SCREAM!
02.12.16 | Voting still open on round 1 since we're stuck with a tie! |
TheSpirit
02.12.16 | i need to listen to both of these.... looking forward to doing so later. |
SCREAM!
02.12.16 | I find both have their shares of great parts where everything seems to click and parts where it doesn't and they sort of drag.
Vemod sounds more consistent though but I've heard it quite a few times and have only listened to Black Howling once so I'll listen more before I vote. |
TheSpirit
02.12.16 | Started listening to 2 first, and I'm impressed. It started out kind of mediocre and then that guitar solo came in and since then it's been so much better. Digging the production as well. |
Hawks
02.12.16 | Jammed 1 last night and it's pretty sweet. Will jam 2 either tonight or early tomorrow. m/ |
SCREAM!
02.12.16 | @Spirit That's what I'm talking about. It started off sounding like really generic atmos bm then it hits it's stride but then it sort of goes up and down like that with some really great parts and some really dull ones.
Will have to relisten anyway |
Gameofmetal
02.12.16 | 2 is good but im leaning towards my pick rn |
hal1ax
02.12.16 | Oh sweet new round. Will listen to 1 after work tonight. Who won round 1?
Lol just read that first post. Disregard^^ |
SCREAM!
02.12.16 | The way things are going round 1 might get decided by a coin flip |
hal1ax
02.12.16 | damn, i rly like 1. gonna be close for me. need to re-listen |
hal1ax
02.13.16 | i'm voting for 2.
was close for me but i feel like the weak parts in 1 were worse than those in 2. The full ambient track in 1 felt rly mediocre. |
Hawks
02.13.16 | Agreed hard. 2 will have to wait til tomorrow for me then I'll cast my vote. |
ScuroFantasma
02.13.16 | Liked them both but I'm voting for 2. Much more balanced and consistent imo. Plus like you guys mentioned that ambient track on 1 is kinda underwhelming. Bass on 2 is much better as well and that's a draw for me. That said when I was listening to 1 I dug it a lot and kinda expected I'd be voting for it.
Anyway, my vote is for 2 |
SCREAM!
02.13.16 | That ambient track is what is keeping me from voting for 1. Will relisten to both today and vote |
SCREAM!
02.13.16 | So yeah it's close. Both of these are in the 3.5 range for me but I'm giving it to 1 |
p4p
02.13.16 | 1 |
Nazzadan
02.13.16 | Disregard, listening to both again for final decision |
Hawks
02.13.16 | Voting doesn't close for this until tomorrow right? I won't be able to jam until the morning haha. |
SCREAM!
02.14.16 | Yeah we settled on two day rounds so that's tomorrow |
Nazzadan
02.14.16 | Alright, 2. Final answer. |
TheSpirit
02.14.16 | I'm thinking I'm going with 2 on this one as well. |
Deathconscious
02.14.16 | i dont find either of them to be very impressive but 2 is a little better with some moments of greatness, so thats where my vote is going. |
SCREAM!
02.14.16 | 2 has a solid(ish) lead going it seems |
Gameofmetal
02.14.16 | black howling grew on me more, honestly really close for me but i think i still like vemod a little more. never had an qualm with the ambient track |
SpiritCrusher2
02.14.16 | I liked both of these, but I have to go with 2 |
Hawks
02.14.16 | Still gotta jam 2 again, but I'm still voting for it. |
Mystletainn
02.14.16 | Listening to 1 now and on first track, I don't mind the clean vox here at all. |
Mystletainn
02.14.16 | my vote goes to 1 |
Hawks
02.15.16 | Ok yeah 2 wins this round by a landslide for me. |
Deathconscious
02.15.16 | so 3 to 6 so far by my count. |
ZippaThaRippa
02.16.16 | 2, absolutely |