intotheshit
01.22.13 | I only watched 20 minutes of 7 before I had suicidal urges, so I turned it off. |
DominionMM1
01.22.13 | you prefer 5 to 7? i mean they're both awful, but i found requiem a little less nausea inducing. |
Winrar
01.22.13 | Yeah 7 was awful. I prefer Aliens simply because of how quotable it is compared to Alien. |
intotheshit
01.22.13 | Alien created a sense of dread and suspense that I have yet to find in any other movie, so I think it deserves the #1 spot solely based on that. |
Cipieron
01.22.13 | i haven't seen 3, but besides that i'd rank everything the same.
avp is dumb but fun |
Atari
01.22.13 | only seen the first 3 but agreed with your ranking on those |
savagecabbage
01.22.13 | ended up at a friends and watched 5 on mushrooms a couple years ago. strange times |
intotheshit
01.22.13 | How about the easy fact that none of the DNA bullshit makes any sense. If one sole being
seeded the earth, then every creature would have same DNA.
That's just one. It's a major one, at that. |
paxman
01.22.13 | My ranking would be exactly the same. |
Crymsonblaze
01.22.13 | 1
2
6
5
3
7
4
Everything after Aliens sucks though |
Jruined
01.22.13 | http://movieplotholes.com/prometheus.html
Pretty good summation of a number of the plot holes in Prometheus. Beautiful movie, but that's about it. |
InfamousGrouse
01.22.13 | Yeah I never understood the claims that Aliens surpassed the original in quality, it's not that great bar the last half hour. |
intotheshit
01.22.13 | I don't think DallyLama is very observant. |
deathofasalesman
01.22.13 | Honestly #2's scares were utterly predictable and was literally the same premise of the first film, just with added guns instead of defenseless spacemen. |
deathofasalesman
01.22.13 | Alien, however, is artistic, fear-inducing and almost poetic. |
linguist2011
01.22.13 | My personal favourite would be the original. Like Dead Space, it thrives on brilliant atmosphere and doesn't depend on throwing god-knows-how-many monsters at any particular character, but instead on one alien. That is so beautifully designed and constructed that it just doesn't fucking die right until the end. |
InfamousGrouse
01.22.13 | Ash is a twat agreed |
GnFnRs87
01.22.13 | Agreed on the ranking.
1 is a better movie than 2 but it's close
3 was beautifully shot and Michael Fassbender was indeed terrific but it's hardly an Alien movie
4 isn't as bad as its made out to be, still nothing on the others
Fuck the rest |
Jruined
01.22.13 | The original idea Vincent Ward had for Alien 3 sounded like it would have been great if it had been green lit.
http://vincentwardfilms.com/concepts/alien-3/unrequited-visio/ |
cagedescending
01.22.13 | i'd put A3 and Prom about equal, maybe A3 a little higher. liked em both, but they're def deeply flawed
otherwise list is perfect |
Chortles
01.22.13 | aliens is so good mmmmm |
MO
01.22.13 | good ranking, 1 & 2 are pretty equal in my books, for different reasons obvs |
Inveigh
01.22.13 | "Alien created a sense of dread and suspense that I have yet to find in any other movie, so I think it deserves the #1 spot solely based on that."
my thoughts exactly |
cagedescending
01.22.13 | Alien is tits agreed |
paxman
01.22.13 | The black stuff in Prometheus doesn't make any sense whatsoever. |
intotheshit
01.22.13 | Made one guy into a monster, killed the other two |
paxman
01.22.13 | ...and impregnated Noomi Rapace's character |
paxman
01.22.13 | And wasn't it the same stuff the guy drank at the beginning that started life on earth or was that something else? |
cagedescending
01.22.13 | and then there's like, ANOTHER kind of goo that's green and does... something else. there's definitely
at least two kinds of extraterrestrial technojizz |
paxman
01.22.13 | White goo is the only goo that makes sense |
intotheshit
01.23.13 | The more I talk about Prometheus, the less I like it. |
Lambda
01.23.13 | 1. Aliens
2. Alien
3. Prometheus
4. AVP
5. Alien 3
6. Alien Resurrection
7. AVP 2 |
intotheshit
01.23.13 | Yeah but you're like 3/4 retarded so your ranking doesn't count |
bach
01.23.13 | hit the nail on the head. |
evilford
01.23.13 | Agreed Alien is the best. Aliens rules too mainly because of Bill Paxton but its not as great as Alien. The rest were garbage.
Haven't seen Prometheus tho |
ILJ
01.23.13 | "http://movieplotholes.com/prometheus.html"
Jesus christ great, another site for me to spend way too much time on. |
Acanthus
01.23.13 | Wow no andcas yet? Weird.
A lot of people don't consider the AvP's canon, the original three films are enough for me. |
Groink
02.15.13 | The director's cut of Alien 3 is actually really good, some of the plot holes and missing scenes are covered. |
BigBlob
02.15.13 | Alien Resurrection was good ffs. Dont understand the hate it gets. |
DamnVanne
02.15.13 | Everyone in Alien is shitty at their job, and that hurts the movie's quality of believability. |
Insurrection
02.15.13 | Nice rating but I'd swap 1 and 2. |
Insurrection
02.15.13 | "Alien Resurrection was good ffs. Dont understand the hate it gets."
Alien Resurrection was awful |
Crymsonblaze
02.15.13 | Yeah everything after Aliens is irredeemable |
NOTINTHEFACE
02.15.13 | This ranking is completely, 100% correct. Congratulations. Realizing that 1 is ever so slightly better than 2 is a rare gift. |
theacademy
02.15.13 | i might swap 4/5
3, resurrection, and requiem bleed together |
theacademy
02.15.13 | its like:
Alien/Aliens = 10/10
Prometheus/AVP = 6/10
Rest = 3/10 or below |