JaySpiral: Split Post-hardcore?

JaySpiral 10.02.13	So do you guys agree or think it's just fine?
Trebor. 10.02.13	I always wondered why there's two melodic hardcores Like fuckin Lifetime sounds nothing like Modern Life Is War and they're both melodic hardcore
KILL 10.02.13	good side is husker du bad side is refused
DurzoBlint 10.02.13	I enjoy all sides of post hardcore, from the bands such thrice and fightstar, to ones like at the drive in, to the heavier ones like hopesfall and barrow.
Trebor. 10.02.13	"I enjoy all sides of post hardcore, from the bands such thrice and fightstar, to ones like at the drive in." You only mentioned bands on one side wtf where's the emarosa and sksk and from first to last and shit
KILL 10.02.13	wait bmth are considered post hardcore now? i thought they were puss turdcore shit
PitchforkArms 10.02.13	its not okay....
deathofasalesman 10.02.13	no one knows what post-hardcore is even post-hardcore bands so let's get together and eliminate the genre tag
JaySpiral 10.02.13	Coheed and Cambria confirmed for progcore.
Cygnatti 10.02.13	Hmm
JaySpiral 10.02.13	@Hep Kat, what splits would you suggest, if we're going to be serious?
WeepingBanana 10.02.13	3 is definitely not even close to post-hardcore. 2 is where it started to transition into the shit it is today but i still really really like 2. 4 is the shit that post-hardcore has become
WeepingBanana 10.02.13	hep for most helpful comment of the year
JaySpiral 10.02.13	Circa Survive is fantastic fak u
SeaAnemone 10.02.13	the fact that you put touche amore and atdi as indicative as one side means you really shouldn't be characterizing and generalizing about post-hardcore styles, sorry
JaySpiral 10.02.13	@SeaAnemone k. I wasn't saying they were exactly alike. I was saying they were closer to actual post-hardcore than a lot newer stuff people call post-hardcore. I recognize Touche Amore and ATDI are very different, which just shows more that post-hardcore needs to be split up.
Emim 10.02.13	first rule of post-hardcore everything is post-hardcore
SeaAnemone 10.02.13	jayspiral I'm not saying that because TA and ATDI are very different I'm saying that they aren't very good examples of "the other side" of post-hardcore in opposition to newer styles at all
WeepingBanana 10.02.13	the survival of the genre DEPENDS on being split up do your part
SeaAnemone 10.02.13	"needs to be split up." lol this sentiment
IbenizGEO1 10.02.13	first rule of post-hardcore everything is post-hardcore [2]
JaySpiral 10.02.13	@SeaAnemone Do you not think the genre has become so varied that it would be convenient to distinguish between the different styles within the genre?
SeaAnemone 10.02.13	there's good and shit of every genre; every genre progresses and goes through bad and good stages, in general I mean if the populace really wants to popularize some new genre term for all the new DGD/Emery/Circa Survive etc. then sure, but I don't really see a point in trying to formalize it and make it happen haha but lol, plz don't try to characterize "real" post-hardcore with TA and ATDI
HypedMerchant 10.03.13	"'real'"
sniper 10.03.13	post-hardcore = post-hardcore punk it literally means punk that is "downstream" so to speak, of hardcore it's not really a genre, it's an umbrella term. emo is technically post-hardcore.