mikedrumz
03.06.13 | I love them both. But my vote goes to LZ because they are led zeppelin. |
coneren
03.06.13 | good list ideas |
mikedrumz
03.06.13 | Ty. Floyd for lyrics, but LZ for overall... going to California is just such a flawless song |
coneren
03.06.13 | make more of these maybe with bands that dont suck and are for old men |
peaks40
03.06.13 | both great, generic list sorry bro |
mikedrumz
03.06.13 | Led zeppelin? Suck? 0.o |
coneren
03.06.13 | they are very bad yes |
mikedrumz
03.06.13 | ..how is led zeppelin bad?! |
coneren
03.06.13 | most bands from the 70s suck get with the times. guy sounds like a woman half the time |
mikedrumz
03.06.13 | Sorry...just........no... |
mikedrumz
03.06.13 | Great musicianship and groundbreaking for the era |
coneren
03.06.13 | actually yes sorry if your opinion is clearly wrong |
conesmoke
03.06.13 | Pink Floyd were sooooo much more awesome than Led Zeppelin.
In saying that, I still think Led Zeppelin rule. |
JokineAugustus
03.06.13 | As long as Animals>all Led Zeppelin and Floyd I don't care. |
mikedrumz
03.06.13 | Cept the wall>animals, so.... |
coneren
03.06.13 | if youre going to listen to old people music you may as well listen to a good band like motley crue |
JokineAugustus
03.06.13 | hahahahahahahaha mike |
mikedrumz
03.06.13 | Led zeppelin and pink Floyd> motley Crüe |
MeatSalad
03.06.13 | plz stop |
coneren
03.06.13 | i knew you were an idiot before but damn |
mikedrumz
03.06.13 | You said pink Floyd and led zeppelin are really bad...? |
coneren
03.06.13 | yes because i am not an idiot even my dad agrees and he is old |
mikedrumz
03.06.13 | Your dad....is an idiot. |
mikedrumz
03.06.13 | And he touches you at night |
coneren
03.06.13 | i think it is very clear who the idiot here is. ill give you a hint its you |
mikedrumz
03.06.13 | You said led zeppelin was terrible...you lose by default |
coneren
03.06.13 | actually because you think they arent awful means it is in fact you how does it feel being this stupid youre so stupid you dont even know youre stupid wow a whole new level |
robschuldiner1
03.06.13 | 2 by faaar ... the wall is great but overrated imo |
deftonesrock420
03.06.13 | both suyck |
Rowan5215
03.06.13 | LZ are amazing, but PF win in my eyes. Gilmour and Wright are just some of the best vocalists ever. |
DominionMM1
03.06.13 | zep if i'm drunk, floyd if i'm stoned |
BigHans
03.06.13 | lollolololllolololololollolololl
Zepp by a fucking landslide |
Graveyard
03.06.13 | zeppelin plagiarized a lot and roger waters is a bitch
so idk |
YankeeDudel
03.06.13 | FLOYD |
mandan
03.06.13 | Can't decide, sorry. |
deftonesrock420
03.06.13 | floyd but its close |
tommygun
03.06.13 | gilmour > plant (singing)
plant > waters (singing)
waters > plant (lyrics)
gilmour = page (guitar)
jones > waters (bass)
wright > jones (keys)
bonham >>>>>>>> mason (not even fucking close)
zep for consistency but floyd for 5s
I can't decide :/ |
BigHans
03.06.13 | Zepp annhilates Floyd |
deftonesrock420
03.06.13 | learn to prog bro |
YankeeDudel
03.06.13 | you cant compare bands like that tommy. thats like comparing 2 basketball teams position wise by their starting 5s. |
blastOFFitsPARTYtime
03.06.13 | Floyd, if only for the sake of originality. |
blastOFFitsPARTYtime
03.06.13 | Although I can dig it, Tommy. |
avonbarksdale221
03.06.13 | Floyd. |
tommygun
03.06.13 | yeah I know yankee I was just considering the possible factors but my gut is probably saying zep by a hair |
BigHans
03.06.13 | learn to prog bro
^ Rawk >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Prog |
Gwyn.
03.06.13 | Floyd |
tommygun
03.06.13 | dude blastoise I gave waters lyrics cos he is a mastermind but as a singer and bassist he is no more than average
jones kills him on bass
plant has him beat on singing for my money but not by that much cos sometimes plant rules and sometimes he's extremely irritating |
blastOFFitsPARTYtime
03.06.13 | Sorry, man. Totally misread that. Fissed as puck right now. Fair fucking play, I agree hard. |
tommygun
03.06.13 | sweet man m/ p/ |
blastOFFitsPARTYtime
03.06.13 | !!
My real life name is actually Tom m/ |
tommygun
03.06.13 | holy shit m/ |
SmersH
03.06.13 | Someone mentioned Floyd for lyrics - Zep overall.
That.
(though Animals is pretty damn flawless) |
blastOFFitsPARTYtime
03.06.13 | Sweet fucking name agreed. |
NightmareCinema16
03.06.13 | Two different genres...I can't just compare two brilliant albums. |
tommygun
03.06.13 | if we're only comparing the albums on the list then zep iv >>> |
demigod!
03.06.13 | hard, but overall
Floyd>
for me |
CrownOfMagnets
03.06.13 | Dude honestly I love Zep as much as the next guy but I'd say Pink Floyd just because. |
NightmareCinema16
03.06.13 | It's a tie. I'm just going to throw white flags in the air and call it done. |
eggsvonsatan
03.06.13 | Why bother ranking them. They're both great but have absolutely nothing in common. |
CK
03.06.13 | Led Zeppelin is the band I favor more for certain |
Mad.
03.06.13 | gilmour < plant (singing)
plant > waters (singing)
waters > plant (lyrics)
gilmour < page (guitar)
jones > waters (bass)
wright > jones (keys)
bonham >>>>>>>> mason (not even fucking close)
Overal it's gotta be Zep, surely one of the greatest groups of musicians ever assembled? |
tommygun
03.06.13 | "gilmour < plant (singing)
plant < waters (singing)"
wat |
JamieTwort
03.06.13 | ^ yeah no way is Waters a better singer than Plant or Gilmour.
Also Gilmour > Page (guitar), easily imo.
Not sure who I'd choose overall, tough call. |
BigPleb
03.06.13 | Floyd p/ |
ckunke002
03.06.13 | Been heavy on a LZ phase lately. They are the definitive rock band to me. Pink Floyd are damn good though. Some of there stuff is a little over the top for me though, but they are certainly a great band.
Nothing can beat JPJ, Bonzo, Page and Plant though |
demigod!
03.06.13 | idk man prime Floyd is some goooooood stuff. |
BigPleb
03.06.13 | Floyd has Animals, so yeah |
ButteryBiscuitBass
03.06.13 | Floyd. Animals and Meddle are phenomenal. LZ are still awesome though. |
tommygun
03.06.13 | yeah floyd has like three 5s and a lot of good and some rubbish
zep has all 4s and 4.5s except for in thru |
rate10000albums
03.06.13 | floyd |
NapalmCrusader
03.06.13 | You can't compare both. The 2 band owns hard, but zep is my favorite one. |
sblevins95
03.09.13 | Hard to compare these two because I love them both but Floyd takes the cake |