|
User
Reviews 1 Approval 70%
Soundoffs 37 News Articles 3 Band Edits + Tags 43 Album Edits 46
Album Ratings 1184 Objectivity 87%
Last Active 07-06-18 5:38 pm Joined 10-04-10
Review Comments 10,673
| Coheed And Cambria Ranked
All of their albums ranked. You'll probably disagree. Would love to hear your ropinions. | | 7 |  | Coheed and Cambria Year of the Black Rainbow
This should come as no surprise. One could argue that by the end of the original
saga, CoCa were already on the down swing. Many fans were less than satisfied
with the conclusion of No World For Tomorrow. After the fever pitch of FFTTEOM,
NWFT was more of a guttering candle than a blazing climax. YOTBR was something
of a creative slump for a band. They were clearly searching for new direction and
struggling to find it. While Pennie's addition to the band infused some impressive
technicality, his drumming lacked the lively quality of Eppard's. YOTBR is a desert of
an album; low on all of the things that make CoCa great. The only tracks of any
note are World of Lines and Here We Are Juggernaut. And let's face it, Juggernaut
is only great because of one killer line. | | 6 |  | Coheed and Cambria The Afterman: Ascension
Though it certainly marked a comeback for CoCa, Ascension wasn't quite there yet.
It proved that Claudio and company could still write sprawling 8 minute epics (see
Domino the Destitute). Unfortunately, Ascension suffered from being too uneven.
There are as many strong songs as there are forgettable clunkers. Ultimately,
Ascension is too short and underdeveloped to live up to CoCa's previous efforts.
One of the more interesting tracks is Holly Wood: The Cracked. It's like the spiritual
successor of Al the Killer. Dark, discordant riffing fused to an infectiously catchy
chorus. | | 5 |  | Coheed and Cambria No World For Tomorrow
At one point in my life, this was my favorite CoCa album. It did not age gracefully.
Though it's far from being their weakest, it has little to offer outside of its catchy
pop-rock singles. It's clear that CoCa were trying to open themselves up to a more
mainstream audience while taking a step away from their progressive roots. Though
the End Complete is a stunning track, the rest of the four part suite falls flat on its
face. The album starts out strong but near the end it becomes a tiring exercise. | | 4 |  | Coheed and Cambria From Fear Through the Eyes of Madness
"Why the fuck isn't this higher?" Yeah I don't really know either. Though I've been
listening to this album for years something about it still puts me off. One of the
main problems I have with this album is the beginning. The combination of Always
and Never/Welcome Home is so explosively strong that it leaves the rest of the
album wanting in comparison. It's literally too good. The rest of the album's
sprawling length fails to recapture that feverish energy. That's not to say that this
isn't a fantastic album. The Suffering and The Final Cut are two of my favorite
CoCa tracks of all time. On a side note, this album could use way less of the
bloopity sound effect bullshit. If you cut all of the mindless electronic wankery the
album would be a good ten minutes shorter. P.S. the title track is fucking amazing. | | 3 |  | Coheed and Cambria The Afterman: Descension
Unlike Ascension, Descension just clicked for me. Nearly every song achieves what
it's striving for with flying colors. From the heavy handed riffing of Sentry the
Defiant to the gleeful poppiness of Number City, Descension is a triumphant return
to form. Though it ends on a rather low note, Descension's meaty middle section is
more than enough to make up for it. I can't write about this album without
mentioning the absolutely glorious Gravity's. Coheed and Cambria haven't
written a song like that in years. | | 2 |  | Coheed and Cambria In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3
Where do I even begin? From start to finish, Silent Earth 3 is a monster of a record.
There's something here for everyone. Claudio is in top form, howling his gruesome
lyrics with delightful abandon. The guitars alternate between slabs of proggy
goodness and saccharine sweet pop riffs. Eppard and Todd deliver a solid backbone
with crushing basslines and beastly chops. In addition to being a great studio
record, night 2 is easily the highlight of Neverender. The live edition of the title
track is mind-numbing in it's greatness. Al the Killer is nastier than its ever been.
Three Evils, The Crowing and Blood Red Summer are like the holy trinity of catchy
awesomeness. | | 1 |  | Coheed and Cambria The Second Stage Turbine Blade
At one time, this was easily my least favorite Coheed record. I didn't understand
the hype. At some point two years ago, it finally clicked. I think it was Everything
Evil that finally did it for me. The raw emotion, the frenetic riffing and the grisly
story-telling took me by surprise. It's the little imperfections that make the album
great; The cracks in Claudio's voice, the ugliness of the screams, the fuzzy
production, even the uneven songwriting. Words don't really do it justice. Again,
the Neverender performance of this album is stunning. The guitar tone in the
opening notes of Delirium Trigger is delicious. Neverender (the song) explodes with
life and passion. | |
ZippaThaRippa
01.04.14 | MAN YOUR OWN JACKHAMMER | BigPleb
01.04.14 | shit list and shit band | ZippaThaRippa
01.04.14 | @ThirtySixChambers
For sure. I felt exactly the same way after YOTBR. I didn't want to listen to anything Coheed after that monstrosity of an album. Descension really changed my mind. They're not what they used to be but they're finally good again! | CalculatingInfinity
01.04.14 | "MAN YOURRR DATTLE BATTLE STATIONSSS" WE'LL HAVE YOU DEAD PRETTY SOON............and now... | RFO13
01.04.14 | Love this band but NWFT is awful | Artuma
01.04.14 | "WE'LL HAVE YOU DEAD PRETTY SOON............and now..." SINCERELY, WRITTEN FROM MY BROTHER'S BLOOD MACHINE | BigPleb
01.04.14 | this guy has horrible vocals and the songwriting is beyond pretentious, prob worst band ever actually. | BigPleb
01.04.14 | at sucking dicks ya | adr
01.04.14 | yea band is so overrated. | ZippaThaRippa
01.04.14 | @BigPleb
www.youtube.com/watch?v=5adF0xlvM_U | dmp3131
01.04.14 | Band rules and I kick myself for not listening to their discography yet. Only heard 2-6. | BigPleb
01.04.14 | dont yt link me in hope that it will change my mind | CalculatingInfinity
01.04.14 | The band is overrated but they've still pulled off some great stuff. | RFO13
01.04.14 | @dmp Dude, you have to listen to SSTB. Idk why you have not but you must. | dmp3131
01.04.14 | I've heard they are one of the better live bands out there...and again, kicking myself for missing Uproar this year... Alice in Chains, Coheed, and Circa Survive. | Snake.
01.04.14 | SAYONAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARRRAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA | Chortles
01.04.14 | Awful band | ZippaThaRippa
01.04.14 | Who are you people | kris.
01.04.14 | switch 3 and 4 and yeah this is pretty much right
| ShitsofRain
01.04.14 | yup 4 needs to be higher | KILL
01.04.14 | great band | InFiction
01.04.14 | I think your list is actually pretty accurate dude! I might switch 1 and 2 based on occasion but otherwise you got everything down to a tee - descriptions included. Very nice. | kmace
01.05.14 | 4 is 1 in my book then I agree with everything else. SSTB and IKSoSE being interchangeable as well. | Rowan5215
01.05.14 | Pleb being a cunt in this thread, damn | itsalltherage
01.05.14 | 4's got to be 1 man. That's just how it is. | Keyblade
01.05.14 | 2 |
|