ZackSh33
12.25.15 | Merry Crimble, everybody!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oW6nZyJSERw |
evilford
12.25.15 | John lennon beat women no joke [2]
Sorry to rain on ur parade |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | Amazing ranking. 1 is my favorite too. "I Am the Walrus" is my favorite song by them. |
ZackSh33
12.25.15 | @evilford unfortunate but true
@Ars, thanks man. Glad you appreciate 1 as much as I do. |
Relinquished
12.25.15 | enjoyed the list man, continue with the good times |
Asdfp277
12.25.15 | john lennon beat his wife |
ZackSh33
12.25.15 | @relinquished - thanks for reading, glad you enjoyed it. Now that these guys are on Spotify, the good times will undoubtedly continue haha |
wtferrothorn
12.25.15 | evilford beat yea to the punch asdf. btw sweet list man |
evilford
12.25.15 | In any case they made gr7 music no doubt, rubber soul and Sgt pepper all the way |
Mystletainn
12.25.15 | *Growing up with a beatle |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | "john lennon beat his wife"
AND made great music. Assoles can make good art, hell many amazing artists are fucked up people. |
Asdfp277
12.25.15 | i just copypasted acad's name on the review site but ok |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | "The beatles suck, their fans suck more, and I'm glad John Lennon died."
That's cute coming from a guy whose biggest pie chart slice is progressive metal. |
Asdfp277
12.25.15 | but ok, you can come here and react like that, like, half an hour late, on christmas of all times |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | "There's nothing cute about it. I firmly believe if the beatles never existed the world would be a better place."
lmao you make The Beatles sound like Hitler. Please stop. |
ZackSh33
12.25.15 | CHRISTMAS. IS. CANCELLED. |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | We're all on the naughty list. Sputnik doesn't have nice members :) |
ZackSh33
12.25.15 | i've heard stories about them existing but those are just myths...right?? |
Asdfp277
12.25.15 | the beetles invented boybands tho
"That's cute coming from a guy whose biggest pie chart slice is progressive metal"
-you haven't even heard any any album made in the last two decades who are u to judge
|
Mystletainn
12.25.15 | Sputnik not nice? I've met nothing but the nicest people on this website, we're all a happy family |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | "the beetles invented boybands tho"
I hope you're kidding because they're not even a boy band. The Osmonds, The Jackson 5, and The Monkees are considered to be the first boybands...
"you haven't even heard any music that's been made in the last two decades who are u to judge"
That would mean I haven't heard anything after 1995... which is far from true. |
Asdfp277
12.25.15 | isn't the monkeys just a shitty rip off of the beetles tho
wake up, they are the first boyband |
user
12.25.15 | what a wonderfully derailed thread
awesome list, though. love your dad's quote on sgt pepper--gave me some legit good vibes in context of the list. |
Asdfp277
12.25.15 | spado is just taking the piss tho, but get more defensive if you can |
ZackSh33
12.25.15 | yeah i gotta agree the beatles kind of invented the idea of an "attractive" rock band |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | "spado is just taking the piss tho, but get more defensive if you can"
It's hard to when the guy's obviously trolling, your comments bothered me more honestly. |
ZackSh33
12.25.15 | @user i get that same sort of vibe- making this list was a lot of fun and brought back a lot of good memories, I'm really happy people feel the same way when they listen to these guys |
Asdfp277
12.25.15 | they pretty much got known that way, converting into a boyband by a manager didn't they |
ZackSh33
12.25.15 | they had it all dude. the best part of their career is that they evolved and escaped the mop-top/fab-four classification, imagine if they hadn't |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | Boybands don't write their own lyrics or compose their own music though. The Beatles are no more of a boy band than The Kinks or The Rolling Stones. |
Asdfp277
12.25.15 | ars: that's u imposing that characterization, and you're completely ignoring cultural context within the music industry at the time and the way people consumed music back then. and i'm not particularly fond of the rolling stones so it's not really gonna help your case lol |
ZackSh33
12.25.15 | a lot of things changed in 50 years - all three of the bands you named started out by doing covers and then wrote their own stuff. No one in their right mind would let any of the boy bands of today write their own music. They're in it for their looks more than for their supposed singing abilities |
ZackSh33
12.25.15 | and Beatles > Rolling Stones no doubt about it |
Asdfp277
12.25.15 | it's not even controversial stuff, what bothers me is that you so blindly love the beetles that you even refuse to acknowledge reality |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | "and you're completely ignoring cultural context within the music industry at the time and the way people consumed music back then."
