User
Reviews 123 Approval 98%
Soundoffs 230 News Articles 8 Band Edits + Tags 1 Album Edits 185
Album Ratings 2276 Objectivity 84%
Last Active 09-26-19 3:01 pm Joined 01-26-17
Review Comments 9,464
| REC ROULETTE ROUND 5 -- Butcher Brace
losin' steam faster than a harlot's kettle.. | 1 | | Mark Lanegan Bubblegum
The theme for this are DUETS. I'd like you to rec me three. | 2 | | Tindersticks Waiting for the Moon
When I say duets, I mean vocal interplay, not two musicians who came together to arrange, though if they happen to do that while singing together, all the better! One of your recs can be male-male, but I would prefer male-female dynamics. Examples are Stuart Staple with Lhasa de Sela on Sometimes It Hurts off this album, or the duet Lanegan does with PJ Harvey on Bubblegum above. Have at it. Stipulating questions not allowed. | 3 | | David Byrne and St. Vincent Love This Giant
Unique 1
Who
Unique, I know you adore St. Vincent, and I like quite a bit of her music, even if she is more or less a perfectly molded piece of 21st century hipster twaddle. That being said, I liked this song, I think she and Byrne are a good match, if only in the sense that they both behave like perfumed asexual tapeworms. Song had plenty of that old Talking Heads white man funk. I grant thee 3.5/5 | 4 | | Get Well Soon Schulz & Böhmermann (The Original Soundtrack)
Unique 2
When You're Near Me
This was fucking lovely. Equal parts Bond theme lushness and Gainsbourg-esque zex. Love that schmaltzy orchestral arrangement. And the voices blended well, like beet juice and Russian tears. Have a 4.5/5 | 5 | | Andrew Bird Are You Serious
Unique 3
Left Handed Kisses
Fiona Apple is damn great. I've never heard of Andrew Bird before, and he sounds pretty well like every other half-decent indie act from the mid-2000's (whom I all hate). However, the otherwise banal skeletal structure of the song was improved by little quirky noise add-ons and some other kinks that elevated it past simple indie radio fare. I liked the song enough, but will probably never listen to it again. Her voice is much better and more individualized that his. If this was a duet of Andrew Bird and Emily Haines, it would have gotten a 0.5/5. As it is Fiona Apple, this gets 3/5
Unique's score -- 3.66666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666667
also known as the WINNER.. | 6 | | Fleetwood Mac Rumours
bgill 1
Go Your Own Way
I know nothing at all about Fleetwood Mac's music, so I've only vaguely heard the hook to this song on classic radio skips, old pubs etc. The drums in this are fucking stellar. The song is cheese. Good cheese, even great cheese, but at the moment, I'm feeling intolerant of lactose, so I'm banishing this cheese back into the starter vat of a cheese factory, to be curdle, then remove the bacteria so it turns back to milk, and then shove that milk back into the cow's udder it came from. Have a 3/5 | 7 | | Typhoon (USA-OR) White Lighter
bgill 2
Morton's Fork
Despite the fact that Morton's Fork sounds like a Dr. Seuss book about a serial rapist, the brass and strings on this tune were goddamn gorgeous. Not crazy about his voice, but that the interplay with the girl on the chorus was very sweet. For that, you get 3.5/5 | 8 | | Devin Townsend Ziltoid Live at the Royal Albert Hall
bgill 3
Universal Flame
I mean this song's name speaks for itself. A grand concept that comes with an equally grandiose sound. It has that shaking vast atmosphere of possibility and rallying a crowd. This sort of music isn't really my thing, but if you take it for what it is, it's good. However, I feel like the female vocals here were backing more than they were collaborating, unlike the Typhoon song where she felt like an integral part of the aesthetic moment. Also, since Universal Flame is a concept I have a hard time imagining (do people argue about their flames?), I have to give this one a 3/5
bgill's score -- 3.1666666666666666666666666666666666666666667 (sorry, dude, this batch didn't do much for me..) | 9 | | Gentle Giant Octopus
Fripp 1
Knots
Hmmm. Maybe it's the nautical album art, or the theatrical aspects of the music itself, but this sounds like something that Captain Hook has his men sing on the ship while they scrub the masts and tar the cormorant and other ocean shite. The duet part of this was a stretch. Also, where are the cojones? 3/5 | 10 | | Kate Bush The Dreaming
Fripp 2
Get Out of My House
