hesperus: Sputnik's Favorite NIN Songs

ArsMoriendi 03.03.16	The Warning Piggy Mr. Self Destruct
Tyler. 03.03.16	do we need to do this for every artist
ArsMoriendi 03.03.16	Why not? :P
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.03.16	the big come down
EnyaFangirl 03.03.16	terrible lie
SanguineCream 03.03.16	The Perfect Drug Terrible Lie The Becoming Choosing one off of TDS is a fucking difficult task
Insurrection 03.03.16	the big come down[2] oh three songs.. ruiner and the great below
bach 03.03.16	sin all the love in the world mr. self destruct
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.03.16	ruiner is in my top 3 too. a third is really hard to pick but honestly head down is up there, not that anyone else in the history of nin fandom would ever agree
Minushuman24 03.03.16	And All That Could Have Been Ruiner We're In This Together
brandontaylor 03.03.16	ruiner
Insurrection 03.03.16	head down is top 10 at least, possibly top 5 but there are too many to choose from
altertide0 03.03.16	La mer Just Like You Imagined Leaving Hope
zakalwe 03.03.16	Wish
laughingman22 03.03.16	The Becoming A Warm Place The Great Below
DoofusWainwright 03.03.16	terrible lie closer hurt
zakalwe 03.03.16	All that exciting records talk earlier. NIN are definitely up there. Downward Spiral on its release was a dark, industrial thingamabob that just seemed dangerous as hell to us kids. What a classic.
DoofusWainwright 03.03.16	yeah they made my list too, something sinister and sexually perverse going down on TDS, as a 15 year old it made you feel like you were being pushed a bit outside what you were comfortable with = perfect teen album
zakalwe 03.03.16	Fist fucking and doggy style. Subtle.
onionbubs 03.03.16	Ruiner Reptile Something i can never have picking just 3 is hard man id also vote for the becoming, the big come down, the great below, the wretched, and wish if it were more than just three though
DinosaurJones 03.03.16	La Mer Right Where It Belongs Zero Sum
Cryptkeeper 03.03.16	Hurt Piggy Heresy
Middle18 03.03.16	The Perfect Drug Terrible Lie Right Where it Belongs Got a soft spot for the ballads
anarchistfish 03.03.16	and all that could have been something i can never have not so pretty now
MO 03.03.16	good to see lots of people picking Ruiner m/ ruiner wish march of the pigs their old in your face shit destroys their newer material
Pajolero 03.03.16	DOWN IN IT
Pajolero 03.03.16	All of Pretty Hate Machine really.
NakedSnake 03.03.16	Head Down My Violent Heart Lights In The Sky
Dolving999 03.03.16	You get me closer to God.
UpwardSpiral 03.03.16	Is this band any good?
Aftertheascension 03.03.16	Hurt You know what you are? Mr. Self Destruct
JeetJeet 03.03.16	Underneath It All Only We're in This Together
grannypantys 03.03.16	reptiles w're in this together
hesperus 03.03.16	Updated. It's cool to see people picking stuff from Still.
JWT155 03.03.16	Just Like You Imagined
anarchistfish 03.03.16	soz for ruining 100% artwork
hesperus 03.03.16	I can't believe I knew what that song was from. I was a much bigger NIN fan back in the day.
altertide0 03.03.16	Lol @ not so pretty now
DinosaurJones 03.03.16	Dang, I tried to edit my comment before you updated the list. Oh well.
hesperus 03.03.16	It's not like it's irreversible. Zero Sum instead of Terrible Lie, right?
Log S. 03.03.16	Heresy The Perfect Drug Where is Everybody?
onionbubs 03.03.16	the wretched is a great choice. i freaking love that song as well. It's way too hard to just pick 3
DinosaurJones 03.03.16	Yessir.
hesperus 03.03.16	Log: I'm just gonna go with the first 3 songs you listed
MadDemonofConfusion 03.03.16	Piggy Reptile Just like you imagined Fuck it doesn't break my top three but Last deserves a mention
MyNameIsPencil 03.03.16	Ghost VII
user 03.03.16	the day the world went away (still version) the fragile zero sum
ReminiscentOfAWhale 03.03.16	My whole existence is flawed!
Muppelope 03.03.16	The Becoming, The Wretched, The Warning
Tunaboy45 03.03.16	A Warm Place Ruiner Copy Of A
user 03.03.16	not trying to be (too) mean but do we need to do this for every artist [2]
hesperus 03.03.16	Just the ones with expansive enough discographies and large enough fanbases on the site. It's not like we're gonna see "Sputnik's favorite Gospel songs" or "Sputnik's favorite Justin Bieber songs" anytime soon.
onionbubs 03.03.16	id be interested to see a U2 one of these, seeing how dividing a lot of their music is for some people. the cure would be a fun one too. simply coz i like em.
hesperus 03.03.16	I'm not nearly familiar enough with either of those bands to participate, but I'd say go ahead and make one of those lists yourself.