No, trust me I have a good point. It's like the people who try to argue that proto-punk acts are punk acts when they aren't. I'll agree that The Beatles can be seen as a proto-boyband, but definitely not an actual boy band. |
Asdfp277
12.25.15 | again, you're the one makings those specific characterizations, and it's no coincidence that you're doing them when discussing this band in particular
love them as much as you want, but don't blind yourself to reality to keep that perfect image of them, you're going on this pointless argument trying to cite overly specific characterizations for that purpose only |
evilford
12.25.15 | How bout some pumpkin pie guys |
Mystletainn
12.25.15 | Pumpkin pie n vodka |
theacademy
12.25.15 | john lennon, the paragon of peace and love, beat his wife and his band was a shitty blink-182 ripoff
mccartneys cleans were garbage as well
merry xmas guys
|
evilford
12.25.15 | U too brow |
ZackSh33
12.25.15 | @academy it all makes so much sense now
merry xmas to you as well! |
RosaParks
12.25.15 | awful band |
Frippertronics
12.25.15 | ars fails to realize spado is a flyhead alt gg |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | Oh flyhead is back? Lame |
theacademy
12.25.15 | lmae* |
alienobserver
12.25.15 | lmae tbh |
SharkTooth
12.25.15 | And here I was thinking flyhead disappeared off the face of the earth
Btw John was married twice and beat both his wives |
ZackSh33
12.25.15 | Thanks for the feature! |
Asdfp277
12.25.15 | why would anybody hit their spouse |
Asdfp277
12.25.15 | you're pathetic |
SharkTooth
12.25.15 | Flyhead alt confirmed |
Ocean of Noise
12.25.15 | I love this list. :) |
SharkTooth
12.25.15 | I love this thread :) |
Ocean of Noise
12.25.15 | I mean yeah John beat women and was generally an asshole but that doesn't make this music any less great. |
SharkTooth
12.25.15 | Agreed |
stranger
12.25.15 | so many abuse sympathizers
bet you guys are greg hardy fans too |
Ocean of Noise
12.25.15 | Dude I can only speak for myself but I'm definitely not an abuse sympathizer. I just happen to believe that it's stupid to dislike someone's music because of who they were.
If the appreciation of art depends entirely on the personalities of its creators, then what the fuck is its purpose? |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | Duh, a lot of assholes are musically brilliant. Just look at Billy Corgan or Van Morrison. |
Ocean of Noise
12.25.15 | or Varg Vikernes... |
SharkTooth
12.25.15 | Idk what stranger's reading but I never detected any abuse support itt |
Ocean of Noise
12.25.15 | I feel like a lot of people use their dislike for artists as people to justify their dislike for the art they create. And that's a slippery slope. If you don't like someone's music, that's fine, but don't pull the personal life of the artist into your opinion.
