|
User
Reviews 10 Approval 98%
Soundoffs 20 News Articles 12 Band Edits + Tags 41 Album Edits 77
Album Ratings 1093 Objectivity 62%
Last Active 12-17-18 3:10 pm Joined 08-25-16
Review Comments 7,203
| POST-PUNK OFF, A COMPETITION ROUND 2
RULES: A sister-competition to the "Con VS Unique Emo Crown". Two competitors rec 30 albums, 1 at a time, to 3 judges. A new round of recs will be presented once all three judges have finished rating/listening to both albums. This will continue until a total of 30 albums will be presented, 15 from each competitor. Winner will be determined by the highest AVG but tie breaker will be whoever had the best rec and each judge gets 1 vote for that.------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------NEW RULE: Competitors who fail to submit their recs within 1 day after each list's creation will have .5 deducted from their score for EACH day late ____JUDGES: Conmaniac, DeadlyNightShade, neekafat_____ COMPETITORS: UniqueUniverse, Tyler.,teamster_______ EMO COMPETITION: http://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?mode=1&listid=176039#comments | | 1 |  | Red Lorry Yellow Lorry Talk About the Weather
UniqueUniverse's rec
CURRENT COMPETITION SCORE: 22.9 | | 2 |  | Red Lorry Yellow Lorry Talk About the Weather
Con: A menacingly hypnotic album, Talk About the Weather trudges by you in a storm of anxious ramblings. While the vocalist is angstily mumbling about mundane conversations with a sense of life and fervor, the rest of the band plays simple yet rambunctious post punk music, gothic in nature yet jittering and distressed in tone. While the album is very coherent, it seemed to lack a breakout track or two that would’ve put this album over the metaphorical edge. 3.8/5 | | 3 |  | Red Lorry Yellow Lorry Talk About the Weather
Neeka: Brash and hard-hitting, Talk About the Weather moves along with purposeful repetition and a seriously dark edge. At first it’s all gloriously appealing, but it isn’t long before the surprisingly short album feels somehow tiring due to this redundant nature. That is of course until the final two tracks come out of nowhere and throttles you around for even thinking such a thing. 3.7/5
Track Ratings: Talk About the Weather: 8 -, Hand on Heart: 8 +, Feel a Piece: 7.5 -, Hollow Eyes: 7.5 +, This Today: 7 +, Sometimes: 7 +, Strange Dreams: 8.5 +, Happy: 8 + | | 4 |  | Red Lorry Yellow Lorry Talk About the Weather
Deadly: Gripping and edgy, Unique truly put out a rec here which I embrace near and dear to some of my favorite albums I’ve heard. Talk About the Weather embraces the tone of punk music while obviously staying true to a typical post-punk album sound. As you listen to this album, it’s hard not to picture the lead vocalist muttering lyrics with a grimacing expression. The album features some of the most bitter and angsty british vocals I have heard. The punchy and gritty basslines further push you into a feeling of vexation. The atmosphere is intoxicating in a way that it never loses it’s grip. If anything, the grip is at its tightest on closer “Happy” which is an irony in and of itself as it is genuinely menacing. It’s clear to me why someone would consider it a classic especially given its time of release. 5/5 | | 5 |  | Elvis Costello This Year's Model
Tyler.'s rec
CURRENT COMPETITION SCORE: 24.2 | | 6 |  | Elvis Costello This Year's Model
Con: Holy shit Elvis Costello was so cool. I mean, just look at that album cover…
Man-crushing aside, I really enjoyed this record because it’s just so fucking fun. Pump It Up is a classic song that I’ve been jamming for awhile now, but a lot of the tracks on here blew that one out of the water. Elvis is able to incorporate a lot of different genres into this pop gem, (he even gets psychedelic with the intro to Hand on Heart) and ultimately he paves the way for a lot of the modern “pop punk” we hear today (I commented on this doc earlier that this is what Jeff Rosenstock would’ve sounded like if he was born in 1950 haha). Overall really fun rec, even though it’s only slightly post punk. 4.1/5 | | 7 |  | Elvis Costello This Year's Model