ScorchingMerkaba 03.03.16	1. I Look Forward To Joining You Finally. 2. The Mark Has Been Made. 3. Vessel. Fuck this is hard. The whole fragile album could be on this list lol. Reptile is a good one too
DinosaurJones 03.03.16	"Sputnik's Favorite Carly Rae Jepsen songs"
evilford 03.03.16	how in the mother FUCK has no one voted for happiness in slavery yet
evilford 03.03.16	I guess my other two would be the becoming and gave up
onionbubs 03.03.16	its difficult to pick only 3, man. i like happiness in slavery quite a lot, but its not my top 3. then again, it kills me not to vote for a couple of songs, the big come down, the wretched, and wish especially.
evilford 03.03.16	yeah those are sweet. also @ OP, change gave up to physical
Royl123 03.03.16	"Hurt", "I do not want this", and "Piggy".
user 03.03.16	@ OP I mean the "the day the world went away" that is on still
evilford 03.03.16	it was hard not voting for piggy, them organs man
evilford 03.03.16	and the mark has been made. ugh
hesperus 03.03.16	user: I didn't want to add alternate versions separately, but I added a parenthetical next to your username with the specific version you wanted. Also, something weird is happening where when I go in to edit the list it erases the last few edits and I have to add them again, so I'm gonna leave the list be for a while. But keep the votes coming.
evilford 03.03.16	"The Big Come Down - LordePots" hey cool, great song but didn't take pots as a fan of that type of song
user 03.03.16	ill take it
Parallels 03.03.16	Ruiner Sin Hurt
Log S. 03.03.16	oh shit, missed that little description when i first saw this narrowed down list: heresy, the perfect drug, where is everybody?
Insurrection 03.03.16	pots has always raved about the big come down, and rightfully so
DominionMM1 03.03.16	sin wish last
furyroad97 03.04.16	I always thought Ripe (With Decay) was pretty underrated. Surprised there's only one track from Hesitation Marks, though. Anyways, here's my votes: Ripe (With Decay) Everything Head Like A Hole
Gyromania 03.04.16	that's a tough one... most of my choices would come from downward spiral tbh, but if i had to pick just one, i think it'd be closer
onionbubs 03.04.16	closer's top 10 for me. that piano at the end is so haunting, and the build to it feels even darker as well. i love the way it ties into ruiner too. incredible track.
NordicMindset 03.04.16	Terrible Lie And All That Could Have Been Ruiner
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	"hey cool, great song but didn't take pots as a fan of that type of song" i was a huge nin fanboy in my early teens and that was always my favourite song of his
Spec 03.04.16	Probably not allowed to say this but "The Hand That Feeds" "The Big Come Down" "The Day The World Went Away"
Spec 03.04.16	Was lucky enough to inherit like every album from potsy. The Fragile is the best haaaaands down.
hesperus 03.04.16	The Downward Spiral is more consistently great imo. The Fragile has some fantastic songs, but for every La Mer there's a Where Is Everybody? (sorry to people who like that song)
Gyromania 03.04.16	downward spiral crushes the fragile. the fragile has some incredibly boring songs and is a little too long
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	""The Hand That Feeds"" this is joke tho right?
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	cuz that is objectively the worst nin song ever created and i thought that this was universally accepted to be true.......... but yeah fragile is best and glad u are enjoying the discog
Log S. 03.04.16	there are far worse than that the only people i could see having that opinion are those who listen to NiN because they "hate the mainstream"
Gyromania 03.04.16	hand that feeds isn't bad imo. it's not stellar by any means but it sure as hell isn't bad. i mean, their worst song... dude, almost 90% of year zero is infinitely worse than hand that feeds
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	disagreed year zero rules hand that feeds is just a really really boring and generic song for nin standards.
user 03.04.16	nah year zero aint that bad
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	yeah year zero is conceptually one of reznors most well composed albums, aside from downward spiral of course because that is just one of the greatest concept albums of all time
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	not to be confused with ~musically~ being most well composed of course.
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	yeah i dunno i cant think of a single nin song i dislike nearly as strongly as hand that feeds there are some others i dislike but none that i flat out hate that much
TheGreatQ 03.04.16	The Becoming Vessel Down In It
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	down in it is possibly my second least fav nin song
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	lights in the sky is pretty shit too
TheGreatQ 03.04.16	Understandable, it's really different. Just something about it I love.
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	i like most of pretty hate machine but that song just rubs me the wrong way also i think its assumed we are all obligatorily discluding all of his 100 shitty one off albums like further down the spiral and fixed etc etc for 'worst song' candidates because i just pretend all that garbage doesnt exist tbh
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	oh BUT that actually reminds me of some hidden gems like 10 miles high, metal, and and all that could have been
Gyromania 03.04.16	down in it is terrible. just terrible
Gyromania 03.04.16	further down the spiral? that's a thing? had no idea
ArsMoriendi 03.04.16	Down in It is really fun, but not Trent's best or even close yeah... The Only Time is prime Pretty Hate imo
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	i also hate Physical
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	and most of the rest of broken for that matter lol
cvlts 03.04.16	The Hand That Feeds Came Back Haunted The Day The World Went Away
Gyromania 03.04.16	nin sucks; let's talk about the tea party
ArsMoriendi 03.04.16	Even Wish and Gave Up?
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	wish and gave up are the only 2 i like
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	last is ok i guess
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.04.16	wish is definitely best
hesperus 03.04.16	Updated
Snake. 03.04.16	the day the world went away
evilford 03.04.16	"i was a huge nin fanboy in my early teens and that was always my favourite song of his" always been one of mine too, just didn't make top 3
onionbubs 03.04.16	definitely my favorite track off of the fragile's right disc.
DinosaurJones 03.04.16	This list is making me realize I still haven't heard Hesitation Marks. I need to fix that.
evilford 03.04.16	personally I find it to be a travesty that three people have voted for we're in this together, and not a single person has voted for into the void or please
hesperus 03.04.16	Honestly I do too (more for Into the Void, that song is too awesome to have zero votes).
ArsMoriendi 03.04.16	Into the Void is deff my fave off of The Fragile, great song. The Big Come Down is 2nd though...so many good songs on there, and plenty of meh ones too...
hesperus 03.05.16	Everyone's votes seem to be in for the most part, so I reordered the songs by number of votes, then by chronology. If people want to keep voting I'll probably update it, but for now it looks like Sputnik's unequivocal favorite NIN song is Ruiner.
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.05.16	interesting