ILJ
09.14.13 | I'm trying to keep my hopes guarded, and I know that hoaxes with this are frequent but this one seems different. Either we may actually be hearing this soon, or this guy is a fucking master troll. Here's to hoping it's the first. |
ILJ
09.14.13 | Here's some pictures the guy uploaded: http://imgur.com/a/Z9Zmf |
Hyperion1001
09.14.13 | its a fake from discogs |
PunchforPunch
09.14.13 | no its real and also their best |
demigod!
09.14.13 | i saw the post, too. seems legit enough to me. only time will tell, i guess. |
ILJ
09.14.13 | A man can dream |
demigod!
09.14.13 | i wonder how much money people have spent on "real" copies of this before |
StallionMang
09.14.13 | If this is legit, I'll freak. |
MoosechriS
09.14.13 | not getting my hopes up, had a quick glance through the thread and i'm not convinced. If it turns out to true it's obviously awesome though |
Comatorium.
09.14.13 | I've had this for months... Still not sure the huge deal over it |
ILJ
09.14.13 | "I've had this for months"
yeah okay |
Comatorium.
09.14.13 | Just a sec |
Comatorium.
09.14.13 | http://m.imgur.com/IGCt4Lz |
ILJ
09.14.13 | Could just be a different artist with the tags for the tape. It's happened to many people already.
The only way we could ever know for sure if it's ACTUALLY the tape is to have it be confirmed by the band I guess. |
Comatorium.
09.14.13 | It always amuses me when people get their panties in a wad over this cassette and the fact that its been on what.cd for months.
Mostly cause this thing kinda blows, it's just a bunch of drones and some framework for future trscks |
Comatorium.
09.14.13 | It sounds like Godspeed demos to me. They're a pretty unique sounding band, even at that early stage. There's no part of me that thinks someone picked and matched a bunch of Godspeed like songs that not only perfectly matched the times for the track list, but all sound unmistakably Godspeed-y |
PunchforPunch
09.14.13 | you 4.5 the word alive i don't believe you |
sideburndude
09.14.13 | yea I am pretty sure it turned out to be fake on /mu/ |
tlhk
09.14.13 | how would anyone besides the band know if it's real or fake? |
Comatorium.
09.14.13 | Yes, because my music taste in high school 4-5 years ago is relevant -_- god this site has gone to shit since I joined |
StallionMang
09.14.13 | Did the OP upload it yet? |
StallionMang
09.14.13 | I'm not calling this out as fake until I hear it, or if it doesn't get uploaded soon. |
Ignimbrite
09.14.13 | faith |
Havey
09.14.13 | is comatorium just playin or a retard cos i really cant tell |
Cygnatti
09.14.13 | The latter. |
Scoot
09.14.13 | there's no way this is legit, i don't think the band even has copies of it anymore and they apparently don't want it surfacing
doubt we'll ever hear it |
demigod!
09.14.13 | if you read the dude's story behind it it makes it pretty believable and makes some sense. still, he could be bullshitting for a laugh / attention |
Scoot
09.14.13 | those pics look pretty legit...hmm
gonna listen to the sample wav he posted |
adarkishman
09.14.13 | reddit is so fucking bad for music but if this is legit its pretty sweet |
demigod!
09.14.13 | yeah redditors generally have pretty shit taste, but for once i am glad to be subscribed to /r/music
not that i wouldnt have found out anyways tho |
adarkishman
09.14.13 | no dont say that its real |
demigod!
09.14.13 | shut the fuck up you hairless cunt |
adarkishman
09.14.13 | has anyone checked the dadmommydad sample |
Kman418
09.14.13 | hi im r/music and i would sell my first born child on the black market just to lick the freshly spewed baby batter off of dave grohl's long throbbing cock |
demigod!
09.14.13 | new xx? album of the year |
Kman418
09.14.13 | ON MELANCHOLY HILL IS THE ONLY RELEVANT SONG |
adarkishman
09.14.13 | yes we have established that r/music is bad can we just get onto gybe |
demigod!
