elliootsmeuth
10.02.16 | Solid |
LotusFlower
10.02.16 | 25 being least perfect is a massive understatement. |
Polyethylene
10.02.16 | Having 20 lower than the abortion that is 13 makes my soul bleed |
Polyethylene
10.02.16 | otherwise pretty good list :] |
FullOfSounds
10.02.16 | Cool |
Avagantamos
10.02.16 | prog AF |
ashcrash9
10.02.16 | I don't think I'll ever understand why people shit on 13 so hard |
FullOfSounds
10.02.16 | It's a fine album |
Rik VII
10.02.16 | surprisingly good, a lot of these are among my favorites too! |
DoofusWainwright
10.02.16 | Not a massive fan of 5 or 25 |
Polyethylene
10.02.16 | The Wall kinda sucks yeah |
Shadowmire
10.02.16 | i see u are a fan of excess as well |
Avagantamos
10.02.16 | check Isis |
danielcardoso
10.02.16 | 25 being least perfect is a massive understatement [2] lol |
ScuroFantasma
10.02.16 | Cool list, lots of great albums on here |
ABond
10.03.16 | So... with only a couple of exceptions, this is all prog. |
Rik VII
10.03.16 | that means literally nothing because prog is such a loosely defined term. |
ABond
10.03.16 | Which genre is not "a loosely defined term"? |
LotusFlower
10.03.16 | let the poor lass(i) enjoy prog rock if he wants. as long as it isnt steven wilson. |
ramon.
10.03.16 | Griseus is immense |
ABond
10.03.16 | lol, nah, this is a fine list, I like a lot of the albums on this list myself, but this is still veeery homogeneous. |
Rik VII
10.03.16 | you can't seriously tell me that Kamelot, King Crimson and Orphaned Land are all playing the same style of music.
prog isn't a genre, it's more of a mentality. |
LotusFlower
10.03.16 | who said its the same genre? it progs so its bog. |
ABond
10.03.16 | Roughly, yeah, it's not like you said "you can't seriously tell me that Kamelot and Tim Hecker are playing the same style of music" |
Rik VII
10.03.16 | yeah wow, they all use electric guitars. |
ABond
10.03.16 | Well, My Bloody Valentine also use electric guitars, so let's not pretend like most of this list isn't prog-y wankery ))) |
Rik VII
10.03.16 | so you're calling Kamelot wankery? |
LotusFlower
10.03.16 | this all wanks yeah |
Rik VII
10.03.16 | so does Paganini, still isn't prog. |
ABond
10.03.16 | Yeah, kinda pleby basic wankery but still)))
Look, as I said, I like a lot of the stuff on this list (although "The Mantle" and "OK Computer" are by far the best things on here, like by a country mile). It's just when someone narrows down their favorite albums to something as small as just 25, I'd expect more diversity. |
Rik VII
10.03.16 | yeah agreed, it needs some more pop/electronic/etc, but regarding metal and rock, this is pretty diverse imo |
ABond
10.03.16 | lol, Paganini |
Rik VII
10.03.16 | Paganini rules btw |
