JaySpiral
06.19.13 | I was surprised that both Devin Townsend albums lost in the first round. Some pretty sweet classic prog vs new prog matchups here! |
Artuma
06.19.13 | oooh man, a dream match-up I&W vs Scenes
--- (still haven't heard The Yes Album, damn)
---
Scenes from a Memory
Animals
---
Lateralus
Aqualung
Selling England
---
---
Thick as a Brick
Red
Moving Pictures
Still Life
Mirage |
DikkoZinner
06.19.13 | wish you were here
hot rats
?
animals
close to the edge
fragile
moonmadness
aqualung
selling england by the pound
foxtrot
the lamb
thick as a brick
leviathan
moving pictures
larks
mirage |
omnipanzer
06.19.13 | Wish You
Hot Rats
---
Animals
Close to the Edge
Emerson, Lake & Palmer
Lateralus
Aqualung
Selling England by the Pound
2112
Aenima
Thick as a Brick
Red
Moving Pictures
---
Mirage |
JamieTwort
06.19.13 | Wish You Were Here
Hot Rats
Scenes
Animals
Close to the Edge
Emerson, Lake & Palmer
Moonmadness
Aqualung
Selling England
2112
The Lamb
Thick as a Brick
Red
Mindcrime
Larks' Tongues
Mirage |
ViperAces
06.19.13 | images and words
moonmadness |
balazs
06.19.13 | Wish You Were Here
-
none
Animals
Close to the Edge
-
Lateralus
Aqualung
Selling England
2112
Aenima
Thick as a Brick
Red
-
Larks' Tongues
Mirage |
rockandmetaljunkie
06.19.13 | Wish You Were Here
-
Metropolis p.t2
Animals
-
Close to the Edge
Fragile
-
Aqualung
-
2112
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
Thick as a Brick
Red
Moving Pictures
Larks' Tongues in Aspic
Mirage |
greg84
06.19.13 | Wish You Were Here
Hot Rats
Scenes
Hemispheres
Close To The Edge
Emerson
Lateralus
Aqualung
Selling England
2112
Aenima
Thick As A Brick
Red
Moving Pictures
Lark's Tongues
In Absentia |
JaySpiral
06.19.13 | If you have heard one album, but not the other, then you should listen to the other album and then vote. From here on out pretty much every album will be worth listening to! |
ShadowRemains
06.19.13 | wish you were here
hot rats
scenes from a memory
animals
close to the edge
emerson
---
---
selling england
2112
aenima
thick as a brick
red
moving pictures
---
mirage |
Artuma
06.19.13 | what's wrong with you guys? there's no way Larks can beat Still Life |
manosg
06.19.13 | 1,3,5,7,9,11,14,16,17,20,21,23,25,27,30,31 |
ViperAces
06.19.13 | oh and i forgot
larks |
Artuma
06.19.13 | "Please vote with album names!" manosg. lol Viper |
ViperAces
06.19.13 | sorry bro but that album is amazing. and i never liked opeth
i only voted i&r initially because cba and i thought that was the only hard contest, when i saw your comment i felt that larks needed some support too. |
manosg
06.19.13 | lol, thanks Artuma.
Wish You Were Here
Hot Rats
Metropolis Pt. 2
Animals
Close to the Edge
Fragile
Moonmadness
Aqualung
Selling England
2112
The Lamb
Thick as a Brick
Red
Moving Pictures
Larks' Tongues
Mirage |
Artuma
06.19.13 | yeah Larks is sweet but Still Life is just perfect but then again i love Opeth in general
"when i saw your comment i felt that larks needed some support too."