Neeka: While some of the songs are simply too short to get into, Costello is adept at switching genres like a snap of the fingers. His vocals are great too, adding his own personality to each of the styles he wades through, adding to the easygoing and upbeat nature of the album. That being said, it does often drift into cheesy or even annoying territory, what with the female backing vocals and sugary sweet keyboard riffs. More often than not however, This Year’s Model proves to be an enjoyable slice of pop music. 3.5/5
Track Listing: No Action: 7 -, This Year’s Girl: 6 +, The Beat: 7.5 +, Pump it Up: 7.5 -, Little Triggers: 7.5 +, You Belong to Me: 7 +, Hand in Hand: 7.5 +, (I Don’t Want to Go) Chelsea: 8 -, Lip Service: 6.5 -, Living in Paradise: 6.5 -, Lipstick Vogue: 8 -, Night Rally: 7.5 +, Radio, Radio: 7 - | | 8 |  | Elvis Costello This Year's Model
Deadly: Listening to This Year’s Model, you can’t help but love the infectious nature of so many of the tracks on this album. Elvis Costello brings in so much to love, from vocals loaded with personality, entertaining instrumentation and just flat out catchy music. I would be amazed if someone didn’t find something to enjoy here. You would be lying if you said there wasn’t at least one song that you aren’t humming along with or tapping your feet to. Elvis is the epitome of charismatic vocal delivery with his tremulous vocals that stand out like a sore thumb in the best way possible. Song structures typically feature bumping bass beats and quick drum patterns which carry songs in an upbeat and funky manner. Truthfully, I found it hard to find many flaws in this, but I would say there are a few grating parts, primarily the end of “Hand in Hand.” Overall, I really enjoyed this rec. 4.5/5 | | 9 |  | Vaura The Missing
teamster's rec
CURRENT COMPETITION SCORE: 22.1 | | 10 |  | Vaura The Missing
Con: This one was closer, Teamster, as The Missing was able to flash moments of brilliance within it’s sludgy, metal-inspired atmosphere. Whether it was the vocal melody in Incomplete Burning, the bass in Pleasure Blind, or the raw, visceral yelled vox on Braced for Collapse, Vaura is able to prove their worth. However, the repetitive and sometimes offensively annoying drumming takes this down a notch and hinders the band from truly coming into their own on this album. I dig these shoegazey, post-punk recs but I’ve yet to be blown away by this niche of a subgenre. 3.7/5 | | 11 |  | Vaura The Missing
Neeka: I'm even more confused on the definition of post-punk now, as this is clearly more metal influenced than anything. That being said, there’s some excellent musicianship going on here. Despite the heaviness of the music and atmospherics, the band does an excellent job of delivering sweet melodies with some incredible guitar work and vocal delivery. Like teamster’s previous rec this album is incredibly consistent, but this one proves to be more memorable than After the Day Before. While it may also cram some perhaps-too-similar songs together in some spaces, they are quickly broken up by tracks such as the genre-blending powerhouse closers “Abeyance” and “Putting Flesh to the Bone.” 4.1/5
Track Rankings: The Missing: 8 +, Incomplete Burning: 8.5 -, The Fire: 8 -, Mare of the Snake: 8 -, Pleasure Blind: 8 +, Passage to Vice: 7.5 +, The Things That We All Hide: 8.5 -, Braced for Collapse: 8.5 -, Abeyance: 8.5 +, Putting Flesh to Bone: 9 - | | 12 |  | Vaura The Missing
Deadly: Have you ever had an itch and can’t quite scratch it? If so, you can probably understand where I’m coming from with my opinion of ‘The Missing’. Vaura showcase potential for brilliance on this album as much of the instrumentation is impressive. You may ask next, what keeps this from excelling in every way? The answer to this is simple, dull and lifeless drums. There are many opportunites for this record to astonish but always seem to be watered down by overly repetitive and simple drum work. A prime example of flawed and repetitive usage of drum technique can be heard in both the opening drum lines on tracks “The Fire” and “Pleasure Blind”, which if you played both introsin unison, there would be virtually no difference. Often times, it leads you to wonder, how much better would this be with a more creative drummer? | | 13 |  | Vaura The Missing
