Gnocchi
03.12.13 | I'll bite, you choose and i'll give it a go.
If you want someone a bit specific with genres, pick out a couple of contribs that have a focus for a genre. Say, for Electronica go Will R. although I'm not trying to pigeon hole the man : ] |
Azn.
03.12.13 | thanks yo
do my Japandi review? |
Funkenstein
03.12.13 | lol just beware, if you neg the meds thread will gain 7 more pages!! |
WeepingBanana
03.12.13 | the feedback you've already gotten on the review page is all the feedback that the site wanted to give you so making this list makes you seem like a douche |
Eclecticist
03.12.13 | there's a forum thread for this |
Azn.
03.12.13 | Funkenstein: probably not this time, I'm asking for it
Weeping: so? I want more feedback
Eclecticist: did not know |
Atari
03.12.13 | i don't see how it makes him look like a douche. he's only written 7 reviews and is just looking for some feedback damn. he's not being all high and mighty about it. |
WeepingBanana
03.12.13 | no, you want validation via a fucking music website |
Azn.
03.12.13 | yes, I want to know how people react to my writing
problem? |
WeepingBanana
03.12.13 | hmm well you have a 95% approval rating, so i'd say 95% of people like your reviews
if you want this information with finer detail, see review comments |
Azn.
03.12.13 | the thing is people rarely see my reviews, and I've only been reviewing more often lately. I just want some more critiques on my writing, different people might have different impressions |
Azn.
03.12.13 | but jeez I didn't realize making a list would be taboo |
WeepingBanana
03.12.13 | nah i'm mostly just fucking with you bro but yeah list still seems a tad unnecessary |
Azn.
03.12.13 | eh might as well get all the help I can
I like writing and I want to improve |
Atari
03.12.13 | honestly i'm not gonna take sides but there's nothing wrong with asking for additional feedback. For me personally, I've decided a lot of users will blindly pos my reviews or just give the generic "good review atari pos" comment. Because of this, my writing wasn't improving at all. It wasn't until seeking some additional feedback from omahastyles, calc, ecnalzen, etc. that I was actually able to get some helpful comments to help me grow as a writer. |
Azn.
03.12.13 | technically it doesn't matter if the actual review is shit, all that matters is how people view it
and I just want more of others' perspective |
Atari
03.12.13 | wait what how does it not matter if the review is shit? lol |
Gnocchi
03.12.13 | It's not taboo, that was honestly douchie, but at the same time they're right. Yes, there's a thread in the forum that definitely isn't used enough, but I don't see anything wrong in asking for a little feedback outside of the review's thread. I remember the days when Irving was just a user, and handing out some of the best critiques this site has ever seen, or when Dev would be the contributor that would bluntly, with detail would say why the review sucked. It was good. |
Azn.
03.12.13 | Review might be shit, but nobody sees it that way :D
and yeah I usually find negative feedback more helpful than positive feedback |
Eclecticist
03.12.13 | I wasn't being being bitchy like Weeping, I was just pointing out that there is actually a place that exists precisely for this request. |
Gnocchi
03.12.13 | Left some for you duder, |
Gnocchi
03.12.13 | Yeah I got you Josh, but calling someone out that's actively looking for help just like WB did... |
Eclecticist
03.12.13 | Raising a point is not calling someone out. |
Gnocchi
03.12.13 | THATS NOT AT YOU MAN!!!!! : ] |
Azn.
03.12.13 | thanks ipod! |
Eclecticist
03.12.13 | ah, yea but I think the agreement there is unanimous. |