Larks is winning by a large margin tho :P |
MikeC26
06.19.13 | Wish
Hot rats
Scenes
Hemispheres
Close
Elp
Moon
BLP
Selling England
2112
Anemia
Thick
Red
Moving
Still life
Mirage
|
NordicMindset
06.19.13 | Wish You Were Here
Hot Rats
Scenes from a Memory
Animals
Close to the Edge
Fragile
Lateralus
Blackwater Park
Selling England by the Pond
2112
Aenima
De-Loused
Red
Moving Pictures
Still Life
Mirage
|
Artuma
06.19.13 | lol Anemia |
HorrorBusiness78
06.19.13 | Yes Album
Colors
Images and Words
Hemispheres
Close to the Edge
Lateralus
Aqualung
Selling England
2112
Lamb Lies Down
Thick as a Brick
Red
Mindcrime
Lark's Tongues
In Absentia |
truekebabpower
06.19.13 | scenes |
charbyno
06.19.13 | Wish You Were Here
Colors
Metropolis Pt. 2: Scenes from a Memory
Hemispheres
Close To The Edge
Fragile
Lateralus
Blackwater Park
Alaska
2112
Aenima
Thick as a Brick
Leviathan
Moving Pictures
Still Life
Mirage |
sumyunguy
06.19.13 | wish you were here
colors
scenes from a memory
animals
close to the edge
emerson, lake and palmer
lateralus
blackwater park
selling england by the pound
foxtrot
the lamb lies down on broadway
thick as a brick
red
moving pictures
larks' tongues in aspic
mirage
dude, pairing blackwater park and aqualung fucking sucks haha. it's the most apples and oranges shit ever. |
Titan
06.19.13 | Wish You Were Here
Colors
Scenes From A Memory
Animals (fuck)
Close To The Edge
Fragile
Lateralus
Aqualung
Selling England
2112
Aenema
Thick As A Brick
Red
Moving Pictures (fuck)
Larks
Mirage
cant believe i voted against Hemispheres and Mindcrime |
JaySpiral
06.19.13 | I'm a bit disappointed that De-Loused is getting beat that bad. Though it is a worthy competitor at least. |
Titan
06.19.13 | Fuck you Jay for making this list.....you have me voting against my faves
:D |
JaySpiral
06.19.13 | Yeah I know, when I vote it's going to suck ass voting against some of these. |
Friday13th
06.19.13 | Wish You Were Here
Hot Rats
Images and Words (yeah that choice killed me)
Hemispheres
Close to the Edge (best prog album imo)
Fragile
Moonmadness
Aqualung
Selling England
Foxtrot
Lamb Lies Down on Broadway (Genesis turkey streak!)
Thick as a Brick
Red
Operation: Mindcrime (you realize I hate you for that dilemma)
Larks' Tongues in Aspic
Mirage |
JamieTwort
06.19.13 | "what's wrong with you guys? there's no way Larks can beat Still Life"
That one wasn't even a contest for me. Larks' >>> Still Life |
JamieTwort
06.19.13 | Damn I meant to say Foxtrot for 19/20 not 2112. Both rule though. |
Artuma
06.19.13 | well that doesn't surprise me at all JT since i know you're a big fan of classic prog |
cuki92
06.19.13 | The Yes Album
Hot Rats
Images and Words
Animals
Close To The Edge
Fragile
Moonmadness
Blackwater Park
Selling England by the Pound
Foxtrot
The Lamb Lays Down on Broadway
Deloused
Red
Moving Pictures
Still Life
Mirage |
Friday13th
06.19.13 | I agree with JamieTwort. Stuff like Between the Buried and Me doesn't even belong in the same list with old school prog giants. |
JamieTwort
06.19.13 | "well that doesn't surprise me at all JT since i know you're a big fan of classic prog"
If it was MAYH instead of Still Life it might be a different story. |
Gwyn.
06.19.13 | eww btbam
haven't heard most of these so won't vote |
Artuma
06.19.13 | if it was MAYH i would have a tough choice but i'd say MAYH over Larks too |
ViperAces
06.19.13 | i need to listen to mayh, didnt like any opeth so far |
sumyunguy
06.19.13 | with how incomparable some of these matchups are (ie aqualung vs blackwater park), the only real way I could do it was which album succeeds more in its own genre on its own merits. aqualung is pretty much flawless, but it's a top 10 prog album for me. blackwater park, on the other hand, is my #1 metal album ever, hence the bp choice |
ShadowRemains
06.19.13 | voting btbam over zappa = crime against humanity |
JamieTwort
06.19.13 | If BWP wins over Aqualung I will be pissed. |
KILL
06.19.13 | lol |
JaySpiral
06.19.13 | Tool and Dream Theater look like the only newer prog that might make it kinda far. |
treeqt.