09.14.13 | dude we need something to do while we await the moment of truth |
Scoot
09.14.13 | listening to the sample, it's definitely them
i think it's real...wow. never thought it would happen |
adarkishman
09.14.13 | okay fine lets make fun of it
we were born in the wrong generation! |
demigod!
09.14.13 | next thing you know Atlantis is gonna come rising out of the sea! |
Scoot
09.14.13 | there's singing in this lol, kind of sounds like nirvana
i can see why they didn't want this to surface but it's cool to hear nonetheless. the quality is shit though |
demigod!
09.14.13 | is it like that weird falsetto shit on parts of F#A#? |
adarkishman
09.14.13 | bullshit scott it is not POSSIBLE |
Kman418
09.14.13 | pretty sure i just found it on slsk
dgaf about this band enough to check if it's legit or not though lol |
demigod!
09.14.13 | gaf dude they rock |
Scoot
09.14.13 | no it's actual lyrics and shit, i think it's moya
this is clearly before they decided to go all epic and orchestral. that one fuzzy lick sounds right off f sharp though. lots of the sample is just feedback and random static.
you can tell it's them though |
Kman418
09.14.13 | lift yr skinny fists is good but i never listen to it unless i just want some mindless background music really |
Scoot
09.14.13 | this sounds nothing like anything else they made
it's so obscure and fucking weird but still sounds cool nonetheless |
Athom
09.14.13 | did OP deliver? |
adarkishman
09.14.13 | okay im gonna bite the bullet and listen to it
|
demigod!
09.14.13 | i guess this means all lights... isn't cool anymore
|
Scoot
09.14.13 | op delivered adam, you can tell it's them |
adarkishman
09.14.13 | wow this actually sounds legit |
anarchistfish
09.14.13 | i don't believe you
would be better left uncovered anyway. love the mystery |
anarchistfish
09.14.13 | where's the dl link |
Scoot
09.14.13 | http://audiour.com/playlist/ckhbvtps |
TheNexus100
09.14.13 | this actually might be legit wow |
adarkishman
09.14.13 | i dunno if this is legit |
StallionMang
09.14.13 | Listening to the audio sample now, it's legit. I'm fairly sure Menuck is singing, because his voice sounds the same as on Silver Mt. Zion recordings. As different as it sounds from other Godspeed albums, you can see how their sound evolved between this and F# A#, especially on Moncton Blues. |
sniper
09.15.13 | holy shit gonna listen later |
Buzzkillr
09.15.13 | the bounty for this on what is almost 2tb damn. could sure use that upload cred. |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | has he uploaded the whole thing? |
adarkishman
09.15.13 | no hes scared of the copyright gods killing him |
Scoot
09.15.13 | not yet but this sample along with the pics of the booklet and sleeve is pretty definitive proof he has it
should only be a matter of time
|
Scoot
09.15.13 | this will go for a stupid amount on ebay |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | imagine if he videoed himself smashing it to pieces
oh god |
Scoot
09.15.13 | i'm fairly sure he wouldn't live very long |
StallionMang
09.15.13 | Don't give me nightmares, fish. |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | more likely that he'll have a problem uploading it/just won't do it |
sniper
09.15.13 | he seems like he will upload.
