Sweet folk album that starts very strong. 1-4 are all simple but very elegant folk songs, with a nice interplay with the deep male voice and the discrete but subtle female voices in the back. 2 is a little on the sadder side, and 4 more on the country side, but overall a great set of songs. Then 5-7 feel more like pub songs, with more voices, wider instrumentation, and honestly I feel like it breaks the mood quite substantially. If it were only 5, which is not quite my cuppa but is fun at least, it might be okay, but the piratey 6 as well as 7 really don't convince me much. In its last third, the album redeems itself somewhat, but not enough to fully regain the points it lost. 8 is nice like 1-4, and so are 9 and maybe 11, but they feel less convincing after the pub songs. 10 does feel like a halfway point, as it does have that pub song vibe but retains the softer vibe of the more subdued folk songs, and it is okay. More of 1-4 would have been 4.0 easily, but here I'll say at most (and I think I am being generous) 3.8
Bump |