Vaura seem to be stuck in a hard rock style of drumming when it’s clear these songs would be more properly suited to a heavier, metal approach due to their black metal tendencies. In an attempt to look past this “itch” I would be hard-pressed to avoid seeing the pros in this album. The atmospheres are often times quite successful and it seems, in general, that all members of the band have their showcasing moments. The guitar opening riffage in “Incomplete Burning” are some of the most entertaining on the album, the basslines that fill the empty spaces in “Pleasure Blind” and the exploding vocals that breakthrough the somber atmosphere on “Braced for Collapse”. All in all, this was an enjoyable listen that although MISSES its mark, shows a promising future for the band. 3.5/5
(sorry not sorry for the pun or the verbose write up) | |
ZombieToyDuck
08.02.17 | ROUND 2 BEGINS! | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | Wait, I thought we'll do it all in that one thread. | Conmaniac
08.02.17 | idk might get too cluttered right? with 3 judges and longer write ups? | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | yeah, alright | ZombieToyDuck
08.02.17 | Yeah I think, it will get messy | Conmaniac
08.02.17 | that album art is soooo nice | ZombieToyDuck
08.02.17 | Yeah, I reallly dig it | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | Hope you'll dig this much more, since it seems like you're more into dark sad boys...I shall note that. | ZombieToyDuck
08.02.17 | I for sure am, which should really come as no surprise... | neekafat
08.02.17 | I wanted to see how many comments we would get lol | Conmaniac
08.02.17 | true...but we can add up all the threads' comments and pretend | GhandhiLion
08.02.17 | Unique has already won.. | neekafat
08.02.17 | Idk so far he's runnin' last but I think he'll be upping his game | neekafat
08.02.17 | Deadly could you add their current scores to their rec boxes? | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | I mean, you're the only people I've ever encounter who just slightly 'liked' Ocean Rain. I really thought it'll be like the safest choice anyone could make. | neekafat
08.02.17 | I wouldn't say my 3.7 was just a slight like lol | Conmaniac
08.02.17 | yeah see I told u post punk would be hit n miss for me i apologize | butcherboy
08.02.17 | Unique's rec'ing straight up post-punk classics.. amazing album!! | GhandhiLion
08.02.17 | ^this | ZombieToyDuck
08.02.17 | You mean to this list neeka? I can do that when I get all submissions | Conmaniac
08.02.17 | oh god this album is 19 songs better get started | Conmaniac
08.02.17 | oh wait it's 8 lol nvm | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | It's like not even 30 minutes long | neekafat
08.02.17 | Actual screenshot of the convo so far
https://imgur.com/a/WqxHP | Conmaniac
08.02.17 | spotify and their damn bonus tracks! | neekafat
08.02.17 | Gotta love them short albums | Conmaniac
08.02.17 | hahah idk if unique appreciated that screenshot | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | guess... | ZombieToyDuck
08.02.17 | sad Unique is sad | neekafat
08.02.17 | < 3 you UU | Stereochrome1
08.02.17 | I hope The Damned's Phantasmagoria will be featured | Conmaniac
08.02.17 | i hope the other competitors get here...but it's almost 1 pm so we will at least have another rec by then | Conmaniac
08.02.17 | also im done with the first rec for this round, excited for the other two | teamster
08.02.17 | My rec for Round 2 : Vaura - The Missing | Conmaniac
08.02.17 | niceeee all we need now is a TYLER rec | butcherboy
08.02.17 | Unique, shall I make up that list now or on the morrow? | ZombieToyDuck
08.02.17 | time is ticking for Tyler. hope he doesn't take a point deduction | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | butcherboy: It's up to you, you're the administrator, but we'll have to inform bgillesp and Fripp. | Tyler.
