StallionMang: Genre Suggestions

StallionMang 06.27.13	New format is great, by the way.
YakNips 06.27.13	+2 for screamo
Pestiferous 06.27.13	5 exists already and doesnt 6 too?
InfamousGrouse 06.27.13	lol 29
bach 06.27.13	We need deathcore. So we can stop tagging Suicide Silence and Whitechapel as death metal.
KILL 06.27.13	gay
foxblood 06.27.13	NEWWAVE
Mister Twister 06.27.13	Neo-classical tag must be implemented.
StallionMang 06.27.13	Yes, I forgot about new wave, and deathcore's good, too. How about jazz fusion?
PunchforPunch 06.27.13	i'll just tag screamo bands with emo
Havey 06.27.13	"5 exists already and doesnt 6 too?" 5 is gone, unfortunately 6 never existed
Uranium 06.27.13	no more home button either. why mods, why?
foxblood 06.27.13	clicking on 'reviews' does the same thing as home and it's in the same place so no problems there
Cygnatti 06.27.13	Dance aint a genre guys.
foxblood 06.27.13	yes no dance please
Havey 06.27.13	New Age has arrived! Noise, too! :D
foxblood 06.27.13	yeah i already starting taggin with new age that was fast:D
treeqt. 06.27.13	i suggested those! :D did you too? :D let's be suggestion brothers! :D
KILL 06.27.13	chicago house!!!!!!!!
YakNips 06.27.13	:D
Cygnatti 06.27.13	Still waiting on dat new wave and jangle pop.
rockandmetaljunkie 06.27.13	Prob I'm the only user of this site who still supports the return of Hard Rock. I would also suggest including: Jazz - Fusion AOR
Cygnatti 06.27.13	Hm, I don't like the idea of both noise AND noise rock. They'll probably remove one but yeah.
rockandmetaljunkie 06.27.13	In all honesty, I doubt that there will be more tags than the ones we already got.
treeqt. 06.27.13	kinda confused about the lack of screamo though not gonna lie
treeqt. 06.27.13	having both noise and noise rock makes sense imo
Havey 06.27.13	"Hm, I don't like the idea of both noise AND noise rock." they're pretty separate entries dude, they don't even share the same parent genre
foxblood 06.27.13	jangle pop would make me very happy but i'd be really surprised if that got added
treeqt. 06.27.13	man i'll have hella post-rock in my pie chart with all those emo/post-rock & screamo/post-rock shit i have rated. that's kinda gay.
Cygnatti 06.27.13	Oh damn. That's gonna screw some people over, just like it did with me! And just like how people are mistaking the electronic garage genre as garage rock.
treeqt. 06.27.13	oh and pls suggest 'Glitch' a lot too
Cygnatti 06.27.13	Already did. ;)
Havey 06.27.13	krautrock needs to hurry up
Cygnatti 06.27.13	I need to know what kraut rock is first! ;_;
owen 06.27.13	Screamo was added, but it is removed again Crust punk +1000 Powerviolence No wave New wave D-beat Ska punk Different tags for grindcore and deathgrind
Ignimbrite 06.27.13	neofolk neofolk neofolk neofolk neofolk
Hoppoman 06.27.13	for kraut rock see Kraftwerk.
toxin. 06.27.13	how about new age, einaudi's music is more similar to modern pop than "classical music" as we know it. i'd be ok with neo-classical but that sorta bothers me cuz there's a literal definition for neo- classical in terms of music theory. (JK It's here!)
Cygnatti 06.27.13	Ska punk could be just punk + ska, like it already is.
Acanthus 06.27.13	EBM Newwave Futurepop
PunchforPunch 06.27.13	EBM is gr8 +1111111111
treeqt. 06.27.13	"krautrock needs to hurry up" let me help you emphasize the need for it by suggesting it A LOT "how about new age" got added an hour ago or so
balazs 06.27.13	I thought about Neo-classical. classical can be enough though, so not that important. Also, noise and noise rock are absolutely different things. How should we tag merzbow, masonna etc. without noise?
Kman418 06.27.13	skacore
balazs 06.27.13	OK, both noise and noise rock are added, end of story
Cygnatti 06.27.13	Djent is here now. So is melodeath and melo something I can't remember.
treeqt. 06.27.13	melo bm lol
JaySpiral 06.27.13	Rap Metal and Post-Metal definitely need to be in there.
Cygnatti 06.27.13	shoegaze is here! shoegaze is here!!~
toxin. 06.27.13	how is classical anything like neo-classical (presumably taking neo-classical to mean modern pop music like einaudi, yiruma, hsiashi but extended beyond just piano which is more or less where my knowledge ends)? in terms of structure, instruments used, themes, technicality, etc. it's vastly different
Havey 06.27.13	shoegaze has been here for hours dude
Cygnatti 06.27.13	awwwww
Cygnatti 06.27.13	"in terms of structure, instruments used, themes, technicality, etc. it's vastly different" elaborate!
treeqt. 06.27.13	i'd welcome a neo-classical tag. "Rap Metal and Post-Metal definitely need to be in there." Post-Metal is (or was?)
treeqt. 06.27.13	and yeah o/ shoegaze
balazs 06.27.13	Actually neo-classical, modern classical and contemporary classical are all different things, complicated
JS19 06.27.13	we NEED Math Rock and Post-Metal, the others are just bonuses
Cygnatti 06.27.13	"Actually neo-classical, modern classical and contemporary classical are all different things, complicated" add in experimental classical too. -_-
Havey 06.27.13	no
Cygnatti 06.27.13	I don't any of them, so the less of them out there, the easier it is for me.
balazs 06.27.13	I mean there's no sense making such a difference, everything would look like a joke.