06.19.13 | Aqualung
The Lamb Lies Down
De-Loused
|
ViperAces
06.19.13 | somone voted alaska
holy crap |
SaneTBP
06.19.13 | Hot Rats
Animals
Red
Mirage |
Artuma
06.19.13 | BTBAM ain't that bad cmon but yeah on this list they are pretty much a joke |
JaySpiral
06.19.13 | Wish You Were Here
Hot Rats
Scenes from a Memory
Animals
Fragile
Lateralus
Blackwater Park
Selling England by the Pound
2112
Aenima
De-Loused
Red
Moving Pictures
Still Life
Mirage |
NickelbackFTL
06.19.13 | Wish You Were Here
Hot Rats
Metropolis 2
Animals
Close to the Edge
Fragile
Lateralus
Blackwater Park
Selling England
2112
The Lamb Lies Down
De-Loused
red
Moving PIctures
Larks' Tongues
In Absentia |
Jethro42
06.19.13 | Wish you were here
Hot Rats
Metropolis pt. 2; Scenes from a memory
Hemispheres
Close to the edge
Fragile
Moonmadness
Aqualung
Selling England by the pound
Foxtrot
The lamb lies down on broadway
Thick as a brick
Red
Moving Pictures
Lark's tongues in aspic
Mirage |
SirArthur6
06.19.13 | The Yes Album
Hot Rats
Animals
Close to the Edge
Fragile
Foxtrot
Thick as a Brick
Red
Lark's Tongues in Aspic |
DarkInfernal
06.19.13 | -
-
Scenes from a Memory
Hemispheres
Close to the Edge
Fragile
-
Blackwater Park
Selling England
2112
The Lamb lies down
De-Loused in the Comatorium
-
Operation: Mindcrime
-
In Absentia |
n60storm
06.19.13 | Wish You Were Here
Hot Rats
Scenes from a Memory
Animals
Close to the Edge
Fragile
Lateralus
Blackwater Park
Selling England by the Pond
2112
Aenima
De-Loused in the Coma
Red
Moving Pictures
Still Life
Mirage |
teslabarrier
06.19.13 | Wish You Were Here
-
Scenes from a Memory
Animals
Close to the Edge
Fragile
Lateralus
Blackwater Park
Selling England by the Pound
2112
Aenima
De-Loused in the Comatorium
Red
-
-
In Absentia |
NordicMindset
06.19.13 | yay tool will still make it to the next round even if aenima loses. lateralus for the win (even though
I actually like aenima better) |
JaySpiral
06.19.13 | Aenima and The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway look pretty damn close so far, I wouldn't count it out yet. |
sideburndude
06.20.13 | Wish You Were Here
Hot Rats
Scenes from a Memory
Hemispheres
Close to the Edge
Emerson, Lake & Palmer
Moonmadness
Aqualung
Selling England by the Pound
Foxtrot
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
Thick as a Brick
Red
Moving Pictures
Larks' Tongues in Aspic
Mirage
|
geasoftime
06.20.13 | WYWH
Colors
-
Animals
-
-
Lateralus
Blackwater Park
-
-
Aenima
De-Loused in the Comatorium
Leviathan
-
Still Life
In Absentia |
teslabarrier
06.20.13 | fuck it, mine got screwed up. |
grish
06.20.13 | Damn how do I choose between hemispheres and animals, that should be like the final round |
jtswope
06.20.13 | Wish You Were Here
Hot Rats
Scenes from a Memory
Animals
Close to the Edge
Fragile
Lateralus
Aqualung
Selling England by the Pound
Foxtrot
Aenima
De-Loused in the Comatorium
Red
Moving Pictures
Larks' Tongues in Aspic
In Abstentia |
Friday13th
06.20.13 | Who's picking Mars Volta over Thick as a Brick. I'm sorry, personal taste I know but seriously I wouldn't mind Thick as a Brick winning the whole thing it's that essential. |
JaySpiral
06.20.13 | Thick as a Brick is definitely essential, but De-Loused is, in my opinion, a much more enjoyable album to listen to. |
PortraitsOfDecay
06.20.13 | Images and Words |
JaySpiral
06.20.13 | While I agree that Scenes from a Memory is better than Images and Words I'm kind of surprised that it's winning by so much. |
JaySpiral
06.20.13 | Closing voting in about an hour so if you haven't gotten your votes in do it now! |
BigHans
06.20.13 | YOu can just end the contest now Moving Pictures wins by a wide margin and it isnt close |
Trebor.
