bgillesp
02.22.18 | Original Nothing was better to me |
Spec
02.22.18 | I don’t know if it’s legal to make a list like this without “Bleed.” |
BlackwaterPork
02.22.18 | *3 tracks from Nothing including rational gaze*
I like you |
Relinquished
02.22.18 | love that the list has the bookends to DEI, makes it near perfect |
mrend55
02.22.18 | I don’t know if it’s legal to make a list like this without “Bleed.” [2] |
Relinquished
02.22.18 | also how'd you pick close eye visuals over nebulous is beyond me |
Shoegazefan9789
02.23.18 | Demiurge > Nebulous my man |
chug73
02.23.18 | Obzen is a fucking good song.
Why isn't clockworks here.
In Life Is Death also brings the junz |
chug73
02.23.18 | Also 10 years later I cannot work out what is going on in the second verse of Pineal Gland Optics, what is Haake doing. |
Shoegazefan9789
02.23.18 | No catch 33 on here my dude |
chug73
02.23.18 | I agree with Spasm tho, that track is a tripper
some nerd on youtube broke down the snare solo and it's a weird as shit pattern that is symmetrical or something |
BeyondCosby
02.23.18 | I need to check more "old" Meshuggah. I've only really listened to Obzen on. |
chug73
02.23.18 | It's not their best. But it's a damn good album.
When I first got into them I listened to Chaos the most. The production is suffocating. |
Shoegazefan9789
02.23.18 | Yeah Mayhem, Chaosphere is actually my least fav but you can't go wrong with any shug |
chug73
02.23.18 | I think it has Jens best performance and some of the weirdest solos (elastic has some weird as shit solos) but if I had to criticize it I would say it does sound a samey throughout. |
artiswar
02.23.18 | I love you bro but this list is only like 50% of the ultimate Meshuggah album. There isn't even any Catch 33, try again love |
chug73
02.23.18 | This album, in particular, has a samey feel to the songs. Perhaps it is the mechanical as hell production (which sounds awesome) that causes it but something about it just lacks the dynamics they would later play with.
I still think it's solid as hell and has some of their weirdest stuff, just not my fave. |
chug73
02.23.18 | This list needs some catch 33.
I vote In Death Is Death, that riff and solo at :30 is the most meshuggah thing ever |
Shoegazefan9789
02.23.18 | Art my dude, catch33 is some of my fav shit, just read the description and you'll understand why it wasnt included. I was going for a "standard" comp LP |
artiswar
02.23.18 | Just admit that creating an 'ultimate' Meshuggah album is pointless because Catch 33 exists. Why even bother to mix-and-match?? |
Shoegazefan9789
02.23.18 | Imo it doesn't make sense to include passages from C33 and incorporate them into a compilation album. It would do the album an injustice given that it's one song. |
Relinquished
02.23.18 | then explain why Shed sounds fine by itself and was a single |
evilford
02.23.18 | Cool list. I'd pick behind the sun for 4 |
chug73
02.23.18 | Behind the sun is awesome. It gets weirder and weirder as it goes on. The end is like some 3/4 over 4/4 weirdness. |
Shoegazefan9789
02.23.18 | Love me some soul burn thrust
Thanks ford dude. And mayhem, glad we see eye to eye on that now |
artiswar
02.23.18 | I get it Shoegazefan... But it just doesn't feel RIIGHT GODDAMMIT |
chug73
02.23.18 | ok, I'll let the lack of C33 slide. |
bgillesp
02.23.18 | I'd put The Mouth Licking What You've Bled on here. Underrated track off Sphere |
Relinquished
02.23.18 | 5 tracks on C33 can sound good by themselves. where are the fans that know. |
Shoegazefan9789
02.23.18 | They do sound good by themselves, but knowing myself, I would just want to hear the rest of C33 if I just heard one of the passages standing alone in a comp album |
DarkSideOfLucca
03.06.18 | List is perfect except yeah I would change Do Not Look Down with Bleed, but respect |
artiswar
03.07.18 | Bleed and Do Not Look Down are neck-and-neck for different reasons. I like this list a lot but you cheated by not including any Catch 33. That's like doing the list on easy mode. |
BurnMyThighs
03.07.18 | Ugh |
Shoegazefan9789
03.07.18 | Art my man I'm SORRY |
InFlamesWeThrash666
03.07.18 | New Millenium Cyanide Christ man |
CalculatingInfinity
03.07.18 | Catch 33 is already the perfect Meshuggah album ya nonce. |
Shoegazefan9789
03.07.18 | Not sure that song is better than Rational Gaze dude |
MO
03.07.18 | nice. i'd throw in i am colossus or behind the sun instead of do not look down tho |