/optimistic |
Scoot
09.15.13 | if he's smart he'll auction it off to someone who knows what they're doing
you can only attempt to rip a cassette once or twice i believe |
PunchforPunch
09.15.13 | http://imgur.com/a/Z9Zmf
my god....... |
Atrophy
09.15.13 | good goddamn the day finally came
bet /mu/ collectively shat a brick |
sniper
09.15.13 | that doesn't make sense, if you can listen to a tape multiple times you should be able to record it multiple times. if he sells it, and he will, someone else can upload a better rip, but for now he should get a copy up for us. fuck |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | might take a few days :|
"The feature production we are about to present has the virtue of unparalled novelty"
hipsters from the start |
Scoot
09.15.13 | i suppose it was bound to happen eventually but count me in for never thinking it would happen |
sniper
09.15.13 | really hope this happens, regardless of the quality of the rip. tbh it probably isn't that good anyway |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | which is why I always thought it had more value as this legendary mysterious idea |
IbenizGEO1
09.15.13 | this is fake as balls man |
sniper
09.15.13 | maybe he won't do it |
Scoot
09.15.13 | he was getting flamed for taking so long and decided not to do it
will prob sell to a collector who will never upload it and that eight minute clip will become stuff of legend
internet ruins everything once again |
PunchforPunch
09.15.13 | he should just sell it ppl who wants it to be ripped are just jelly of him |
TMobotron
09.15.13 | "internet ruins everything once again"
more like this guy being a twat ruins everything |
sniper
09.15.13 | yeah i saw that. fuck though, fuck |
TMobotron
09.15.13 | I'm seeing these guys in 2 days, god i hope they close with dadmomdaddy |
sniper
09.15.13 | maybe he was a troll all along, can't even imagine why he wouldn't want to upload it otherwise. haven't listened to the sample yet though |
TheNexus100
09.15.13 | listen to the audio and tell me he's trollin |
sniper
09.15.13 | we should def kill him and take the tape then, no other course of action seems reasonable |
Scoot
09.15.13 | the sample is legit, he's just being a douche about it
which makes sense, he has practically all of hipster nation on his dick right now |
ILJ
09.15.13 | i haven't been following this all day
so the guy decided not to upload now? |
sniper
09.15.13 | it doesn't make sense at all, why be withholding? p4p is right, i'm super jealous |
TheNexus100
09.15.13 | whats funny is there is no way the album is good but ITS ALL LIGHTS FUCKED |
sniper
09.15.13 | he commented on a thread where some redditors were talking shit and said his mind was made up and then bounced |
sniper
09.15.13 | agreed proggy |
Scoot
09.15.13 | truest comment of the thread "of all the people to find a copy of this, we get this guy"
if it was a diehard or even casual fan who understood the legend behind this tape it would have already been uploaded in full. this guy was so clueless that he might never have even known what he stumbled upon |
sniper
09.15.13 | but i still resent being denied the opportunity to revel in its mediocrity |
ILJ
09.15.13 | what a dick man
i mean if i had it i would fuck with people but i would still upload it
i'd turn it into a scavenger hunt, upload false links, that sort of thing
but dammit i would upload it. |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | Can we locate his address |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | Where does he say he won't do it? |
Scoot
09.15.13 | 4chan is gonna nuke this guy if he holds out, /mu is seething right now |
sniper
09.15.13 | he doesn't, but he strongly implies it. he said good night. |
ILJ
09.15.13 | i can't believe this is happening man |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | I don't think he understands how dead he's going to become |
ethos
09.15.13 | ALL LIGHTS FUCKED IS A CURSE HE WHO HOLDS IT DIES WITHIN THIRTY THREE DAYS |
Winesburgohio
09.15.13 | god GY!BE fans are pissbabies
the only thing i'm insulted by is his choice of file-sharer |
Scoot
09.15.13 | yeah i mean it would be sweet to hear but some of them are crying like little bitches over it |
North0House2
09.15.13 | He'll upload it in a week, and as soon as we all download it the magnetic pole will shift, all power will go out forever, and we'll never hear it. |
Winesburgohio
09.15.13 | yeah scoot i'm in the same boat
no idea if this is legit or not but whatever the case i don't think the sample tracks sound especially great (although maybe it's just not my cup of tea, no judgement if u do!) |
Arnaud
09.15.13 | The two songs are beautiful. Can't wait till he uploads the rest of the album. |
Kman418
09.15.13 | /mu/
FUCK YOU REDDIT FUCK YOU FUCK YOU FUCK YOU FUCK YOU WOTHLESS PIEECE OF SHIT WEBSITE
>reddit fucked something up
GEE, WHO WOULD'VE GUESSED?