Not everything she does is a stroke of genius. Though the jerky, intermittently dense arrangement gave me a noise/no wave half-hard-on. I hated the song until she went hee-haw, then I realized that the song is about a donkey who won't leave her house. I want to leave her house. Fripp, your idea of a duet is very different from mine. Also, where are the cojones? 2.5/5 | 11 | | Stereolab Dots and Loops
Fripp 3
Parsec
Oxford Dictionary defines a Parsec as a unit of astronomical length based on the distance from Earth at which stellar parallax is one second of arc and equal to 3.258 light-years, 3.086 × 1013 kilometers, or 1.918 × 1013 miles. That distance is also exactly the amount of cojones Fripp has to suggest a song that is not a duet for a duet competition. Decent song though. 3/5
Fripp's score -- 2.833333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333 | |
butcherboy
08.24.17 | hello.. | Papa Universe
08.24.17 | soo, songs not albums? | butcherboy
08.24.17 | yes. i mean stipulating questions not allowed.. | Papa Universe
08.24.17 | soo music, not audio recordings of exorcism? | butcherboy
08.24.17 | minus 1 point for you.. | Papa Universe
08.24.17 | soo virtually meaningless points, not food? | butcherboy
08.24.17 | minus 3 points for you.. | Papa Universe
08.24.17 | but babe...? | butcherboy
08.24.17 | eliminated!! | Papa Universe
08.24.17 | oh well, then I guess I'll keep that brutal Jagger/Bowie track to myself. | butcherboy
08.24.17 | heard it.. | Papa Universe
08.24.17 | David Byrne and St. Vincent - Who | Papa Universe
08.24.17 | Get Well Soon and Kat Frankie - Whey You're Near to Me | Papa Universe
08.24.17 | Are instrumental duets accepted? | butcherboy
08.24.17 | nope.. | bgillesp
08.24.17 | Well I'd be remissed to not include DTP- universal flame (DT and Anneke van Giersbergen). Or maybe I should do a CoC with DT and Che Aimee Dorval. I'll get back to you on that, but I'm only gonna use one of those two.
Most others I can think of you've probably heard | bgillesp
08.24.17 | I'm assuming you're familiar with fleetwood mac, arcade fire, and typhoon | bgillesp
08.24.17 | For my allowance of 1 m-m duet, I'll rec temple of the dog- hunger strike, but in the likely event you've heard it, Pierce the veil- King for a day (which sounds like f-f duet and I'm sure you'll hate it but oh well) | butcherboy
08.24.17 | actually, i am incredibly unfamiliar with fleetwood mac, bgill.. just one of those classic bands I've barely heard.. don't know typhoon either.. hunger strike, i've heard.. | Papa Universe
08.24.17 | Musical mashups are technically duets, aren't they? | butcherboy
08.24.17 | depends on how seamless they are i suppose.. i don't know.. my instinct tilts towards nah.. but rec it, i'll give it a quick listen and we'll see.. | Papa Universe
08.24.17 | And what about features or rap collabs? | butcherboy
08.24.17 | yep and yep.. | Papa Universe
08.24.17 | The mashup: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4PPcnmO76rg | butcherboy
08.24.17 | hahhahahahaha.. no on that one,, but i loved it.. | Papa Universe
08.24.17 | Goddammit! | Papa Universe
08.24.17 | Andrew Bird and Fiona Apple - Left Handed Kisses | Papa Universe
08.25.17 | So in recap, here are my recs:
David Byrne and St. Vincent - Who (off of Love This Giant)
Get Well Soon and Kat Frankie - When You're Near to Me (off of Schulz & Böhmermann)
Andrew Bird and Fiona Apple - Left Handed Kisses (off of Are You Serious) | bgillesp
08.25.17 | Fleetwood Mac- Go your own way
Typhoon (USA-OR)- Young Fathers (not a duet sorry, gonna change it soon)
DTP- Universal Flame | bgillesp
08.25.17 | Nice on the Bird rec UU | butcherboy
08.25.17 | lovely, now the Fripp wait..// | bgillesp
08.25.17 | Morton's Fork is a song with a duet from Typhoon. Sorry, I'm awful with song names within albums I love. I just remember the sounds but don't associate a song name with different parts of the album | Drifter
08.25.17 | https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=t7i2b27EBV4 | Drifter
08.25.17 | Only duet that matters ^^^^ | LeftyMcRighty
08.26.17 | 1- "Strange Form of Life" Bonnie 'Prince' Billy and Dawn McCarthy. One of my top 10 A-T. https://youtu.be/Dy2EpHcBgfE
2- "The Man With the Silver Tongue" The Angels of Light. https://youtu.be/41fqDKZlqmY
3- "Be Free" King Dude and Chelsea Wolfe. https://youtu.be/mw3fTBd0R0g
Honorable Mention: https://youtu.be/zM0KAh5w7Rs | Papa Universe
08.26.17 | First of all, Be Free is fire. Second of all, you're not in the competition. | LeftyMcRighty
08.26.17 | Oh, sorry. Maker's Mark with a beer back made me ambivalent to rules. | LeftyMcRighty
