WeepingBanana
08.21.12 | New American Gospel^^ which is a Lamb Of God album i guess, idk i just looked it up
list is so edgy and contrarian i can't even take it |
SCREAMorphine
08.21.12 | I love when people make lists like this |
camaraderie
08.21.12 | Oh man! |
NoMeansYes
08.21.12 | 1 is a classic in genre and out. 6 really is their best album, that's not to say that it isn't overrated tho. 5 is completely wrong. Who the hell rates 9 and 11 highly!? |
Deviant.
08.21.12 | "Probably the weakest sludge metal I've ever heard."
Well there's your first problem |
alachlahol
08.21.12 | hey NWOAHM fuck off and die |
Youtellme
08.21.12 | Nevermind has to be here. |
TenSecondsToThink
08.21.12 | Wat? No way that this is serious. |
Youtellme
08.21.12 | "Classic: Slipknot - Iowa"
Um...
|
ViperAces
08.21.12 | 7 is overrated |
tempest--
08.21.12 | This list is like Grand Theft Auto. Sure, these albums are overrated as hell, but that doesn't make them bad.
Also, Yellow & Green isn't a sludge metal album and was never meant to be a sludge metal album.
You get nothing! You lose! Good day, sir! |
Insurrection
08.21.12 | so much wrong in this list |
JamieTwort
08.21.12 | lol at 1. |
JohnnyoftheWell
08.21.12 | List has a few right, but 1 and 2 just no, 7+12 aren't worth mentioning
6 is a little bit (not their best, true), and 3 for sure |
KILL
08.21.12 | bitch |
thumbcrusher
08.21.12 | overrated - aka 'i don't like these albums as much as some people so and my opinion is objectively right so they should not bring other people the enjoyment they do cause i'm a miserable bastard.' |
Pentagon
08.21.12 | "OK, I know it sounds weird this is here considering how trashed it has been, however for some reason there are people claiming that this will be revered as a classic in twenty years. I have no idea of what they're talking about."
Stop making shit up |
Rsetness9
08.21.12 | I agree with 4 |
jrm96
08.21.12 | maybe some are overrated bcuz they're actually good |
YankeeDudel
08.21.12 | overrated - aka 'i don't like these albums as much as some people so and my opinion is objectively right so they should not bring other people the enjoyment they do cause i'm a miserable bastard.' [2] |
IndianaWarLord
08.21.12 | i thought the blackening was stellar. i feel like you're the drunk guy disagreeing with everything b/c you desire the attention and want people to think you may have some sort of clue of what you're talking about |
AGuyIsWatchingYou
08.21.12 | "overrated - aka 'i don't like these albums as much as some people so and my opinion is objectively right so they should not bring other people the enjoyment they do cause i'm a miserable bastard.'"
Pretty much this, the word has absolutely no meaning and can be applied to every album ever recorded. You don't even have to listen to the album, just slap the word on the album and it's a valid criticism. |
MasBarHigeuoris21
08.21.12 | Agree with 3 and 4 but having 15 on here is stupid. 15 is not even close to sludge metal. |
TheSpirit
08.21.12 | This list epitomizes what's wrong with site nowadays |
MO
08.21.12 | "So Meshuggah wimped out hard here and this is their best album? This is nowhere as chaotic and technical as their previous albums."
lol how'd they wimp out when it sounds a million times more massive than the albums before it |
thumbcrusher
08.21.12 | @riff good to know |
DeadBeat
08.21.12 | 80% of this list is actually correct. |
YankeeDudel
08.21.12 | well thanks for clarifying |
TheSpirit
08.21.12 | 80% of your brain is dogshit |
intotheshit
08.21.12 | Dude, when are you going to fucking get a clue? |
alachlahol
08.21.12 | take your ten ton hammer shirt and get outta here |
mindleviticus
08.21.12 | Probably the weakest sludge metal I've ever heard.
That's just stupid. That's because it's not sludge metal. |
intotheshit
08.21.12 | @NWOAHM666
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nc_LIR5ExIU |
Skrapyard
08.21.12 | 8: "Makes New American Gospel sound like a well-produced album."
Oooh, rookie mistake. Production is the most overrated thing ever. |
Graveyard
08.21.12 | List is all sorts of wtf |
NWOAHM666
08.21.12 | "lol how'd they wimp out when it sounds a million times more massive than the albums before it"
Lolwut? Chaosphere is twice as brutal and five times as technical.
"Who the hell rates 9 and 11 highly!?"
9 is rated highly by hipsters and 11 is rated highly by the mainstream.
"15 is not even close to sludge metal. "
The idiot who rec'd me that album said it was comparable to Eyehategod, Crowbar and Mastodon. The only thing it has related to Eyehategod is the fact it it sounds dopesick.
"Um..."