>wife wants him to sell it
>women ruining something as usual
>mfw I'll never hear this cassette in full because of a faggot redditor
I don't want to live anymore.
GYBE is all smoke and mirrors. I hope the whole thing gets leaked somehow so they're exposed as the genuinely untalented people they are.
again
i love how you guys are blaming reddit when this "gyibe" fellow is clearly one of you.
which was then responded to with
It's me. I don't even like Godspeed Emperor Black You.
lets track him down, break into his house and steal it
|
ILJ
09.15.13 | gotta love /mu/ |
Kman418
09.15.13 | there's two guys going back and forth trying to track down his address and rob him in this thread right now |
IbenizGEO1
09.15.13 | good that's what he gets for lying |
sniper
09.15.13 | /mu overreacting
GEE, WHO WOULD HAVE GUESSED?
i do hope he uploads but i won't lose any sleep either way let's be honest |
treeqt.
09.15.13 | muhh reddit muhh redditmuhh reddit muhh redditmuhh reddit muhh redditmuhh reddit muhh redditmuhh reddit muhh reddit |
ILJ
09.15.13 | muh sense of entitlement because music is so easily attainable that when i can't get exactly what i want i throw a bitch fit |
sniper
09.15.13 | lol you made the list |
someguest
09.15.13 | http://youtu.be/awhsOgmdq6w?t=2m3s |
adarkishman
09.15.13 | hahah /mu/ |
adarkishman
09.15.13 | im kinda pissed though actually what the fuck is that cunt doing |
Kman418
09.15.13 | sleeping |
adarkishman
09.15.13 | well fuck him |
someguest
09.15.13 | you'll listen to music again
if you're lucky |
treeqt.
09.15.13 | stay positive stay based |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | The cassette's probably worth more unleaked, so I wouldn't be at all suprised if he sold it without
uploading it. Hopefully the buyer will then upload it. Just gotta make sure he fedex's that shit so
some pimple faced little shit at the post office doesn't drop it |
StallionMang
09.15.13 | Woke up yesterday to find that All Lights has surfaced, and I wake up today to find that the guy won't upload it. Fuckin' fuck. |
StallionMang
09.15.13 | Also, Constellation scanned these photos of the cassette, for any of you that still need proof that he has (or had) the real
thing.
http://web.archive.org/web/20000527090924/http://www.cstrecords.com/html/allfuckedb.html |
treeqt.
09.15.13 | how is that proof he has the real thing
if anything that hints more towards it being fake |
geasoftime
09.15.13 | I have this. It's not very good. |
Havey
09.15.13 | no you dont |
geasoftime
09.15.13 | lol, do you guys want another sample? |
geasoftime
09.15.13 | What song do you want to hear, Havey? I'll let you pick whichever you like, and I'll upload it |
sniper
09.15.13 | upload the same section this guy did |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | upload the same section and the 5 minutes after it, together as one file |
ILJ
09.15.13 | "lol you made the list"
okay but i don't see what that has to do with anything. |
sniper
09.15.13 | do you not want this to leak as much as the rest of
us? |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | I don't understand what's wrong with wanting a long lost recording of a band you like to be available.
You use the terms "entitlement" and "bitch fit" as if that's an unreasonable desire. |
Havey
09.15.13 | geas not deliverin HMMM |
Spec
09.15.13 | I already have it ahaha. |
IbenizGEO1
09.15.13 | Spec share |
Havey
09.15.13 | anyone who actually thinks he has the real thing is a retard |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | no one thinks he has the real thing |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | still can't find where this guy said he won't upload it |
IbenizGEO1
09.15.13 | the dude on reddit is fucking whipped and is also a lair. |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | it's an amazing hoax if it is a hoax |
IbenizGEO1
09.15.13 | agreed still think it is though |
Hyperion1001
09.15.13 | theres a kickstarter to pay the guy for the tape
this guy is brilliant really, hes gonna make bank on something that is obviously no more than an urban legend at this point and when they do finally confirm that this is fake as always hes gonna have cash and the fanboys are gonna look like idiots |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | and all we'll have is a shitty mp3 of something we could've recorded ourselves in 30 minutes with just a microphone, a guitar from ikea and a swimming pool.
