Casavir
04.10.18 | I sat on this one for a while. |
mrdogthrow
04.10.18 | i always laugh at the kitty at 9 hahahahah look at that dumb cat |
Casavir
04.10.18 | Yeah, it looks pretty derpy. Doesn't make the music anymore bearable, unfortunately. |
TheSonomaDude
04.10.18 | Pantera rankings are pretty diverse. I have always loved 7 tbh |
HarryBoBerry
04.10.18 | Interesting ranking, but you explained yourself very well. I'll have to give #1 a shot. |
Casavir
04.10.18 | They tend to be. Thoughts on the rest of the ranking? |
TheSonomaDude
04.10.18 | I honestly appreciate 1 being where it is. it's an underrated gem for sure
excluding their first three, i'd prob rank my Pantera as RTS>CFH>PM>VDoP>FBD>TGST |
Thalassic
04.10.18 | Good explanations.
I've been known to highly enjoy quite a bit this band put out. Can't help it. |
Casavir
04.10.18 | I remember listening to this after hearing a bunch of people talk about how bad it is and my entire first listen was just me waiting for it to suck only to discover that it's actually great. |
Doctuses
04.10.18 | pantera is an okay band |
Casavir
04.10.18 | Yeah, the top 3 only barely manage to get a 4 from me but don't make them among the best releases of their respective years for me. Still, I'll give credit where I feel necessary and say when I really liked something. |
Doctuses
04.10.18 | True |
Doctuses
04.10.18 | Praise for 3 at 3. Good album coulda been next level but the slicing of the songs are fucked. Woulda been helpful if they were in the same place when they recorded their parts. Also some of the songs were lazily made and wre generally shitty but suicide notes and floods are tight |
Doctuses
04.10.18 | I also think its hilarious this bands tough guy WALK bravado when they were literally the epitome of gay for 3 albums, whatever ai guess lol |
Casavir
04.10.18 | I find it ridiculous that they just completely ignore Power Metal to this very day. I mean, come on. It's easily among their best work. |
Casavir
04.10.18 | I can't tell you how many times I've run into Vulgar Display fans who refer to Power Metal as glam. It's like they literally started listening to metal the week they got into Pantera. |
TheFantasticDangler
04.10.18 | 'I have no clue as to why anyone would consider this a landmark release for any other reason that reminding the general public that metal exist'
Uhm, what? I have no clue why someone would write off this album that is so clearly loved by so many people and contains multiple classic metal tracks? A New Level, Walk, This Love, Fucking Hostile, is an amazing fucking run of songs. This album goes harder front to back than any other release by them. |
Casavir
04.10.18 | I guess if powerful means "a lack of variety", "boneheaded composition", "uninspired vocals" and "comparatively lacking musicianship", then it's pretty powerful. |
TheFantasticDangler
04.10.18 | Oh, you actually think you're right? Not even a 'w/e too each their own, lots of people obviously love this, just my opinion'. If you find the vocals in Walk, Fucking Hostile and Love 'uninspired' and find they 'lack musicianship' and are 'composed boneheadedly' we're done here lol. Those tracks are Pantera classics, metal classic and your needlessly contrarian opinion won't change that. |
Casavir
04.10.18 | "youre needlessly contrarian opinion won't change that."
lmao |
Casavir
04.10.18 | I find the idea of being "needlessly" contrarian amusing. Like I'm causing some kind of catastrophe to occur because I find an album boring on repeat listens. |
TheFantasticDangler
04.10.18 | catastrophe, nah Im just arguing with some goof on the internet
Like, Fucking Hostile, This Love, and Walk are quintessential Pantera and metal classics so excuse me if I find it funny/kinda outrageous you think theyre bland and unmemorable
|
BallsToTheWall
04.10.18 | 5 rules. |
Doctuses
04.10.18 | Tbh 6 has some bangers and snoozers. OP is right in general its just one sound. |
Doctuses
04.10.18 | And This Love is a semi-gay entity |
budgie
04.10.18 | holy shit 1 is actually 1, for the first time
i love you casavir, you made me smile when i opened this list |
Casavir
04.11.18 | Why, thank you kin-EEEYYAAAA POWAAAH METAAAAAAAHHHLLL! |
Dwap
04.11.18 | 6 is 1 |
TheFantasticDangler
04.11.18 | don't tell him that |
Casavir
04.11.18 | "6 is 1"
If you enjoy mediocrity, then sure.
|
TheSonomaDude
04.11.18 | 6 has some killer riffs but also has some really boring stuff that people seem to forget/ignore. the good shit is really good tho |
TheFantasticDangler
04.11.18 | ^ agreed, but apparently songs like Walk, This Love and Fucking Hostile are pure mediocrity |
TheSonomaDude
04.11.18 | "Regular People" has always been my fave off that album |
TheFantasticDangler
04.11.18 | underrated tune for sure |
Casavir
04.11.18 | It falls flat when compared to the top three here and many other albums in 1992.
I mean, right off the top of my head:
Sadus - A Vision of Misery
Blind Guardian - Somewhere Far Beyond
Dark Millennium - Ashore the Celestial Burden
Mekong Delta - Kaleidoscope
Solitude Aeturnus - Beyond the Crimson Horizon
Depressive Age - First Depression
Psychotic Waltz - Into the Everflow
At the Gates - The Red in the Sky is Ours
Bolt Thrower - The IVth Crusade
Darkthrone - A Blaze in the Northern Sky
W.A.S.P. - The Crimson Idol
Liers in Wait - Spiritually Controlled Art
and on and on and on... |
TheFantasticDangler
04.11.18 | none of those are better, but thats like your opinion, man |
Casavir
04.11.18 | How many of those have you actually listened to? |
TheFantasticDangler
04.11.18 | probably all of them at one point or another
edit: i mean, my metal phase was like from 12 to 20ish so ive fallen out of love/cant remember a loooot of metal ive listened to |
Casavir
04.11.18 | So how can you say that none of them were better for sure? |
Doctuses
04.11.18 | Gotteeeeeeem |
TheFantasticDangler
04.11.18 | the fact that none of them stand out to me anymore, but ill never forget VDoP? |
BigHans
04.11.18 | Seeing 6 where it is makes me want to have a stroke. |
TheFantasticDangler
04.11.18 | reading his write up for it gave me one |
Casavir
04.11.18 | Yeah, there's clearly no such thing as rediscovering albums that you previously didn't consider. |
Casavir
04.11.18 | By the way, I clearly explained which albums it falls short against in that description. |
BigHans
04.11.18 | I haven't heard 5. I like all of 1-7. Vulgar has always just jumped out to me. I love it. Mouth For War and Regular People are two of my favorite metal songs. Walk sucks. |
Casavir
04.11.18 | None of Vulgar Display matches the peaks of those top three for me. |
Doctuses
04.11.18 | Is bighans a reference to peep show? |
budgie
04.12.18 | lol did someone actually say vulgar display of power is a better album than a blaze in the northern sky |
Casavir
04.12.18 | Yes. |
Kompys2000
04.12.18 | Wow yeah 6 is pretty low but CFH and TGST are both in your top 3 so you're good in my book |
Casavir
04.12.18 | What do you think of 1? |
Kompys2000
04.12.18 | 1 is okay- super derivative, but miles better then anything they'd done before.
Also, Darkthrone is hilariously overrated so that's not saying much but yes Vulgar display is better |
Casavir
04.12.18 | Get ou-I mean, I totally respect your opinion. |