MAGNIFICENT: Top 5 Pink Floyd Albums

Muisc4Life26 09.06.13	Animals Wish You Were Here The Wall Meddle The Piper at the Gates of Dawn
Rowan5215 09.06.13	Wish You Were Here Animals Dark Side Obscured by Clouds The Division Bell
StallionMang 09.06.13	Replace 4 with Piper and that's my list.
Aids 09.06.13	edgy picks
DrHouseSchuldiner 09.06.13	The Dark Side Of The Moon Wish You Were Here Animals Meddle The Piper at the Gates of Dawn
YoYoMancuso 09.06.13	Wish You Were Here the other ones
tlhk 09.06.13	thank you so much for this
Riviere 09.06.13	"Replace 4 with Piper and that's my list." Gtfo, Gilmour > Barrett all day jk, but seriously, The Wall is greatness.
JamieTwort 09.06.13	Piper > The Wall, agreed.
Rowan5215 09.06.13	Most Floyd > The Wall.
tommygun 09.06.13	wywh animals piper meddle and um i spose dark side
Speed512 09.06.13	wywh should be 1
tommygun 09.06.13	but yeah madcap laughs > dark side
Rowan5215 09.06.13	On an Island > Madcap Laughs bro
tommygun 09.06.13	nah
Rowan5215 09.06.13	yah
ButteryBiscuitBass 09.06.13	KC & The Sunshine Band >
NeroCorleone80 09.06.13	Animals Wish You Were Here Meddle The Dark Side of the Moon The Piper at the Gates of Dawn
MAGNIFICENT 09.06.13	Enjoying the diversity of your Floyd top 5's! Seeing some Piper, some Division Bell and some OBC! And @thlk, you're welcome ; )
JamieTwort 09.06.13	My top 5 is pretty much exactly the same as Nero's. Although sometimes I think I prefer The Final Cut to Piper.
BigPleb 09.06.13	Needs more Piper. The Wall is low tier Floyd imo.
DominionMM1 09.06.13	saucerful > piper and the wall
linkinmuse 09.06.13	Wish You Were Here The Dark Side of the Moon Animals The Wall The Division Bell
DominionMM1 09.06.13	"The Division Bell" lol
MAGNIFICENT 09.06.13	What Dominion? He can't have an opinion? Lebowski, I see where you come from, but The Wall belongs to any top 5 Floyd in my opinion. It's a cohesive record with an amazing concept and there isn't one song I don't like. And just like a story's listener has to be patient, one who listens to The Wall has to be patient. It's a musical journey.
guitarded_chuck 09.06.13	http://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?listid=129968&memberid=71831
JamieTwort 09.06.13	The Wall is far from cohesive imo. It has some outstanding moments though.
MAGNIFICENT 09.06.13	Jamie, and then again, opinions. It feels great to me if I approach it thinking I'll have a long journey ahead of me. I'd like to see everyone criticizing The Wall making an album better than it instead of complaining about it A little torn up between The Wall and Meddle though, both amazing records.
JokineAugustus 09.06.13	Here's where you laugh Animals Piper WYWH Obscured Dark Side
MAGNIFICENT 09.06.13	It's a pretty original list, Augustus, although I'm not that much of a Piper fan.
MAGNIFICENT 09.06.13	Yeah, choosing Meddle over The Wall. Echoes ftw.
JamieTwort 09.07.13	"I'd like to see everyone criticizing The Wall making an album better than it instead of complaining about it" I could never make an album like The Wall and I can quite happily admit that but that doesn't mean I can't still give my opinion on the album based on the level of enjoyment I get from it.
Rowan5215 09.07.13	^^^ Exactly.
MAGNIFICENT 09.07.13	Jamie, yes, I agree, but you didn't get what I wanted to say with that statement, There are people who say The Wall "sucks", that it is "a bad album", and that's the thing I just don't get, y'know? Of course I couldn't make a Justin Bieber album since I don't have his girly voice but I'm free to express my opinion about it.
JamieTwort 09.07.13	Fair enough. I certainly don't hate The Wall, I just think it's flawed and somewhat overrated and that Floyd have a lot of better albums.
Rowan5215 09.07.13	He just said he didn't hate it dude, and he's right that they've done waaaaaaaaay better.
JamieTwort 09.07.13	@Decaying: I'm on about my opinion of The Wall.
JamieTwort 09.07.13	Along with like 5 of their other albums yea.
JamieTwort 09.07.13	It's good but not amazing.
Rowan5215 09.07.13	Some songs on there are quite amazing, others suck hard.
JamieTwort 09.07.13	Agreed Rowan.
Rowan5215 09.07.13	"But the wall and all its progness" Cos you know no other Floyd has "progness" at all, right?
Rowan5215 09.07.13	I was adding a joke to your joke bro
Rowan5215 09.07.13	This thread.
Rowan5215 09.07.13	Haha I see you've learned Sput traditions well, not right now man.
guitarded_chuck 09.07.13	"I'd like to see everyone criticizing The Wall making an album better than it instead of complaining about it" lolol
Minus. 09.07.13	We definitely needed another Floyd list
Artuma 09.07.13	the wall is a 5, fight me
FuncrusherPlus1 09.08.13	I've only heard three so far, i'd go. The Wall Wish You Were Here The Dark Side Of The Moon