but still |
TheSpirit
09.15.13 | good thing i dont care about this band or id be pissed |
Scoot
09.15.13 | lol hyp bringin the truth
if this really is a hoax it's one of the best i've ever seen and the guy is a legendary troll
|
IbenizGEO1
09.15.13 | he had 20 years to make get it right lol |
Scoot
09.15.13 | the dude posted again
says he's down for ripping it as long as constellation records is okay with it, says he emailed them about it. then he's selling it on ebay and probably posting the rips after the tape is sold |
StallionMang
09.15.13 | Alright, I can respect that decision. |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | thas fair
godspeed are basically communists anyway so I'm sure they won't mind |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | actually don't constellation have it anyway? |
Scoot
09.15.13 | i think what the band will do is ask him for the sample and photos to prove it's legit (because efrim will know right away) just in case he's scamming
once they verify its authenticity i'm sure they won't mind |
sniper
09.15.13 | let's hope |
demigod!
09.15.13 | so what's the latest? |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | Apparently the band have been trying to look for a copy themselves but I don't understand why it's still lost if constellation scanned it |
Scoot
09.15.13 | people are saying he deleted his account..
looks like 4chan started harassing him in order to piss him off so he wouldn't release it, just to troll gy!be fans
woww the internet sucks |
anarchistfish
09.15.13 | damn, and yet I keep playing devil's advocate when it comes to "humanity sucks" arguments |
StallionMang
09.15.13 | What a drama queen. |
Scoot
09.15.13 | yep confirmed that it was people from /mu/ |
Gwyn.
09.15.13 | dam |
Spec
09.15.13 | Album isn't that great anyways. |
Gwyn.
09.15.13 | What you heard wasn't the real one |
Spec
09.15.13 | Yeah it is. |
Spec
09.15.13 | I own a copy. Found it at a garage sale. |
Ignimbrite
09.15.13 | oh my god fuck reddit fuck /mu/ fuck the internet in general holy fuck |
Scoot
09.15.13 | there's still a chance we'll hear it, he's definitely going to sell it and we just have to hope that whoever gets it is decent enough to rip it for everyone and not just hoard it
slim chance though |
ILJ
09.15.13 | "do you not want this to leak as much as the rest of us?"
"I don't understand what's wrong with wanting a long lost recording of a band you like to be available. You use the terms "entitlement" and "bitch fit" as if that's an unreasonable desire."
You guys misconstrued what I said. It's totally fine to want it to leak, and I do want it to leak, but it's not okay to do what some people on /mu/ are doing. I was referring to their overreacting to the guy dicking us around, not anybody on here. |
Gwyn.
09.15.13 | The guy is an imbecile for not ripping it and putting it really if it's real, I don't care if he wanted to do the "right thing" it's clear that the band doesn't give a fuck at this point they even said it wasn't interesting enough to even warrant a reissue
He was either dumb or it was all fake |
Spec
09.15.13 | Guys I lied.
I don't own it. |
IbenizGEO1
09.15.13 | Obviously |
Spec
09.15.13 | I'm sure you're all very surprised. |
Gwyn.
09.15.13 | CLEARLY |
Spec
09.15.13 | hahaha |
grish
09.16.13 | wait so was it ever determined if this was real |
Gwyn.
09.16.13 | Nope, dude just deleted his accounts because of 4chan and nothing has been heard about this since. It's over man.
Though, maybe if the person who he sells it too decides to do something about it we'll hear more of it, the person who buys it MUST know how rare this is but who knows. |
Spec
09.16.13 | So this isn't happening. |
sniper
09.16.13 | i think anyone who would care to buy it would probably also care to rip it. |
anarchistfish
09.16.13 | Unless they like the idea of goading people with it |