BigPleb
04.18.13 | Here comes the flame... |
zakalwe
04.18.13 | The first 4 are spot on. |
Artuma
04.18.13 | 7 above 8? seriously? |
BigPleb
04.18.13 | Then after that, the controversy sets in haha.
Yeah, The Wall is hideously overrated.
Still a great record, though. |
Artuma
04.18.13 | omg, the wall is #1 for me |
BigPleb
04.18.13 | I respect that. |
NightProwler
04.18.13 | We are a small amount of Sputnikkers who prefer the Wall (well, it's pretty tied with Dark Side, but still). And I am, apparently, the only one who enjoys 14, lol |
JamieTwort
04.18.13 | One of the most accurate Floyd rankings I've seen. Your top 4 is spot on. Great to see 6 so high too. |
DrHouseSchuldiner
04.18.13 | Sweet list for a classic band in my top 10 bands of all time
i believe that every sputnik user has a different ranking for floyd
so my ranking will be
1 The Dark Side of the Moon
2 Wish You Were Here
3 Animals
4 Meddle
5 The Piper at the Gates of Dawn
6 The Wall
7 Atom Heart Mother
8 A Saucerful of Secrets
9 More
10 Ummagumma
11 The Final Cut
12 The Division Bell
13 Obscured by Clouds
14 A Momentary Lapse of Reason
Any way the list can change with time but i believe that 1 will be my 1 and 14 will be my 14 lol |
BigPleb
04.18.13 | Cheers JT, Final Cut is so underrated.
I enjoyed all of Floyd's records up until 13. |
Artuma
04.18.13 | 14 is where it should be tbh |
BigPleb
04.18.13 | Ye its pretty bad.
A Saucerful of Secrets is really overlooked too. |
ButteryBiscuitBass
04.18.13 | my God this is CORRECT. |
NightProwler
04.18.13 | But it has Terminal Frost and Learning to Fly :( |
DrHouseSchuldiner
04.18.13 | I try to dig 14 but i cant tbh |
BigPleb
04.18.13 | Cos its quite boring.
Wow, no signs of butthurt so far. |
Artuma
04.18.13 | no reason to be butthurt, list is pretty accurate overall |
Rowan5215
04.18.13 | Saucerful, Obscured and the Division Bell are way too low IMO, but good list. |
Artuma
04.18.13 | division bell is pretty good yea |
Rowan5215
04.18.13 | Gets way too much hate, defs. Last two songs and Wearing the Inside Out are fucking amazing. |
BigPleb
04.18.13 | Like I said, enjoyed every Floyd album bar More and AMLOR |
Rowan5215
04.18.13 | Yeah, opinions and shit. I like them all, I wouldn't give any less than 3, but I mostly agree with your ranking. |
NeroCorleone80
04.18.13 | I completely agree with the top 5. |
stabbler
04.18.13 | Does Ummagumma belong in this list? |
BigPleb
04.18.13 | Um, yes? Why wouldn't it? |
tommygun
04.18.13 | top 5 is great and don't really care to rank the others so sweet list pos |
Artuma
04.18.13 | "Does Ummagumma belong in this list?"
of course it does |
tommygun
04.18.13 | actually I might put wywh above animals and piper above dark side but w/e it's your world we're just posting in it rock on |
demigod!
04.18.13 | what tommy said |
stabbler
04.18.13 | I dunno - Ummagumma is part live part individual project. I've never thought of it measured up against their other stuff. |
BigPleb
04.18.13 | They're p much interchangeable I s'pose :)
Its still an LP.... |
stabbler
04.18.13 | Ah well..Floyd discography can definitely be grouped into 3 different levels of excellence and you've pretty much captured it |
BigPleb
04.18.13 | Cheers man, I agree hard. |
stabbler
04.18.13 | Though the live part of Ummagumma alone would be way higher imo |
TheSpaceMan
04.18.13 | I agree with top 5, but I'd always put DSotM as 1 cause I'm cliche and feel like they hit something special with that one |
Adabelle
04.18.13 | Sweet ranking, I haven't heard all of their records but of what I have heard:
Animals > WYWH > DarkSide > TPATGOD > The Wall > Momentary Lapse > Division Bell
Which is identical to you if you swap the last two! |
Artuma
04.18.13 | Adabelle you need to hear Meddle asap |
Adabelle
04.18.13 | Mmmm it looks that way |
ChuckyTruant
04.18.13 | 14 is def 14 |
SputnikSweetheart
04.25.13 | would be nice to have little explanation for each album but good list (I'm just starting to get into them now, that's why) :) |
Adabelle
04.25.13 | Listened to Meddle btw and it either places 3rd or 4th, not quite sure yet, either say, our ranking is basically the same! |
Artuma
04.25.13 | meddle is fantastic, it's a shame that it is so often left in the shadow of the "big 4" |