bach
10.09.12 | 3 and 5 are my personal favorites. |
peaks40
10.09.12 | same dude |
bach
10.09.12 | My ranking: 3 5 1 4 2 |
peaks40
10.09.12 | @viraloblivion dude i literally just rented there will be blood, nice avatar |
Inveigh
10.09.12 | switch 3 and 5 and this would be my list |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | Thanks love that movie iwas thinking about watching it actually |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | 2 above 3? Woaaa interesting
1 and 3 are my favorites but blood mountains amazing as well |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | Ya I actually might switch 2 and 3 haha |
Atari
10.09.12 | Never heard them. |
bach
10.09.12 | @Atari
You haven't? |
Vespiion
10.09.12 | They have one of the most consistent discographies. I love all of their albums. |
ZombicidalMan
10.09.12 | I like Crack The Skye the most. It's cool how a band that wrote "Blood And Thunder" could write "The Last Baron" and make me enjoy them equally. |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | I agree zombie, and Atari I think youd love them |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | Idk I just love their older sludgy sound and march of the fire ants was my first mastodon song |
ZombicidalMan
10.09.12 | I hear what you're saying man, Blood And Thunder was my first Mastodon song, Naked Burn's probably top 5, and March Of The Fire Ants is fantastic. I just think in ye olde days of Mastodon, their sound was better, but their song writing was a lot worse. Take your pick which you prefer really |
ZombicidalMan
10.09.12 | Of course no one wants to pick Blood Mountain because it was the shitty transition stage |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | Ryan- all their stuff is great, definitely not a single bad album IMO |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | I really like blood mountain, probably even more than the hunter |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | Solid band might have to listen to them tonight |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | Hunter is good but didn't grip me like the other albums have |
ZombicidalMan
10.09.12 | It was less consistent. You had some killer tracks like The Wolf Is Loose and Sleeping Giant mixed in with a lot of filler. That's what I thought anyways. If you compare it to Leviathan or whatever, it doesn't hold up on the whole |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | I love every song off leviathan |
Atari
10.09.12 | Damn guess I'm checking them out tonight |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | That's true, leviathan was much better- blood mountain, while the most inconsistent, had some of their most fun moments IMO |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | I can agree with that, blood mountain had some fun riffs |
ZombicidalMan
10.09.12 | I think I'd hold Crack The Skye and Leviathan as equal. Definitely my two favourites anyways. Another note is that a band can't be bad if Scott Kelly guest vocals on their albums |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | "I think I'd hold crack the skye and leviathan as equal"
Glad we agree : ) |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | Yessss, Scott Kelly is a beast he's on every album except remissions I believe |
MMX
10.09.12 | Leviathan that's that shit I don't like |
ZombicidalMan
10.09.12 | The first time I listened to Crack The Skye (the track) I heard his voice and was just like "Better rate this shit a 5" |
bach
10.09.12 | That's a load of bullshit MMX. |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | Title track is the best fer sure haha |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | The czar, dude. The czar. |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | Just ignore him he wants attention |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | Damn now that I think about. Might have to put cracke in second haha |
ZombicidalMan
10.09.12 | Nah, The Last Baron has to be the best on the album. It has too many good riffs |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | There we go all fixed |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | Dude ever since I saw this list I pauses my movie to put on crack the Skye lol |
MMX
10.09.12 | That's a load of bullshit MMX.
Check my ratings |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | What's so special about your ratings? Oh yea absolutely nothing |
bach
10.09.12 | I CAN SEE THE PAIN! IT'S WRITTEN All OVER YOUR FACE! |
MMX
10.09.12 | What's so special about your ratings? Oh yea absolutely nothing
He said he didn't believe me that I didn't like leviathan (Which I don't like)
my rating for it is a 2.5
Leviathan that's that shit I don't like |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | No one gives a shit |
MMX
10.09.12 | You care enough to respond to my comment |
bach
10.09.12 | "He said he didn't believe me that I didn't like leviathan (Which I don't like)
my rating for it is a 2.5"
I stand corrected. |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | Why would you be proud to not like something awesome? |
MMX
10.09.12 | Album never sat well with me, Dunno just could never get into it |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | Yes to tell you that no one cares about your ratings |
MMX
10.09.12 | Bach was obviously intrigued by them or at least curious |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | Good for him |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | But it's about moby dick and if you don't like moby dick you don't like dicks and therefore you're gay
I go to college dude, I'm right |
MMX
10.09.12 | "I go to college dude, I'm right"
can't argue with that logic |
bach
10.09.12 | I was really just being a benign idiot when i said that, MMX. |
MMX
10.09.12 | SHUT UP and agree with me Bach so I can be right lol I'll owe you a solid |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | It's ok mmx no one can argue with that logic |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | I don't want you to owe me a solid |
bach
10.09.12 | @ MMX
Mittens Romnedies. |
bach
10.09.12 | You're all flabbergasted by my quick wit, no? |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | I gotta be honest Bach , your genius froze my body so I couldn't reply right away
|
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | Yeah Bach I threw up after I read that I was so stunned |
MMX
10.09.12 | Nope Bach, I went to go get a snack from kitchen |
Atari
10.09.12 | Lol |
bach
10.09.12 | SHEEEET! I BE ACTIN' A FOOL UP IN THIS HIZZY! |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | Define hizzy, I'm too white to know what that is |
bach
10.09.12 | One's place of residence
Example: Yo dizog, we goin to mah hizzy!! |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | Oh now I get it
So like a country club? |
MMX
10.09.12 | Exactly |
conesmoke
10.09.12 | This list is EXACTLY how i feel. The only possible switch would be between 2 & 3.