Ignimbrite 06.27.13	Folk Metal
Cygnatti 06.27.13	folk + metal
balazs 06.27.13	If we had a genre tree though...
pissbore 06.27.13	thrashing deathblack metal for bands like possessed, early kreator, early destruction, early sodom, cogumelo records bands etc
Relinquished 06.28.13	"post-metal is already a tag." it shouldn't be, after years of promoting it I find it real stupid. atmospheric sludge metal is a better tag.
toxin. 06.28.13	@cyg, listen to "river flows in you" and contrast it with liszt's "la campanella" since they're about equal and length and both more or less paint vivid pictures as their names would suggest. technical difficulty notwithstanding, la campanella has varied texture (the main theme, for ex., has alternating measures of staccato and legato for an obvious example). it also has several thematic differences, including what sounds like a minor main melody, major interludes, and a chromatic scale (?) tossed in. also are those 15th intervals?? you can hear dynamics and accelerandos yourself and i don't feel like pointing htem out. river flows in you just sounds like a pop song. it has a singular tempo, and the only dynamic fluctuations are the natural pulses of a phrase (which don't count as using dynamics for artistic vision). this isn't to bash on yiruma but to show the two pieces aim for different things. i think you'd find even most basic "classical music" that has been deemed by people more versed than us to be worthy of surviving centuries after their composition have a far grander vision than a lot of "neo-classical" which, for better and worse, is much more poppy. @balazs, ya you're right but modern classical always seemed like a pointless term to me, comparing phillip glass to like brian crain is kinda dumb
Days of Future Passed 06.28.13	Yeah I suggested Krautrock too
toxin. 06.28.13	really lazy analysis of la campanella btw, i've truthfully only listened to it like 5-6 times so i apologizes for how cursory it is :[
tommygun 06.28.13	toxman u a genius
lyon1535 06.28.13	My suggestion for a new genre is "Satan"
Funeralopolis 06.28.13	need screamo and synthpop
ChopSuey 06.28.13	too many genres
auberginedreams 06.28.13	we don't need to get ridiculous with subgenres but can we please get screamo it feels weird to have football etc. and orchid in the same pie chart slice.
auberginedreams 06.28.13	my pie chart is weird as fuck like now i have prog rock in my pie chart because i 5'd a la dispute album or something lol.
Cygnatti 06.28.13	"this isn't to bash on yiruma but to show the two pieces aim for different things. i think you'd find even most basic "classical music" that has been deemed by people more versed than us to be worthy of surviving centuries after their composition have a far grander vision than a lot of "neo-classical" which, for better and worse, is much more poppy." yeah, that makes a lot of sense. but technicality notwithstanding, spring is soooo very much a pop song.
Cygnatti 06.28.13	"we don't need to get ridiculous with subgenres but can we please get screamo it feels weird to have football etc. and orchid in the same pie chart slice." screamo was one of the first genres to really get pushed for. none of the new genres except a very few (for whatever reason) like r&b, shoegaze, melodeath won't show up until a few days from now.
auberginedreams 06.28.13	also why does deafheaven show up on the main emo genre page even though they are not tagged as emo?
Cygnatti 06.28.13	a single idiot or two voted that they were emo, for the time being, if a band gets one vote in a genre, the site will perceive it as if it were that genre. so if you got one band, and got enough alts to vote one vote for every available genre, that one band will show up in every genre page, and contribute to every genre to everyone's pie chart. they said they'll get this fixed but that's how it is right now. the biggest thing we need to do is get the user base to keep on voting. the more votes, the much less likely a band will be mislabeled.
PunchforPunch 06.28.13	Gamelan and Keroncong!!
grish 06.28.13	jazz fusion
ConcubinaryCode 06.28.13	Post black metalcore with jazz sax breakdowns.
demigod! 06.28.13	real ones
ConcubinaryCode 06.28.13	I'll be sure to make that one reality. But uh... Ambient?
demigod! 06.28.13	my comment was in response to the thread title hah wasn't getting at ya
ConcubinaryCode 06.28.13	Now I feel so embarrassed...
toxin. 06.28.13	"yeah, that makes a lot of sense. but technicality notwithstanding, spring is soooo very much a pop song." i don't agree but it doesn't really matter. i think you can find examples of classical works that is more similar to the new age movement (or w/e you wanna call it) than to other classical stuff. i just wanted to differentiate the two in broad generalizations since exceptions for genre tags always exist
StallionMang 11.02.13	Been 4 months and still no skramz tag, wtf.