If John wrote songs glorifying spousal abuse, I would see this a bit differently. But he didn't. His songs (the ones I know, anyway) exist separately from that, and therefore shouldn't be judged in terms of that. |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | The only "John's asshole personality spread to the lyrics" songs are in his solo career anyway and are targeted at politicians, Paul and for 1 song George. |
SharkTooth
12.25.15 | I know right? Don't hate the Beatles just for John |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | John's still my favorite Beatle music wise, even if he's my least favorite personality wise. So many of his songs are my favorites... |
SharkTooth
12.25.15 | George is my favorite musically |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | George is my #2
Music: John > George > Paul > Ringo
Personality: Ringo > Paul > George > John
lol it's almost like a correlation. |
wtferrothorn
12.25.15 | Been in a real big Beatles kick since they were added to Spotify. Sgt. Peppers is still my fave so far, but Abbey Road is amazing too. |
SharkTooth
12.25.15 | Agreed Ringo is the coolest of the 4 |
wtferrothorn
12.25.15 | He's also the best artist of the four
http://blogs.artinfo.com/artintheair/files/2012/06/ringoart.jpg |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | I'm forever a Magical Mystery Tour lover, such a fun album. Then again anything post-Help! is great. |
SharkTooth
12.25.15 | "http://blogs.artinfo.com/artintheair/files/2012/06/ringoart.jpg"
Damn those MS Paint skills |
Ocean of Noise
12.25.15 | if I had to rank the Beatles' members musically I'd say Paul > George > John > Ringo |
SharkTooth
12.25.15 | TO THINK THE PEOPLE WOULDVE HAD ENOUGH OF SILLY LOVE SONGS
-literally the only song of Paul's solo career I'm familiar with |
Ocean of Noise
12.25.15 | lol idgaf about any of their solo careers tbqh |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | "literally the only song of Paul's solo career I'm familiar with"
Live and Let Die? Maybe I'm Amazed? Simply Having A Wonderful Christmas Time?
|
onionbubs
12.25.15 | George > Paul > John >>>>>>>>>>>>>Ringo
George has some really great work all throughout his career. Paul and John both had pretty hit or miss albums, but Band on the Run, Venus and Mars, RAM, Imagine, and Walls and Bridges are all solid. And I can't make it through a full ringo album, but i like a couple of his songs. |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | Only solo career I checked was John's and John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band is easily the best of those, but I also really like the John moments of Sometime in New York City |
onionbubs
12.25.15 | ^some stuff on Plastic Ono bores me, but God, Isolation, and Working Class Hero are great songs.
|
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | Hold On is my favorite.
COOKIE |
SharkTooth
12.25.15 | "Live and Let Die? Maybe I'm Amazed? Simply Having A Wonderful Christmas Time?"
None of them ring a bell |
stranger
12.25.15 | how is that even possible
yr pleb is showing |
SharkTooth
12.25.15 | Idk but I've met bigger plebs than myself irl
Just sayin' |
ArsMoriendi
12.25.15 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ma8OhzFdIA Only Paul solo song I actually care about honestly. |
ZackSh33
12.25.15 | COOKIE [2] |
Snake.
12.26.15 | why is this featured |
ZackSh33
12.26.15 | turn it around: why wouldn't it be? |
SharkTooth
12.26.15 | Seems pretty feature worthy to me |
evilford
12.27.15 | "I mean yeah John beat women and was generally an asshole but that doesn't make this music any less great."
I don't think anyone said that. ??? Unless I missed it. Just saying a lot of people and rabid fans take the individuals themselves as representatives of the qualities preached in their music and that's just factually wrong. Doesn't make their music less great, it rules, it's just interesting how much of a hypocrite lennon was. |
SharkTooth
12.27.15 | What exactly did Lennon himself do for world peace other than lie in bed for a week tho?
Honestly he didn't do that much, he was just getting increasingly full of himself as the years went on. |
Flugmorph
12.27.15 | Very nice reading through this man. I only discovered the beatles recently for myself ( and i also liked magical mystery tour the most so far). |
MO
12.27.15 | awesome list
I pretty much experienced the Beatles in the same way with my mom who played them all the time when I was younger. Definitely helped shape my music taste |
user
12.27.15 | "why is this featured"
cause it's a great list. |
Asdfp277
12.27.15 | What exactly did Lennon himself do for world peace other than lie in bed for a week tho? [2] |
user
12.29.15 | made people come together to discuss how terrible emotive by a perfect circle is |