PunchforPunch: Ac/dc Or Guns N' Roses?

PunchforPunch 02.17.14	2 is my fave
Rowan5215 02.17.14	Dude they're both 5s how can I
ExcentrifugalForz 02.17.14	If they both were coming to town and doing free promotional shows the same Friday night and even were passing out free candy. I wouldn't go to either.
SitarHero 02.17.14	Damn. So edgy.
PunchforPunch 02.17.14	same
zakalwe 02.17.14	Acca Dacca by the longest stretch.
emprorzurg 02.17.14	please, 14 year old girls who think it's cool to like 'old bands' call AC/DC acca dacca, never do it again. thank you
JamieTwort 02.17.14	G'N'R cos Appetite.
ButteryBiscuitBass 02.17.14	AC/DC cos Dirty Deeds Done Dirt Cheap is legit best album ever.
zakalwe 02.17.14	Acca Dacca (I'm a 14yr old gobby tart zurg, deal with it son)
Davil667 02.17.14	Appetite is a classic, but so is Powerage and Highway imo... The Bon Scott era as a whole was fantastic so my vote goes to AC/DC.
emprorzurg 02.17.14	you'd be a pretty awesome 14yr old gobby tart zakalwe, your music taste rocks
tommygun 02.17.14	both shite
Rice303 02.17.14	AC/DC, I've never been a massive fan of anything Guns And Roses besides Appetite For Destruction
JamieTwort 02.17.14	Bon Scott-era AC/DC rules but Appetite destroys every album AC/DC have ever made.
PunchforPunch 02.17.14	ballbreaker is 4.5 tho
manosg 02.17.14	AC/DC because of sheer volume of Bon Scott-era material.
PunchforPunch 02.17.14	u don't like Fly on the Wall manosg? "both shite" H-how could you!?
Davil667 02.17.14	Appetite is without a doubt a class of its own, but it’s also the only GnR album I can listen to from beginning to end. The sheer volume of great AC/DC songs makes my decision an easy one here...
manosg 02.17.14	"u don't like Fly on the Wall manosg?" I actually have at 3 so I don't hate it lol. My least favorite are Blow Up Your Video and Black Ice.
rockandmetaljunkie 02.17.14	AC/DC because they were more consistent. Although, I love AFD more than any other AC/DC album.
SitarHero 02.17.14	The UYI's were inconsistent, but there were some great fucking songs on there. Axl, despite all his other failings, is a superb lyricist, for the most part.
tempest-- 02.17.14	appetite rules but ac/dc are way more consistent so ac/dc and bon scott played the recorder in this weird ass prog rock band before he joined ac/dc so yea
menawati 02.17.14	ac/dc bcos bon scott and dirty deeds done dirt cheap
VermTheImpaler 02.17.14	AC/DC is the most overrated band ever, not bad but they don´t have diversity and unlike motorhead their music bore me to the death. Lies, appetite and illusion 1 and 2 rapes AC/DC
DominionMM1 02.17.14	ac/dc man. highway and powerage destroy anything gnr has done.
VermTheImpaler 02.17.14	Reckless life, anything made by ac/dc. Coma rapes everything, is raw and destructive, more than TNT. Not saying that AC/DC is bad but is the most overrated classic rock band ever, I love classic rock but this band is far from being at the same level of other titans, sure is influential but is by far less interesting than most of their contemporaries
BigHans 02.17.14	Appetite is best album ever Highway and Powerage are close. Both are basically the best band ever.
JamieTwort 02.17.14	Appetite is best album ever [2]
BigHans 02.17.14	I say that all the time but Appetite really is the best album ever
StallionMang 02.17.14	both shite [2]
menawati 02.17.14	maybe closer comparison would be gunsnroses vs aerosmith
BigHans 02.17.14	As hard as Aerosmith have sucked for the last 25 years, you can't deny Toys in the Attic, Get Your Wings, and Rocks are indisputable classics.
JamieTwort 02.17.14	Hard.
BigHans 02.17.14	Sorry, meant 35 years. Aside from Pump, anything post 70s Aersomith sucks hard.