08.02.17 | Elvis Costello - this year's model | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | That's not exactly Post-Punk, but close enough to compete, I guess... | Tyler.
08.02.17 | Omg we said new wave works it's fine lmao | ZombieToyDuck
08.02.17 | Perfect! No tardy entries | butcherboy
08.02.17 | well, I'm at work all day tomorrow morning, so I'll do it up then, and shoutbox them tonight about it.. | teamster
08.02.17 | I like the rec Tyler... | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | Oh yeah, we did... wasn't it me, who suggested New Wave and Goth to count in the first place? Huh.. | Tyler.
08.02.17 | Thanks... | ZombieToyDuck
08.02.17 | Okay all recs accounted for and scores for everyone listed. | Tyler.
08.02.17 | Where does the score come from ??lol | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | last round. | ZombieToyDuck
08.02.17 | from last round, that's each competitor's current score | ZombieToyDuck
08.02.17 | clarified that, makes things clearer to those who are tuning in | teamster
08.02.17 | I'm really excited to see your opinions about the Vaura album...I wrote a review for it a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away...
http://www.metalstorm.net/pub/review.php?review_id=12437 | GhandhiLion
08.02.17 | Red Lorry Yellow Lorry lower better win, considering the other two are not post- punk | ZombieToyDuck
08.02.17 | We shall see | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | [2] | neekafat
08.02.17 | From what I can tell new wave and post-punk are pretty similar, and over half the bands so far were already part gothic | GhandhiLion
08.02.17 | "and over half the bands so far were already part gothic" That is fine given goth evolved out of Post-punk. New wave Is radically diferent, closer to pop music. Post-punk is cold, atmospheric and experimental (not that new-wave couldn't be) | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | New Wave is if you take only the aggressive, upfront kind of Post-Punk and replace their guitars with synthesisers. Goth is if you do the same with the brooding sad-boy Post-Punkers. | butcherboy
08.02.17 | I'm rooting for Red Lorry Yellow Lorry, because Costello doesn't qualify as post-punk by any motherfucking stretch.. | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | In all fairness, Alexisonfire also shouldn't have qualified for Emo Crown, and yet here we are. | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | But yeah, I'll take all the support I can get. Thanks, butch. | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | But that Vaura album rocks so far. | neekafat
08.02.17 | It's his No. 1 tag tho | neekafat
08.02.17 | Jamming Vaura now | JasonCarne
08.02.17 | Love that Vaura album, but I prefer Red Lorry Yellow Lorry just slightly. Costello never did much for me. | neekafat
08.02.17 | I'm even more confused about post-punk now | Papa Universe
08.02.17 | If you're still confused, here's a little aid. All of these are Post-Punk songs:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJRsfMklhxc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5VnwL4-Ghn0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jcOrCrTLCGk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=snhkO-c-S0c
Try to fathom that.
This is out of the competition.
Also, you don't have to understand Post-Punk, that's the competitor's job. You only listen to the stuff we submit you to. | neekafat
08.02.17 | So kind of influenced by punk music in its abrasiveness and rejection of pop culture, but with a much thicker atmosphere and with heavier incorporation of other sounds and styles?