Is it still at 5? |
NWOAHM666
08.21.12 | "Sure, these albums are overrated as hell, but that doesn't make them bad."
Nobody was saying that. And whoever understood that from this list is in deep need of purchasing a dictionary. |
Graveyard
08.21.12 | stfu |
intotheshit
08.21.12 | And you're in deep need of finding some common sense. |
Calc
08.21.12 | good to know only metal seems to make overrated albums |
thumbcrusher
08.21.12 | hipsters rate chimaira? |
Scoot
08.21.12 | lol'd as soon as i saw 1 |
MO
08.21.12 | "Lolwut? Chaosphere is twice as brutal and five times as technical."
I love how you complain about them being less technical, then complain about Megadeth throwing in more solos and being more technical, make up your mind |
taylormemer
08.21.12 | I |
MO
08.21.12 | BESTIAL!!
PURE!!!! |
NWOAHM666
08.21.12 | "I love how you complain about them being less technical, then complain about Megadeth throwing in more solos and being more technical, make up your mind"
Thrash =/= experimental metal. |
NWOAHM666
08.21.12 | "good to know only metal seems to make overrated albums"
Obviously, since AC/DC, Converge and Emmure are metal, and this list is meant to incorporate every single overrated album in history of mankind, as I clearly stated in the description. |
taylormemer
08.21.12 | I |
NoMeansYes
08.21.12 | Damn |
VicariousIntent
08.21.12 | Why do I even bother looking at these types of lists anymore |
Scoot
08.21.12 | converge and emmure are technically metal though |
Kbusch123
08.21.12 | dear god yes to 5....
never liked meshuggah. don't know why tho, considering the crappy shit i listen to XD |
intotheshit
08.21.12 | lol NWOAHM.... I don't understand how you still think you make lists that mean anything. This whole entire site has berated you for your idiocy countless times, and yet you still argue. God, you must be the biggest retard this side of Sputnik. When 25 out of 25 people are telling you that you're wrong, more than likely you're wrong. Your stubborn, thick-headed, bullshit attitude is hilariously pathetic. |
Scoot
08.21.12 | pitfall |
Kbusch123
08.21.12 | @intotheshit
ill be honest, there are much more elitist and thick headed people on sputnik than this guy =/
(despite my agreement on a few of these, trashing Rust In Peace is just wrong...) |
Scoot
08.21.12 | yeah you didn't know |
ViralOblivion
08.21.12 | meshuggah is not experimental, converge is more experimental than them and Jane Doe is a classic |
Youtellme
08.21.12 | "overrated - aka 'i don't like these albums as much as some people so and my opinion is objectively right so they should not bring other people the enjoyment they do"
Actually, you know what forget my previous comments.
This sums up my feelings. |
HitlerIsTheBest
08.21.12 | "overrated - aka 'i don't like these albums as much as some people so and my opinion is objectively right so they should not bring other people the enjoyment they do"
he said "albums that I consider to be overrated." he didnt say it was fact, dumbfuck. |
HitlerIsTheBest
08.21.12 | what a surprise, a fag getting upset over my name |
TheFonz123
08.21.12 | "Everything that's not instrument-related here sucks."
well that's an interesting way to say that the vocals are bad. |
thumbcrusher
08.21.12 | damn people are moody today |
jrm96
08.21.12 | that's the spirit |
fr33convict
08.21.12 | MY OPINION RAPES THE SHIT OUT OF YOURS GO KILL YOURSELF!!1 |
bach
08.21.12 | Nobody overrates Emmure, Period. |
jrm96
08.21.12 | does anybody really overrate municipal waste? |
fr33convict
08.21.12 | "OMG! fr33convict! bro i thought you died back in 2010"
I did. Not a fun experience. Don't recommend it. |
MeatSalad
08.21.12 | 15 has a 3.7 which continues to drop from ~4.1, and yet you call it overrated. You call it sludge metal too which is beyond retarded |
TheFonz123
08.21.12 | Probably the weakest sludge metal I've ever heard! |
MeatSalad
08.21.12 | It's about as sludge as major/minor |
mangasm
08.22.12 | Worst user of all time. |
SputnikSweetheart
01.07.13 | I totally agree on 15 I can't understand all the praise it's receiving. I found it extremely boring and not inspired to say the least.
Got to disagree on many others on this list though haha :) |
darkthrone1
01.07.13 | 1.....LOL |
KjSwantko
01.07.13 | Not only does this list wrongly include Nothing and RiP, but he also takes the time to mention a Chimaira album that no one thinks is good lol. Great list buddy |
YankeeDudel
01.07.13 | list is like 8 years old |
sixdegrees
12.18.17 | this dude was ahead of his time |
swipenet
12.18.17 | Nigga what? (at most of these) |
rodrigo90
12.18.17 | How is meshuggah's nothing overrated? I mean outside sputnik |