PillowGuy: 3D Zelda Games Ranked

Atari 03.14.14	I'd say wind waker is higher but i love them all
FearTomorrow 03.14.14	1 > 4 > 2 > 5 > > 3 for me
Wadlez 03.14.14	Wind Waker's a masterpiece.
Rhyme 03.14.14	twilight princess over wind waker is a crime
ArsMoriendi 03.14.14	Wind Waker and Skyward Sword should be higher than Twilight Princes. Put Twilight at the bottom and the list is spot on.
PillowGuy 03.14.14	Twilight Princess is criminally underrated. Wind Waker isn't as good as people make it out to be.
Wadlez 03.14.14	Yes, it is. Gotta love the graphics in Windwaker.
PillowGuy 03.14.14	No, it isn't. Had the worst dungeons out of all the 3D Zeldas.
Wadlez 03.14.14	There are other elements to a Zelda game..
PillowGuy 03.14.14	And Wind Waker does no more of a better job at them than Twilight Princess, besides maybe the overworld.
Friday13th 03.14.14	2 easily, but Majora's Mask is awesome and just a year later omg. That's when Nintendo knew what they were doing.
climactic 03.14.14	majoras had the worst dungeons. but the best atmosphere, and probs the best pre-dungeon stages id go OoT MM TP Ww never played ss
mryrtmrnfoxxxy 03.14.14	4235 havent played much of mm
SharkTooth 03.14.14	2>all others
Kalopsia 03.14.14	i'd switch 3 and 4, but otherwise list is spot on
Ending 03.14.14	Haven't played 5 but 1-4 yep.
kris. 03.14.14	1 2 4 3 5 is the correct rank majora's mask is god-tier and if you think otherwise then you're a filthy peasant
PillowGuy 03.14.14	"majoras had the worst dungeons." Stone Tower Temple was better than any dungeon/temple in WW.
Avagantamos 03.14.14	TP is incredible
Rev 03.14.14	Wind Waker Majora's Mask Ocarina of Time Skyward Sword Twilight Princess
Atari 03.14.14	doesn't seem to be any love for skyward sword
Wadlez 03.14.14	Age definitely factors into a person's ranking in this case.
PillowGuy 03.14.14	"doesn't seem to be any love for skyward sword" Or TP, for that matter.
Atari 03.14.14	true true. I like TP but being a wolf bugged me at times
mryrtmrnfoxxxy 03.14.14	skyward sword was infuriating
Atari 03.14.14	why? it's not my favorite, but still an excellent game
climactic 03.14.14	Swamp temple is annoying, ice temple has a cooll design but is also kinda annoying, Water temple is shit, and yea stone temple rules
emester 03.14.14	my order wind waker majora ocarina Twilight Skyward
Faraudo 03.14.14	Ocarina is 1 for me.
Atari 03.14.14	Wind Waker looked beautiful in HD
climactic 03.14.14	ocarina is THE game
Atari 03.14.14	playing ocarina of time on 3DS right now and I enjoy it more than the original. Just the thought of playing OOT on a handheld was enough for me, but it exceeded my expectations.
climactic 03.14.14	sounds awesome but i havent cared about nintendo handhelds in like 5 years. might replay the original OoT soon though or master quest
RivalSkoomaDealer 03.14.14	I really need to get around to playing the Wii Zeldas...
WashboardSuds 03.14.14	ocarina >> twilight >> ww >> skyward >> majora all are masterpieces though
Necrotica 03.14.14	Where's TSoP
FearTomorrow 03.14.14	Majora had some of the best dungeons ever damn
Nikkolae 03.14.14	Majora hands down and if you dont like the time thing you can get bent
WashboardSuds 03.14.14	the time thing was fine but I found it made some parts of the game more frustrating than they needed to be, like the town quests
Nikkolae 03.14.14	it wasnt nearly as frustrating as travelling to/from Farone/eldin/lanayru on SS
WashboardSuds 03.14.14	agreed with that much. but I still liked getting around in faron/eldin/lanayru themselves more than I did termina, and ss has the better dungeons/bosses for me. blasphemous I know but oh well
Graveyard 03.14.14	majora's mask over everything
Muisc4Life26 03.15.14	2 is 1 for me
TheAshes 03.15.14	I'm probably the only one here that thinks mm is just plain overrated
kris. 03.15.14	jom showing how much of a peasant he really is what a shame
WashboardSuds 03.15.14	"I'm probably the only one here that thinks mm is just plain overrated" no way jose honestly at one point I would have said either MM or WW were the best but I overplayed them a both a lot so if I weren't a little jaded MM would easily be at least 2nd
emester 03.15.14	i wouldent call LBW a 3d zelda Its still one of my favorites tho
TheAshes 03.15.14	sorry Washboard but everything else on this list except for ss shits all over that game. a dark atmosphere & story isn't enough to make up for the fact that the adventure itself just pales compared to nearly everything else in the series. the only dungeon that's really great is the stone tower.