Thanks for understanding haha | Conmaniac
08.02.17 | gonna jam the other two albums now | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | Again, I'll forget to do it later if I don't do this now, here are my thoughts on the other two albums:
Vaura - The Missing
Deep, emotional, dark and brooding experience that leaves a heavy weight on your mind after you finish listening. Its echoic production and near Metallic instrumentation (very reminiscent of early Ceremony) definitely makes up for some nightly landscapic atmosphere. It's a treat of an album. 4.1/5
Elvis Costello - This Year's Model
Hip and cool album, but I just can't get into it. I never was a big fan of Elvis' and while I enjoy this album to a certain extent, I will probably need more listens to get into it, but that'll be pretty much 'forcing yourself to like it' kind of situation. 3.4/5 | ZombieToyDuck
08.03.17 | did you really just use "hip" to describe Elvis Costello? Your "dad" is showing Unique lol | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | Okay, we get it, I'm old, move the hell on. | ZombieToyDuck
08.03.17 | well I need something to hold over you since you booted me out of the competition ;) | Conmaniac
08.03.17 | deadly u ready to finish up these jams? | ZombieToyDuck
08.03.17 | Yeah was just finishing up a last jam of elvis cause its much different listen with headphones vs a bluetooth speaker ya know? | Conmaniac
08.03.17 | oh yea i feel ya...need to jam all of Vaura still tho | Conmaniac
08.03.17 | so far the recs have been pretty consistent with the judges tastes...
Unique: v british, dreamy/cloudy classic 80s post punk
Tyler: not-so-post-punk but likes poppier stuff and a lighter atmosphere
Teamster: very dreary, gothic post punk, heavily shoegaze influenced | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | What can I say, I like me some classics | Conmaniac
08.03.17 | mhmmm I can tell | Conmaniac
08.03.17 | scores are incoming...good round tho ppl | ZombieToyDuck
08.03.17 | okay its settled, so will be posting shortly. | Conmaniac
08.03.17 | some hot n spicy takes this round | ZombieToyDuck
08.03.17 | gunna redo averages before anyone points me out for not updating | Conmaniac
08.03.17 | wait yeah how are you calculating these averages? | ZombieToyDuck
08.03.17 | damnit screw up hold up | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | SCORES SO FAR:
Tyler.: 24
UniqueUniverse: 22,9
teamster: 22,1 | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | or are we doing averages instead of collective sums? | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | Also, should I post my 3rd rec here or wait for the next thread? | ZombieToyDuck
08.03.17 | I got this Unique, but thank you, I appreciate it | Conmaniac
08.03.17 | shouldnt tyler have 24.2 (?) | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | I recalculated it and now it seems like he has 24,3...ehm, okay... | ZombieToyDuck
08.03.17 | ahh I see I did the math with your AVG score instead of what you ended up giving the album | ZombieToyDuck
08.03.17 | Fixed, Con was right! | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | Hey, Deadly, why does it say in the first round's comment section, where you rounded up our scores that Tyler has 11,9? What system are you counting it in? | Conmaniac
08.03.17 | yeah whoops that AVG score was just an average of my track ratings that I did for fun but it didn't reflect my actual score for LC | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | So are you people rating the albums based on personal feelings or averages from personal feelings on each songs? And for that matter, are you counting our overall scores based off of sums of the scores given by each judge or some other ghoulishly dubious bacchanalia of a system that nobody seems to understand? | ZombieToyDuck
08.03.17 | I made an error I just edited my comment I misread con's rating for that album last round. | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | Thank you. | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | So should I submit my next album here or do I wait for the next round's page? | Conmaniac
08.03.17 | yeah I wont do that AVG shit anymore if I ever do track ratings again. just a fun thing to do/see but dont pay too much attention to it | ZombieToyDuck
08.03.17 | Rating each album as a whole. The song ratings were just for fun, I don't do that usually though so I didn't partake. I added all the scores I made a small error but we are all good! | ZombieToyDuck
08.03.17 | Either one Unique doesn't matter if you're antsy, I'm gunna take lunch then post next list. | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | Aight,
3) Minutemen - Double Nickels on the Dime
Since we've established that the submitted albums don't have to be pure Post-Punk extraordinaires... | Conmaniac
08.03.17 | isnt that a straight up punk album | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | And Elvis Costello is a Post-Punk stable? I mean, I can change it, I've got more shit up my sleeve. | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | They've got the tag and everything, I thought we've established that that's enough. | Conmaniac
08.03.17 | idk if either are post punk man im just a judge! ive always lumped Minutemen with like other hardcore punk acts tho but idk shit so i say its fine | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | Yeesh, alright I'll change it then, but if Tyler takes it and gets all 5s, I'm never talking to you again. | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | My choice is:
3) Traitrs - Rites and Rituals
Since one of you already heard Have a Nice Life, here's the next best thing. | Conmaniac
08.03.17 | good choice...
ive sampled minutemen before and im not a fan. | Tyler.