Weirman 02.17.14	GN'R has like one semi-decent album, while ac/dc have like 7 soooooo
InbredJed 02.17.14	AC/DC obv
menawati 02.17.14	"Toys in the Attic, Get Your Wings, and Rocks are indisputable classics." the debut too, and draw the line bcos it was such a screwed up druggie mess that had Kings and Queens on
BigHans 02.17.14	Debut is near classic, Draw The Line is terrible aside from Kings and Queens and the title track imo. In their autobiography they were so drugged out when writing that album Tyler didnt even recognize his own songs. Perry told a story where Tyler heard You See Me Crying on the radio and asked him who it was.
menawati 02.17.14	i like draw the line bcos its so loose and all over the place, slide guitar on get it up is cool
FearTomorrow 02.17.14	AC/DC all the way. 70's AC/DC is the shit. GNR had some good stuff, but weren't nearly as consistent or fun.
Chortles 02.17.14	Dx
DikkoZinner 02.17.14	AC/DC Bon Scott >
VermTheImpaler 02.17.14	Aerosmith in the 70´s was the shit, still enjoy some of permanent vacation, pump and get a grip stuff which is enjoyable as hell.
BigHans 02.17.14	dude Verm Get a Grip is so awful. Maybe I just hate it because when it came out it was a huge album, really hyped and overplayed. That and it had 3 ballads that sounded identical that constantly got played on the radio.
VermTheImpaler 02.17.14	How old are you hans , 35 I guess
DominionMM1 02.17.14	"Maybe I just hate it because when it came out it was a huge album, really hyped and overplayed. That and it had 3 ballads that sounded identical that constantly got played on the radio." agreed. but livin on the edge was great.
BigHans 02.17.14	33. Around here that makes me a fucking senior citizen.
DominionMM1 02.17.14	besides i dug those videos cuz alicia silverstone
BigHans 02.17.14	Living on the Edge was pretty cool, it was the lead single. Then it was Cryin, which was ok for a bit. Then it was Its Amazing, which is a cross between the previous two songs. Then it was Crazy, which is Cryin lite, which sucks. I think they released Eat The Rich but nobody played it, ironic as its my favorite jam on the album.
MalleusMaleficarum 02.17.14	ac dc is waaaaaaaayy better
JamieTwort 02.17.14	Eat the Rich is a pretty cool song.
BigHans 02.17.14	Fever was a single too I think.
JamieTwort 02.17.14	I dig Draw the Line. It's kinda all over the place but it has some good jams.
BigHans 02.17.14	Its too bad they didnt combine the Illusions, it would have been a stone cold 5. Without accounting for play length and the 80 minute limitation, would be something like this: 1. Civil War 2. Yesterdays 3. Coma 4. Dead Horse 5. You Could Be Mine 6. Get in the Ring 7. Don't Cry (Illusion 1 version) 7. November Rain 8. Breakdown 9. Estranged 10. Back Off Bitch 11. Live and Let Die 12. Don't Damn Me 13. Knockin On Heavens Door 14. Right Next Door to Hell
JamieTwort 02.17.14	Fuck yes that would be almost Appetite level.
BigHans 02.17.14	both of Slash's solos in Breakdown destroy, especially the 2nd one.
Davil667 02.17.14	Locomotive and Get in the Ring rule hard.
BigHans 02.17.14	When the Illusions came out I was in 6th grade an living off a $5/week allowance. So I only had enough money to pick one of them to buy when they first dropped. I picked 2, because Get in the Ring hard. Probably the hardest decision Ive ever had to make m/
Insurrection 02.17.14	GNR. ACDC is just awful
SitarHero 02.17.14	Hans' UYI playlist bring the truth. Dont damn me is one of the most underrated hardrock songs ever.
Snake. 02.17.14	opeth
mandan 02.17.14	Not a big GN'R fan, so I'll go with AC/DC.
jmnewcomer18 02.17.14	Both shite [3]
PunchforPunch 02.17.14	the fuck, this got more comments than havey awesome list? bunch of smelly, bad breath, dad rock maniacs.
SirDrumsalot 02.17.14	They both suck. But GnR at least has a few good songs...so I guess GnR.
BigHans 02.17.14	the fuck, this got more comments than havey awesome list? bunch of smelly, bad breath, dad rock maniacs. ^What the fuck man, when you make a list talking about two of the best bands ever its bound to overcome whatever pussy bands was on that list you were bitching about.
chemicalmarriage 02.17.14	ac/dc