MMX...not liking leviathan at all... wtf |
MMX
10.09.12 | sorry for having an unpopular opinion
God now I know how Hitler felt |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | He wasn't alone he had a goddamn army |
bach
10.09.12 | And practically, an entire nation. |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | I hope theres not an army of people who hate leviathan, no offense mmx |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | Yea he was not alone an insane crazy fuck but not alone, I love Eddie Izzard comedy bit about hitler
"You killed 15 million people you must get up very early In the morning" |
MMX
10.09.12 | None taken. I understand why people like the album, it's just not for me |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | Dressed to kill? Niceee |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | Dressed to kill is one of my favorite stand ups ever |
Ovrot
10.09.12 | I would put The Hunter above crack the skye
so uh
Leviathan
Blood Mountain
The Hunter
Remission
Crack The Skye
but they are all good |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | I like that mastodon fans have different ratings, really shows how awesome all their albums really are
And fuck yeah dressed to kill is hysterical |
conesmoke
10.09.12 | Viral, Bach and Lucca. You dudes are my Eddie Izzard. |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | He's the perfect drinking comedian lol |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.09.12 | Cones you're the man |
Mike08
10.09.12 | Haven't done this discography in a while... I guess
1. Leviathan
2. The Hunter
3. Remission
4. Cracke the Skye- (I like this album's sound, but has too much..... filler. Not enough to keep me interested.
5. Blood Mountain- This sucks by a mile. Though I do like Caprilian Crest, Colony of Birchmen, and Crystal Skull. |
SIMBOLIC
10.09.12 | no one can argue with Leviathan at 1 |
ReturnToRock
10.09.12 | 4 is 1, and you forgot the demo and EPs. |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | I meant to do only the LPs |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | And lol @ 4 being 1 |
ReturnToRock
10.09.12 | What do you think about the demo with the shitty singer? I think it would be good if not for the shitty singer.
4 is the only one I heard and went "gotta go out and buy this shit!" and did. I guess I like it more because it's more melodic, and I like melody with my metal. IDK. |
ViralOblivion
10.09.12 | I like their sludgy sound and tbh haven't heard the demos |
tempest--
10.09.12 | 2
4
1
5
3
But yeah, they're all fantastic |
Shiduba
10.09.12 | 1. Leviathan
2. Crack the Skye
3. The Hunter
4. Blood Mountain
5. Remission
every album is fucking awesome though. Haven't listened to Remission enough. |
ThroneOfAgony
10.09.12 | 4's actually my 1. It has everything in it, and 2 yeah agreed with that one |
Dolving999
10.09.12 | 1 is a Leviathan of an album. |
evilford
10.09.12 | lol Atari how have you never heard of Mastodon?
Leviathan rules. Remission does as well. it's a dropoff after that |
evilford
10.09.12 | It's cool, Atari's a good dude. it's just funny that he has never even heard of them... |
Atari
10.09.12 | @ford, of course I've heard of mastodon, just haven't heard them yet. Bases on the 2 songs I've heard, neurosis blows them out of the water
pestiferous, check out neurosis they are amazing lol |
evilford
10.09.12 | oh...I thought you had said you had not heard of them lol
they are overrated but they had some good stuff. and Neurosis does blow them out of the water ;). but Neurosis blows pretty much everyone out of the water |
Atari
10.09.12 | Nah I've heard about them ;) gonna check them out today remember I'm fairly new to metal just like you! |
InbredJed
10.11.12 | This thread is cool. Neurosis >> Mastodon and Blood Mountain is by far the best album, it all came together and it's been a down-hill slide ever since. |
Polyethylene
11.18.12 | Switch 1 and 2 and you've got yourself a deal. The Hunter blew imo... |
MeatSalad
11.18.12 | 1>3>2>4>5 |
oltnabrick
11.18.12 | 5 is their worst. |
MeatSalad
11.18.12 | 5 isn't a mastodon album |
MeatSalad
11.18.12 | HAhahahaha no |
oltnabrick
11.18.12 | Yeah the more I think about it, I don't really like The Hunter.
I hope they do something more like Leviathan or CTS on their next album. |
MeatSalad
11.18.12 | It's mastodon minus all the mastodon |
Polyethylene
11.18.12 | Well yes it's Mastodon minus a lot of the mythology and more ambitious songwriting, problem is that was most of the appeal for me. I liked it all cheesy and epic and fantasy-themed, without it its just radio-friendly "metal."
Curl of the Burl makes me hurl |
MeatSalad
11.18.12 | Curl of the burl is a shitty attempt at stoner rock |
figure337
11.18.12 | Correct order sir. Great job!!!
Curl of the burl is great for what is: The catchiest fucking alternative stoner rock(?) song of all time. |
figure337
11.18.12 | The hunter is great is just lacks the direction of their previous efforts. |
MeatSalad
11.18.12 | ....... |
MeatSalad
11.18.12 | They both do |
MeatSalad
11.18.12 | v |
pedro70512
11.18.12 | 1, 4, 2, 3, 5. Blood Mountain's first half is amazing, second wanders a little. All of Leviathan is awesome. The Hunter just doesn't have the oomph. It's so straightforward that it doesn't have the replay value. |
pedro70512
11.18.12 | I'd actually put Call of the Mastodon ahead of The Hunter, come to think of it. |
DotEight
11.18.12 | Took 4mg of melatonin and did 0.5g of Molly, wonder how long until I pass out. |
Polyethylene
11.18.12 | Black Tongue is good and I think I enjoyed Spectrelight, the rest was just so damn... unremarkable. |
GringoSuave89
11.18.12 | I agree so hard with this list, though depending on my mood I'd switch Skye and Remission. |
oltnabrick
11.18.12 | Leviathan is their best. |
