ArsMoriendi
03.21.16 | No, especially since side 1 is about the character's childhood, and by the time side 3 comes along he's an adult.
What I do believe is that the highlights from the Wall sessions should have made a 1 disc album. |
Tunaboy45
03.21.16 | It's perfectly ordered, starting from side 3 would mean you miss on all of the important context that makes "Hey You" all the more powerful. |
onionbubs
03.21.16 | the order of the album seems a bit weird at times, but side 1 should be side 1 to the album.
anyone else think the fragile couldve just been condensed into one album though? like, take disc 1, and throw on into the void and the big come down, replacing pilgrimage and some other weaker track on left? |
demigod!
03.21.16 | awesome profile picture |
ArsMoriendi
03.22.16 | "throw on into the void and the big come down, replacing pilgrimage and some other weaker track on left?"
Seeing as though "Into the Void" and "The Big Come Down" are my 2 favorites on the entire album, I don't mind this comment. "Please" for should be on it too though. |
onionbubs
03.22.16 | please is good too yeah |
TheMagicalBlender
03.22.16 | "anyone else think the fragile couldve just been condensed into one album though? like, take disc 1, and throw on into the void and the big come down, replacing pilgrimage and some other weaker track on left?"
For a second there I thought you were talking about Yes. |
JigglyPDiddy
03.22.16 | Haven't listened to this record in years, tbh. At least a 2. |
Rowan5215
03.22.16 | ONWARDS AOSHIMA |
someguest
03.22.16 | The most boring double album in existence. God, it's a chore. |
Parallels
03.22.16 | It should start with "what should we do now?" and end with "another brick in the wall"
trump_laugh.jpg |
someguest
03.22.16 | Every song on it sounds the same. And none of it is exciting. It's all a dreary drudge towards nothing. |
Titan
03.22.16 | albums a classic regardless of the all the bitching about it |
someguest
03.22.16 | Two coasters in one. |
Titan
03.22.16 | haha good one |
evilford
03.22.16 | Should have just been one album but it still rules, has its share of amazing moments |
DominionMM1
03.22.16 | those amazing moments are just too few and far between |
BigPleb
03.22.16 | Agreeeed |
hesperus
03.22.16 | onion: I actually put together a condensed, one-disc version of The Fragile once. Basically I took all the tracks that had repeated motifs, like the Frail/Fragile melody, the riff from La Mer/Into the Void, "I can still feel you," etc., and then added a few of the standout tracks. I called it The Fragile (Center) and I was gonna learn how to edit the tracks so I could make a few tweaks to make it flow better, but I never got around to it. Maybe I should revisit it. |
DustyTill
03.22.16 | The thing is that in the flesh? is in the continuation of outside the wall and goodbye cruel world sound like a perfect ending. what i meant by begins with side 3 is the listening order should be side 3, side 4, side 1 and side 2, not just listening to sides 3 and 4. this makes a completely different and darker interpretation of the album. |
Mythodea
03.22.16 | albums a classic regardless of the all the bitching about it [2]
|