06.20.13 | Wish You Were Here
Hot Rats
Images and Words
Hemispheres
Close To The Edge
Fragile
Moonmadness
Aqualung
Selling England by The Pound
2112
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
Thick as a Brick
Red
Moving Pictures
Larks' Tongues in Aspic
Mirage |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | yes album
hot rats
images and words
hemispheres
close to the edge
fragile
moonmadness
aqualung
selling england
foxtrot
lamb lies down
thick as a brick
red
moving pictures
larks tongues
mirage |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | and anyone who votes that anything is better than hemispheres is crazy |
Trebor.
06.20.13 | This is a joke if btbam get past another round |
BigHans
06.20.13 | its a joke if anything beats Moving Pictures fucking LIMELIGHT fucking REd BARCHETTA yeah |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | bro hans you gotta hear some other prog records too |
BigHans
06.20.13 | dude I know I havent progged hard in awhile but you know Rush is the best |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | agreed |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | also how the hell did a btbam record beat emerson lake & palmer? elp's at least listenable wanking |
BigHans
06.20.13 | btbam are fucking embarrassing. |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | god damn i know. its like if youre gonna show off how well you can play at least put it in a listenable song format |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | also the fact that animals is gonna beat hemispheres is ridiculous, FUCK pink floyd, love em but nothing on animals is as good as hemispheres |
BigHans
06.20.13 | Animals is like the 4th best Floyd record at best so yeah pretty much a joke |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | animals is like 3rd best floyd for me but when it comes to prog i'll always take genesis, yes, rush over them, those bands just have better songs i think |
DrHouseSchuldiner
06.20.13 | Wish You Were Here
Hot Rats
Images and Words
Hemispheres
Close to the Edge
Fragile
Moonmadness
Aqualung
Selling England by the Pound
2112
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
Thick as a Brick
Red
Moving Pictures
Larks' Tongues in Aspic
Mirage |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | i need to get in all my alts and pick hemispheres before you people fuck it up |
Ovrot
06.20.13 | Wish you Were Here
Colors I guess
Images and Words
HEMISPHERES
Close to the Edge
Emerson, Lake and Palmer
Moonmadness
Aqualung
Selling England by the Pound
2112
Aenima
Thick as a Brick
Red
Moving Pictures
Still Life
Mirage |
BigHans
06.20.13 | Also if Scenes from a Memory beats Images and Words this site has officially gone to hell |
DrGoatandTheWagons
06.20.13 | Wish You Were Here
Hot Rats
Images and Words
Hemispheres
Close to the Edge
Fragile
Moonmadness
Aqualung
Selling England by the Pound
2112
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
Thick as a Brick
Red
Moving Pictures
Larks' Tongues in Aspic
Mirage |
JaySpiral
06.20.13 | Animals is my favorite Pink Floyd album. Slightly ahead of Wish You Were Here. So it's all subjective guys. |
VanSchuldiner
06.20.13 | Wish You Were Here
Hot Rats
Images and Words
Hemispheres
Close to the Edge
Fragile
Moonmadness
Aqualung
Selling England by the Pound
2112
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
Thick as a Brick
Red
Moving Pictures |
robschuldiner1
06.20.13 | Hemispheres
Close to the Edge
Fragile
Moonmadness
Aqualung
Selling England by the Pound
2112
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
Thick as a Brick
Red
Moving Pictures |
JaySpiral
06.20.13 | Alright voting closed!
CLOSED
CLOSED
CLOSED
CLOSED
CLOSED |
JamieTwort
06.20.13 | Can't beleive I had to vote against Hemispheres but it was put against the best album ever so... |
NordicMindset
06.20.13 | are we getting round of 16 anytime soon? |
aggelosm
06.20.13 | wish you were here
hot rats
Images and words
animals
-----------
Close to the edge
fragile
moonmadness
blackwater park
--------------
Selling england...
2112
the lamb lies....
thick as a brick
------------
red (obviously)
moving pictures
still life
mirage |
aggelosm
06.20.13 | oops...too late hehe |
Motiv3
06.20.13 | Wish You Were Here
Colors
Images and Words
Animals (so tough)
Close to the Edge
Emerson Lake and Palmer
MoonMadness
Blackwater Park
Selling England by the Pound
2112
The Lamb Dies Down on Broadway
Deloused in the Comatorium
Red
Operation Mindcrime
Still Life
Mirage |
JamieTwort
06.20.13 | "Alright voting closed!
