bgillesp
Site HevyDevy Specialist
User

Reviews 1
Approval 100%

Soundoffs 26
News Articles 2
Band Edits + Tags 55
Album Edits 36

Album Ratings 1906
Objectivity 76%

Last Active 10-05-17 10:31 pm
Joined 11-30-15

Forum Posts 4
Review Comments 1,971

 Lists
11.16.17 Under-Appreciated Albums (Pop-Punk Free10.25.17 rrr11: Fix My Ratings
10.10.17 rrr10: concept theatre10.01.17 rr round 9: tripping on a hop in a pape
09.26.17 rec roulette round 8: teach me how to c09.17.17 rec roulette round 7: teach me how to h
09.01.17 rec roulette round 6: jazzy pants08.31.17 Sharknado Film Series Ranked
08.26.17 All... One... Dollar... Get Jealous08.25.17 rec roulette round 5- gimme 2017
08.14.17 rec roulette round 4: Living Live08.08.17 rec roulette round 3- I prog. Can you?
08.06.17 Rec roulette round 2- bgill08.03.17 The Ultimate Guide to Devin Townsend
08.02.17 rec roulette round 1- bgill07.22.17 Goodwill Hunting
04.16.17 Which album should be my 1000th rating?02.05.17 Prog Rock Rec Tourney
More »

rrr11: Fix My Ratings

Description:
1Typhoon (USA-OR)
Offerings


AOTY'18


Btw the rules are pick one of these albums on the top 200 chart I have rated below a 4. You will be graded on how much I bump the rating upon relistening. I have listened to none of these more than twice and all of these ratings are at least from 6+ months ago so I don't remember the album well for any.
36 chambers-3
Crimson King-3.5
Loveless-3
Downward spiral-3
Bath-3
VU-2
All things must pass-3.5
Don't break the oath-3
Melissa-3
The mantle-3.5
White pony-3
Choirs of the Eye-3.5
Soundtracks for the Blind-3
2King Crimson
In the Court of the Crimson King


Robert
Well, I have no idea what was wrong with me the first couple times I tried this out. Maybe I had some hipster complex about not wanting to like what everyone called the best prog or something. Maybe the versions I had haphazardly pieced together on youtube were just poor recordings. In any case, this thing is, as its reputation holds, a true prog masterpiece and it is perfectly clear how it would have had a major influence on the music world. New Rating: 4.5, Growth: +1.0

Score: 16.5
3Agalloch
The Mantle


Protomania
YYYYAAAAAAAWWWWWWWNNNNNNNN. Boy am I tired. This album puts me to sleep, and not in a good way. Agalloch is one of the most boring BM bands I've ever had the pleasure of listening to, and I don't see what is so special about them. That being said, the atmosphere they create is good and their musicianship and writing are too. New Rating: 3.5, Growth: +0.0

Score: 9.5
4My Bloody Valentine
Loveless


Compost
Holy Fuzzballs, this thing is a chore to listen to. I listened to it a few more times for this round, and I can say that: 1. It has grown on me, and 2. I am beginning to understand its influence. However, despite its revolutionary sound and influence, I fail to see how anyone could think these songs are well-written. The transitions between tracks are downright poor, and the songs themselves are nothing special. The production, even for its goal, I don't view as a positive either. The only thing important about this album to me is that it spawned a successful genre of well-respected music. New Rating: 3.3, Growth: +0.3

Score: 21
Show/Add Comments (26)

STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy