bach
10.07.12 | Bon Scott is m/ |
TheNotrap
10.07.12 | Yeah Highway To Hell and Back In Black are absolute classics.
|
GnFnRs87
10.07.12 | Good try but mine would be
1. Highway to Hell
2. Back in Black
3. Let There Be Rock
4. High Voltage
5. Flick Of The Switch/ Powerage (can't decide but FOTS is so underrated) |
SCREAMorphine
10.07.12 | Bon was the man! |
mikedrumz
10.07.12 | Why is black ice on here |
ReturnToRock
10.07.12 | I only agree with your 1. WTF 3?!
Real list:
1. Highway To Hell
2. High Voltage
3. The Razor's Edge
4. Flick Of The Switch
5. Let There Be Rock/Back In Black |
MusicSlayerHQ
10.07.12 | Why does black ice get so much hate |
GnFnRs87
10.07.12 | ReturnToRock: The Razor's Edge that high ? Other than 'Thunderstruck', 'Moneytalks' and 'Are You Ready' album isn't that special. 'Back in Black' and 'Let There Be Rock' are way better I reckon |
ReturnToRock
10.07.12 | ...and Fire Your Guns. And Mistress For Christmas.
Black Ice is average, it only really has three/four good songs, and only one really great song: BIG JACK! BIG JACK! |
ReturnToRock
10.07.12 | Right back atcha GnFnRs87: apart from "Hell's Bells", "Shoot To Thrill", "Back In Black" and "You Shook Me All Night Long" album isn't that special. |
GnFnRs87
10.07.12 | Well it also has 'Rock and Roll Ain't Noise Pollution' and is notable for being the first post- Bon Scott album but you have a point I suppose. |
ReturnToRock
10.07.12 | Yeah and Have A Drink On Me. But like I said, Razors has Fire Your Guns and Mistress which are kind of equivalent. And it doesn't have Shake A Leg to drag it down. |
Youtellme
10.07.12 | Band sucks. |
GnFnRs87
10.07.12 | However the last 5 songs on Razors Edge are all filler. Objectively I'd say The Razors Edge has more good songs but Back in Black has more great songs. |
ReturnToRock
10.07.12 | I agree, actually. But again, Razors filler >>> BiB filler.
Also, comment above yours is standard for this band around here, so get ready for some heat. |
ReturnToRock
10.07.12 | Oh man, I knew I was forgetting one - Got You By The Balls! THAT is a great song, for me it's even better than Mistress! |
GnFnRs87
10.07.12 | I guess I'd agree with that. 'Back in Black' has less filler than 'Razors Edge' but the filler is better on R.E, and BIB has more great songs. Looking from that angle they're objectively equal
'Band sucks'
Retarded comment by a retarded user. So so predictable |
ReturnToRock
10.07.12 | Well most of them are like that. "Generic band", "band is lol", etc.
I would rate BiB no higher than a 3, whereas Razors is a 3.5-4 for me. |
GnFnRs87
10.07.12 | I think I have BiB at a 4.5 and R.E at a 3.5, I take into account influence too and the fact that for AC/DC to replace Bon Scott with Brian Johnson and to produce one of their best albums after losing their popular frontman deserves some credit considering it could have become a half-assed attempt to imitate the Scott days |
ReturnToRock
10.07.12 | ^Oh, you mean like Stiff Upper Lip? ;) |
GnFnRs87
10.07.12 | Basically yes xD if Stiff Upper Lip or Fly on the Wall had come after Highway to Hell then AC/DC certainly wouldn't be as successful as they are now |
GnFnRs87
10.07.12 | Basically yes xD if Stiff Upper Lip or Fly on the Wall had come after Highway to Hell then AC/DC certainly wouldn't be as successful as they are now |
GnFnRs87
10.07.12 | Damn thing, posting twice |
Titan
10.07.12 | swap black ice with dirty deeds....and you're right on the money! |
ReturnToRock
10.07.12 | I'm a fanboy, but I can admit they had a lot of poor albums. I actually don't mind Fly, there's much worse. For Those About To Rock, anyone? Blow Up Your Video? Ballbreaker? |
Titan
10.07.12 | BUYV is just as bad as Fly......Ballbreaker and For those fuckin rip |
GnFnRs87
10.07.12 | I didn't really mind 'FTATR' that much ..... Title track and 'Evil Walks' are okay. Way better than anything on 'Ballbreaker' or 'Blow Up Your Video'. Might even suggest title track raped anything on 'Fly On The Wall' too |
Titan
10.07.12 | agree......spellbound is a great track too |
ReturnToRock
10.07.12 | Fly had Sink The Pink, Danger, and Stand Up. BUYV had Heatseeker, That's The Way..., and Meanstreak. BallBreaker had Hard As A Rock and Hail Caesar, and FTATR has the title track, Put The Finger On You, Evil Walks and C.O.D.
For me it would go Fly > FTATR > BUYV > BallBreaker. And Stiff Upper Lip is right before Fly, almost tied with it. |
NightProwler
10.07.12 | Night Prowler is one of the best songs ever. |
Cygnatti
10.07.12 | back in black is ridiculously overrated |
NightProwler
10.07.12 | 4 classic songs, 1 really good, 5 fillers on BiB. But still, I 4 it |
Cygnatti
10.07.12 | way too much fillers on BiB, highway is much better |
NightProwler
10.07.12 | Oh, definitely! |
ReturnToRock
10.08.12 | "way too much fillers on BiB, highway is much better"
This. That initial sequence of Highway-Girls Got Rhythm-Walk All Over You-Touch Too Much alone is worth the price of admission. And then there's also Shot Down In Flames and Night Prowler... |
GnFnRs87
10.08.12 | And 'If You Want Blood .... You Got It' which has to be one of my favourite AC/DC songs |
ReturnToRock
10.08.12 | Don't like that one that much, but it's a decent song, as is Beating Around The Bush. The only real fillers on that album are Love Hungry Man and Get It Hot (and arguably Beating, but like I said, it's decent). Compare that to Shake A Leg, Given The Dog A Bone, Let Me Put My Love Into You, and there's really no discussion. |
GnFnRs87
10.08.12 | Exactly. 'Highway to Hell' is best by several miles. Although I do enjoy 'Let There Be Rock' (title track annoys me though) and 'High Voltage' too |
ReturnToRock
10.08.12 | Actually my order for the full discog would go:
1. Highway
2. High Voltage
3. Razors
4. Flick
5. LTBR
6. Powerage
7. BiB
8. Dirty Deeds
9. Fly
10. Stiff Upper Lip
11. Black Ice
12. FTATR
13. BUYV
14. BallBreaker
Fly and Ice are only where they are because Fly has Sink The Pink, Danger, Shake Your Foundations and Stand Up, and Ice has R'n'R Train, Big Jack, and Spoilin' For A Fight. Can't believe I rated Ice a 3.5 back then, album is more like a 2/2.5, same as Lip. |
Blakethemusicman123
02.19.15 | 1, 5, High Voltage (International), 2, 4 |
