything that has ever kicked ass. I also don't mind the "bang, bang, you're dead" bit, though I can for sure see why some people hate it. |
Disorderly
09.14.18 | @Kompys2000 Yeah, the riff does kick ass, and Jimmy puts on a great performance. If it had been a 5 minute song, it would be a highlight for me, but it's just too long. :/ |
wham49
09.18.18 | SD of these 2, in rainbows crushed though |
Amiracle94
01.07.19 | Despite Radiohead being my favorite artist, I've always felt that OK Computer was a bit overrated. In Rainbows, Kid A and A Moon Shaped Pool are all better than it imo. Siamese Dream never fails to make me feel alive whenever I listen to it. The guitarwork is just so warm and fuzzy that I start to feel warm and fuzzy. In short, Siamese Dream. |