08.26.17 | ...about rules... | butcherboy
08.26.17 | i'll be checking them out, Lefty.. | LeftyMcRighty
08.26.17 | Enjoy! | Frippertronics
08.26.17 | 1. Gentle Giant - Knots
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUpREizsftU
2. Kate Bush - Get Out Of My House (pls accept this offering of brash braying)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_uHUUwgGW5c
3. James Brown - Lost Someone (the "Apollo" ver.) (this may be cheating but between Brown, his singers and the audience, there's tons of interplay)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q6B3AHXWejg
| butcherboy
08.26.17 | know the Apollo footage of Brown very well, and that version is stellar.. The other two are good | Frippertronics
08.26.17 | ah, so switch that one out then? no prob | Frippertronics
08.26.17 | in that case
Stereolab - Parsec (again, probably a bit of cheating but them vocals) | butcherboy
08.26.17 | Done and done | Frippertronics
08.26.17 | wunderbar | bgillesp
08.26.17 | I need to check some Gentle Giant. Where should I start with them Fripp? | Frippertronics
08.26.17 | Octopus, which is what Knots is from | bgillesp
08.26.17 | Cool. And I also just now considered that Go Your Own Way isn't really a duet... The story of the album is completely duet-like but The Chain might be the best duet example | Papa Universe
08.27.17 | Kaboom! | butcherboy
08.27.17 | there we go.. | Papa Universe
08.27.17 | I feel power! I feel glory! | butcherboy
08.27.17 | i feel like Fripp kamikaze'd this one.. | Frippertronics
08.27.17 | On this episode of "butcherboy has no taste"... | Papa Universe
08.27.17 | oh snap | butcherboy
08.28.17 | I will always love you, Fripp.. but i will never forget.. | Frippertronics
08.28.17 | You think this is over? I've yet to begin my torment upon your salted soul, butcher's block. | butcherboy
08.28.17 | well, i could have taken the same approach you took to my duet round for your minimal music and recced you a chamber orchestra .. | butcherboy
08.28.17 | also, i've recently unsalted my soul, as I am trying to cut back on sodium in my diet.. | Frippertronics
08.28.17 | "duets"
"asks for vocal interplay"
are you by chance unfamiliar with the concept of the very thing you asked for?? | butcherboy
08.28.17 | semantical poo etc. | butcherboy
08.28.17 | also, I listened to In Praise of Learning.. i really don't go for much prog, but there's something about them, hell.. give me more stuff like that.. | Frippertronics
08.28.17 | again, you're looking for stuff from the Rock in Opposition movement, which spans beyond prog and more into experimental/minimal/jazz,etc. Again, bands related to Henry Cow is what you're looking for. | butcherboy
08.28.17 | you're so sassy sometimes..
don't you know that grey skies are going to clear up? | Frippertronics
08.28.17 | you're asking to be deprived of Henry Cow-esque greatness | bgillesp
08.28.17 | Eh, oh well. | bgillesp
08.28.17 | So what are your overall rankings/winner? | butcherboy
08.28.17 | is this the last round we're doing|? | Papa Universe
08.28.17 | No... we actually didn't disclose how many rounds there will be. I sure hope this ain't the last one, but if you lads are tired, we can take a short hiatus until like 1st of September... | Papa Universe
08.28.17 | For what it's worth, I hope we don't. I've got another 12 rounds prepared and they are ingeniously cunty. Would be a shame to waste them. | Frippertronics
08.28.17 | Personally, I'm cool with keeping this going for a bit longer. A break every five or so rounds doesn't sound like that bad of an idea, though. | butcherboy
08.28.17 | I'm off to Havana in a bit more than a week, so I will be off the grid for awhile.. I could do with doing another round, and then taking a break.. | Papa Universe
08.28.17 | Okay, then let's do a Round 6 and then we'll meet up again, once butcherboy announces his grand return in another one of his chill.out lists... | butcherboy
08.29.17 | alright, if bgill is alright with it, let's do it.. because I think he also has a trip coming up.. | bgillesp
08.29.17 | Nah, I'm into my semester now. I won't be on the site as frequently anymore for a while but I can take recs and jam them quicker, so I'm good to roll on. So yeah we can do a round 6 then break for Fripp and my final report comment will now just be a checkpoint for y'all to see. | bgillesp
08.29.17 | Getting recs and categories to you may not be as quick anymore though. I'm about out of ideas, so a break after round six will give me time to stack up some more |
|