emester 03.15.14	WW was more about the open world than the dungeons even though they were still fantastic
Gyromania 03.15.14	majora's mask is my favourite too, but i think skyword sword is better than twilight princess. that said, they're all amazing
FearTomorrow 03.15.14	Twilight Sward is pretty average for a Zelda game imo
Crymsonblaze 03.15.14	i guess ocarina wind waker then the rest THEN the awful ds 3d ones but i don't really like the 3d zeldas, i prefer all of the 2d ones to any of the 3d ones (cd-i excluded obviously)
Gyromania 03.15.14	no way - it's the darkest zelda game besides majora's mask
Gyromania 03.15.14	the 3ds rendition of ocarina of time is so much better wtf? lol
FearTomorrow 03.15.14	Felt like it tries a bit too hard to be dark, felt forced. The wolf segments and shadow world parts just seemed so tacked on. Shame because it had some awesome story elements, and Midna was a great character. All that said, I never finished it... really oughta.
Crymsonblaze 03.15.14	lttp (obviously) awakening oracles four sword adventures lbw minish cap loz four swords adventure of link
Crymsonblaze 03.15.14	yeah twilight princess is pretty much garbage
FearTomorrow 03.15.14	Hey now
Crymsonblaze 03.15.14	nah it's not that bad, just way way WAY too slow
WashboardSuds 03.15.14	"sorry Washboard but everything else on this list except for ss shits all over that game. a dark atmosphere & story isn't enough to make up for the fact that the adventure itself just pales compared to nearly everything else in the series. the only dungeon that's really great is the stone tower." I know I put it last but I still really disagree with this. actually I'm gonna revise my ranking here (first list wasn't definite anyway) ocarina >> majora >> twilight >> wind waker >> skyward honestly it's hard for me to rank skyward accurately in this list because it's sort of a black sheep if you think about it
MisterTornado 03.15.14	cosmo shout out
WashboardSuds 03.15.14	wtf peeple twilight princess has a little bit of everything, the scope of ocarina of time, the twisted alt reality thing of LttP, and the almost twisted nature of Majora. really excellent game
pkrhawk7 03.15.14	Am I the only one that loved Skyward Sword?
Gyromania 03.15.14	it is insofar as it being so vibrantly colourful and what not, but it's still very much a zelda game
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.15.14	fuck this shit majora and orcarina are both classic as fuck tied for number 1 wind waker is next all the other ones were not a part of my childhood and therefore come after in whatever order u want doesnt matter ive been playin the minish cap shits pretty good
PunchforPunch 03.15.14	wind waker over ocarina? that's kinda fucked up demi
FearTomorrow 03.15.14	it's kinda true, idk they're basically tied but all I know for sure is that Majora is 1
WashboardSuds 03.15.14	wind waker has the most clear artistic vision methinks. fuck I really want the HD remake
FearTomorrow 03.15.14	Definitely had the most fun world to explore at least, and exploration is my favourite
WashboardSuds 03.15.14	"Definitely had the most fun world to explore at least, and exploration is my favourite" agreed, and on that note I don't get the hate for the triforce quest. I think that's the point where the game really gets you invested in the exploration
FearTomorrow 03.15.14	Yeah, and you discover so much other shit while doing it. Really encourages and rewards the player for exploring. Also enjoyed the sailing, found it quite atmospheric, and like I said there's always stuff to find along the way. People who act like the overworld is just a huge empty ocean obviously didn't do enough looking around.
WashboardSuds 03.15.14	"Also enjoyed the sailing, found it quite atmospheric, and like I said there's always stuff to find along the way. People who act like the overworld is just a huge empty ocean obviously didn't do enough looking around." this hard
GreyShadow 03.15.14	Twilight Princess is my fav, the adventure aspect in a game has never felt more real to me.
botb 03.15.14	lol at anyone who ranks mm as the highest
FearTomorrow 03.15.14	lol at you pleb
Lord(e)Po)))ts 03.15.14	nah majora had the coolest world, also coolest... well coolest fucking everything tbh
kris. 03.15.14	potsy is forever correct
PunchforPunch 03.21.14	Hey what about LTTP and TMC
MO 03.21.14	ocarina = mm > ww >>>> tp >>>>>>>>>>>>>>ss
Underflow 03.21.14	Major props for getting 1.