08.03.17 | Lol I'm going for new wave why not
New order - power corruption and lies | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | Well, I'm dead.. | Tyler.
08.03.17 | I'm not gonna go full new wave don't worry | Conmaniac
08.03.17 | New Order huh? im familiar with em, this'll be interesting | Papa Universe
08.03.17 | Well, at least DNS 5d Red Lorry, which is the only right rating you can give that album, so as of right now, I'm not nervous... | Tyler.
08.03.17 | *****that is including blue monday | Conmaniac
08.03.17 | oh I dig Blue Monday | ZombieToyDuck
08.03.17 | You betcha, that album was choice | neekafat
08.04.17 | Damn you guys went crazy on those Lorry and Costello albums | Conmaniac
08.04.17 | Costello album was soooo good. but yeah that Lorry 5 was wow | neekafat
08.04.17 | Just can't see it personally, but I did enjoy that album! | ZombieToyDuck
08.04.17 | tis a 5 in my eyes | Papa Universe
08.04.17 | I approve of that | ZombieToyDuck
08.04.17 | I approve of your approving of that | Papa Universe
08.04.17 | I approve of your approval of my approval of that | ZombieToyDuck
08.04.17 | I approve of your approval of my approval of your approval of that | Papa Universe
08.04.17 | I approve of your approval of my approval of your approval of my approval of that | ZombieToyDuck
08.04.17 | well all is well then | Papa Universe
08.04.17 | well then | ZombieToyDuck
08.04.17 | then well, all is | Papa Universe
08.04.17 | as is, very well | ZombieToyDuck
08.04.17 | very well, as you were | Papa Universe
08.04.17 | oh well then | neekafat
08.05.17 | Well | Conmaniac
08.05.17 | not this again wtf | ZombieToyDuck
08.05.17 | Lol | neekafat
09.07.17 | Neeka FINAL SCORES:
Unique - Talk About the Weather
Originally: 3.7/5 - Now: 3.7/5 - OVERALL: no change
Track Ratings: Talk About the Weather: 7.5, Hand on Heart: 8, Feel a Piece: 7.5, Hollow Eyes: 7, This Today: 7.5, Sometimes: 7.5, Strange Dreams: 8.5, Happy: 8 (AVG: 7.69)
Tyler - This Year's Model
Originally: 3.5 - Now: 3.3 - OVERALL: -0.2
Track Listing: No Action: 7, This Year’s Girl: 6, The Beat: 6.5, Pump it Up: 7.5, Little Triggers: 7, You Belong to Me: 7, Hand in Hand: 7, (I Don’t Want to Go) Chelsea: 7.5, Lip Service: 6.5, Living in Paradise: 6.5, Lipstick Vogue: 7.5, Night Rally: 6.5, Radio, Radio: 7 (AVG: 6.88)
Teamster - The Missing
Originally: 4.1 - Now: 4.1 - OVERALL: no change
Track Rankings: The Missing: 8, Incomplete Burning: 8, The Fire: 8, Mare of the Snake: 8, Pleasure Blind: 8, Passage to Vice: 8, The Things That We All Hide: 8.5, Braced for Collapse: 8.5, Abeyance: 8.5, Putting Flesh to Bone: 9 (AVG: 8.25)
DUE TO THE CHANGES OF THESE RATINGS, THE CURRENT SCORES ARE NOW:
Unique: 87.7
Tyler: 82.5
Teamster: 81.0
| Papa Universe
09.07.17 | swoosh |
|