CLOSED
CLOSED
CLOSED
CLOSED
CLOSED" |
Artuma
06.20.13 | next round please. |
Keyblade
06.20.13 | if Mirage doesn't make it to at least the quarterfinals then i unno man just...i unno |
Artuma
06.20.13 | Mirage totally killed In Absentia though |
JamieTwort
06.20.13 | Rightly so. |
Keyblade
06.20.13 | good |
Chortles
06.20.13 | any1 who voted btbam against genesis or zappa should be stoned |
Artuma
06.20.13 | charbyno voted for both BTBAMs |
JamieTwort
06.20.13 | Same goes for anyone who voted for The Mars Volta over Thick as a Brick. |
Artuma
06.20.13 | De-loused is pretty essential to modern prog though so i can accept voting for that even though Thick as a Brick is Thick as a Brick |
DikkoZinner
06.20.13 | Same goes for anyone who voted for Op:MC over MP. |
JamieTwort
06.20.13 | I have both at 4.5 so that was a tough one for me. Went for Mindcrime partly because I thought it probably wouldn't get many other votes, which proved to be the case. |
Artuma
06.20.13 | MP is a hard contender to win the whole thing |
JamieTwort
06.20.13 | I'd rather Hemispheres won. |
JamieTwort
06.20.13 | or A Farewell to Kings but that wasn't even on the first list. |
Artuma
06.20.13 | Hemispheres against Animals though |
JamieTwort
06.20.13 | Yeah I had to vote against it cos of that. Animals is top 3 prog for me. |
DikkoZinner
06.20.13 | Next round will be ferocious |
Motiv3
06.20.13 | animals vs hemispheres was definitely the toughest one. God dammit I didn't see that the voting closed before I put my picks :(. |
Artuma
06.20.13 | yep, Animals is just so amazing. it's only my 3rd fav Floyd but still a 5/5 |
BreakerdeGodot
06.20.13 | Wish You Were Here
Hot Rats
Metropolis Pt. 2: Scenes from a Memory
Animals
Close to the Edge
Fragile
Lateralus
Blackwater Park
Selling England By the Pound
2112
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
Thick as a Brick
Red
---
Still Life
Mirage |
DikkoZinner
06.20.13 | Someone should do a death metal one of these, but Incantation would prob win. Diabolical Conquest. |
Artuma
06.20.13 | or a metal one in general |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | dude metal is too broad |
laughingman22
06.20.13 | animals or hemispheres is going to be kicked out this round and yet we still have a dream theater album :( |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | hahaha i know wtf |
Friday13th
06.20.13 | Quit whining Pink Floyd or Rush will probably win |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | then again obv dream theater's not better than rush or floyd, its just there were some unfortunate pairings here, like foxtrot vs 2112, sorry but had to pick foxtrot |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | fuck u |
Friday13th
06.20.13 | true "2112" or "Supper's Ready" ouch |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | dude i know its tough |
Cygnatti
06.20.13 | lol Mr. Hood ilu |
Insurrection
06.20.13 | wish you were here
colors
metropolis
animals
close to the edge
fragile
moonmadness
blackwater park
alaska (cause it has no chance)
foxtrot
the lamb
-
red
operation mindcrime
still life
in absentia (again, no chance) |
Cygnatti
06.20.13 | too late, man. |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | fools cant read! |
Insurrection
06.20.13 | yea just realized that |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | thank god his vote doesnt count he voted for colors ;) |
JamieTwort
06.20.13 | lol |
ViperAces
06.20.13 | colors is somewhat ok, voting for alaska was the crazy part |
DikkoZinner
06.20.13 | & op:mc over mp |
Insurrection
06.20.13 | are you really judging my votes that didnt count? you guys need a life |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | im gonna kick your ass little boy! |
JokineAugustus
06.20.13 | Wish You were here
Hemispheres (toughest one ever)
Moonmadness
2112
Still Life
|
Artuma
06.20.13 | "Alright voting closed!
CLOSED
CLOSED
CLOSED
CLOSED
CLOSED" |
Artuma
06.20.13 | but another Still Life vote is needed tho |
JaySpiral
06.20.13 | About to put up the next round guys. |
sonictheplumber
06.20.13 | WOO |
SaneTBP
06.20.13 | Where's Jane Doe? |
