GiaNXGX
10.13.12 | Truth and if you disagree you are wrong. |
YoYoMancuso
10.13.12 | amen. it's a 4 at best. |
Chortles
10.13.12 | i love men! |
Lenix
10.13.12 | wow, now I'm so glad I gave it a 3 when I did then! |
ThunderNeutral21
10.13.12 | truth hard, i jammed some of it, and its really good but overlong and not as good as soundtracks so far for me |
mindleviticus
10.13.12 | That's because it's really good. I 4.5'd it anyways |
MO
10.13.12 | ooo new Godspeed song is dope |
GiaNXGX
10.13.12 | Yes it does. Fuck the Seer. Longest godspeed song is awesome as fuck. It is really good, it just needs some practice and better arrangements at some points, otherwise: Behemoth > Don't bend Ascend. |
Lenix
10.13.12 | have you even heard filth? |
Spec
10.13.12 | Godspeed song rules. |
MO
10.13.12 | obvs not you lake |
Cygnatti
10.13.12 | does this mean I can 2 it and look elite? :3 |
Spec
10.13.12 | obvs not you lake |
GiaNXGX
10.13.12 | I have heard almost their entire discography. Swans is an amazing group and Gira is a genius songwriter. What gets me is that now in 2012 people are basically holding The Seer as a monolith of modern music and more than just a very good album- that's it. If you guys listened to Nadja or jam-bands as much as I do 30 minute tracks are not as "wow" as they seem. |
GiaNXGX
10.13.12 | Gonna up a article about the godspeed song btw. |
HitlerIsTheBest
10.13.12 | the problem is that its a great album but people like it a little more than i do!!!! |
GiaNXGX
10.13.12 | a lot of people who discovered them through it are listening to their discography now, who cares if it's overhyped
Yeah that's the good thing :] Soundtracks for the Blind & Filth are harder to listen to imo. I just wanted to clear "the 5's" out. |
GiaNXGX
10.13.12 | I bet that Sowing was introduced to Swans by Seer and 5'd it cuz reason A. |
GiaNXGX
10.13.12 | 3 GB
hmmmm..... Probably 250 kbps. |
GiaNXGX
10.13.12 | shit I'm missing a lot of stuff then. |
GiaNXGX
10.13.12 | 15.9 hours of swans but i'm missing a few
LMFAO |
GiaNXGX
10.13.12 | Swans discog is 38 album without bootlegs. Holy shit. |
Uranium
10.13.12 | we're climbing a ladder to god..... space cunt! |
Foaming
10.13.12 | "I have heard almost their entire discography."
So what have you missed? |
Cygnatti
10.13.12 | "I bet that Sowing was introduced to Swans by Seer and 5'd it cuz reason A."
uh...
http://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/41261/Swans-My-Father-Will-Guide-Me-Up-A-Rope-To-The-Sky/ |
treeqt.
10.13.12 | thanks for the godspeed you link |
GiaNXGX
10.13.12 | my fault :/ |
StarlessAnd
10.13.12 | albums sucks thanks for reminding me!11!!!!111! |
Applebite
10.13.12 | This is kind of a weird angle to approach the issue of flippant 5's. You might as well mention Neurosis, Converge, GY!BE, Deftones, and a few others. Since they all get 5'd up the ass even when people haven't heard the album. Every band has it's posers or half assed bandwagoners. I don't see what the point is of pointing out one over the other. |
afergusonart
10.13.12 | new godspeed song is pretty cool |
GiaNXGX
10.13.12 | So what have you missed?
Cop, Greed, Holy Money & a lot of bootlegs/live albums. That doesn't counts. |
GiaNXGX
10.13.12 | This is kind of a weird angle to approach the issue of flippant 5's.
I get what you mean but "The Seer" was different. When albums get 5'd up earlier it is because people are trolling or are just too excited. They usually change ratings later. "The Seer" was 5'd by arround 50/60% of the site. That's the thing. |
camaraderie
10.13.12 | i guess insta-5'ing an album 120 minutes long entails reviewing a previous album a year and 7 months before huh? |
Applebite
10.13.12 | Yeah, but I feel that it was warranted. The album is extremely good. |
Uranium
10.13.12 | I've listened to this all the way through about 3-4 times so far. I haven't come up with a solid number yet. I'm thinking a 4 and if continues to grow (which I think it may) i'll bump the rating. |
Electric City
10.13.12 | hell yeah the new godspeed stuff.
but also the seer is actually a 5 idk man |
zxlkho
10.13.12 | Woooooooooo all aboard the anti Seer hype train! choo choo |
bungy
10.14.12 | holy shit who cares
|
Uranium
10.14.12 | talk all the shit you want on the seer, they've seen it all |
ThyCrossAwaits
10.14.12 | Basic argument of this list: "The Seer is only getting 5's because it's super long."
End of list: "omg nu godspeed so loooooong rulz hahrd" |
sixdegrees
12.16.17 | I still have yet to listen to the Seer |
