GreyShadow
User

Reviews 3
Approval 100%

Soundoffs 151
News Articles 8
Band Edits + Tags 10
Album Edits 15

Album Ratings 602
Objectivity 61%

Last Active 07-16-22 6:04 am
Joined 05-04-11

Review Comments 7,030

 Lists
12.20.23 Grey's Top 10 Releases of 202308.08.23 Ultimate Davey Havok (AFI) Ranking
07.25.23 Top 20 Hail The Sun Songs07.05.23 2020s AOTY check in
06.01.23 Top 15 A7X Songs05.31.23 Top 10 Silversun Pickups Songs (23)
04.17.23 we should all rank Metallica tbh01.29.23 My Top 10 Songs atm
12.23.22 suggestions for finding band members08.08.22 Upcoming Concerts
07.15.22 Debut EP from your sputpal Grey! 04.12.22 Bored at work digs :)
01.03.22 5s By Bands That Aren't My Favorite Ban09.28.21 Circa Survive - Album Top 5s
06.14.21 AFI - Improving Bodies 05.24.21 La Dispute Discography Ranked
12.09.20 Grey's Top 10 EPs...ever!10.30.20 What's The Best Emo/Math Rock band?
More »

AFI - Black Sails In The Sunset Ranked

Alright, I have been on the hugest AFI hype since I saw them live a few days ago. I decided I am going to rank every album Black Sails and on as best as I can (excluding album intros since I never know how to rank them). Legit, my favorite band and always will be. Bonus songs may be lower just due to lack of listening to them, but they are generally worth a mention
15AFI
Black Sails in the Sunset


Transference - don't listen to it much but I dig Hunter in the chorus
14AFI
Black Sails in the Sunset


Lower It - dat bass intro is slick
13AFI
Black Sails in the Sunset


No Poetic Device - the poppiest song here. still really good though
12AFI
Black Sails in the Sunset


At A Glance - a tad longer and verse is a tad too similar to The Last Kiss but the latter half is really sick
11AFI
Black Sails in the Sunset


Who Knew? - Wish I listened to this more, it's quite the banger.
10AFI
Black Sails in the Sunset


Weathered Tome - okay yeah, this track feels so filler, but it's so hype
9AFI
Black Sails in the Sunset


God Called In Sick Today - okay if there is ANY super controversial pick I make, it's this one and I totally love this song but it's one of my least favorite AFI closers. Seems really epic live though. Idk, my biggest problem is that I don't think the screams mesh with the "ooo's" in the chorus. The I Heard a Voice version fixes that problem for me but still. I have this album at a 5 so you can't hate me for it.
8AFI
Black Sails in the Sunset


Narrative of Soul Against Soul - love that duet in the chorus
7AFI
Black Sails in the Sunset


Exsanguination - coolest word
6AFI
Black Sails in the Sunset


Midnight Sun - #beyondandtoalltimeIstand
5AFI
Black Sails in the Sunset


Porphyria - so much craziness in such a short time
4AFI
Black Sails in the Sunset


Clove Smoke Catharsis - I saw them play this live and it was gorgeous
3AFI
Black Sails in the Sunset


The Last Kiss - that guitar in the bridge had me hooked immediately as a kid. I thought it was actually the coolest thing ever
2AFI
Black Sails in the Sunset


The Prayer Position - shows that they can still be slow and aggressive
1AFI
Black Sails in the Sunset


Malleus Maleficarum - if this isn't your number 1 on this album, you are simply wrong. Their best pre-STS song in my opinion and still one of the best songs I've ever heard.
Show/Add Comments (13)

STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy