Tangerine Dream
Green Desert


4.0
excellent

Review

by e210013 USER (318 Reviews)
February 17th, 2025 | 17 replies


Release Date: 1986 | Tracklist

Review Summary: The missing link between "Atem" and "Phaedra". A very good transition piece.

“Green Desert” is the twentieth second studio album of Tangerine Dream that was released in 1986. The line up on the album is Edgar Froese and Christopher Franke.
Tangerine Dream is one of the most influential electronic groups. Their music has made an immeasurable impact on ambient, new age, techno, trance, and progressive rock, as well as in modern film score composition. Founded as a psychedelic rock group in 1967 by Edgar Froese, the group was initially associated with the Krautrock scene. The initial phase called “The Pink Years”, started with the avant-garde rocking debut work that bared the misleading title “Electronic Meditation”. It was only after their debut that we had the transition to “Cosmic Music”, partly influenced by Pink Floyd. Synthesizers were only used on their second, third and fourth albums “Alpha Centauri”, “Zeit” and “Atem”.

Somehow, “Green Desert” is a superb relic from the older days of Tangerine Dream. It was recorded in 1973 only by Edgar Froese and the relative newcomer, ex-Agitation Free drummer Christopher Franke. The absence of the third bandmate Peter Baumann can be explained because he left the band temporarily in 1973 for a few months to a sabbatical to travel around Asia with his girlfriend exploring Tibet. So, for many, “Green Desert” is the lost Tangerine Dream’s album from their golden line up. It’s the missing link between “Atem” and “Phaedra”, which was gathering dust upon the shelves from 1973 till 1986. “Green Desert” was recorded with the purpose of being a taste for Richard Branson’s of the Virgin label. All this worked because they signed a five year record deal with Virgin, beginning what is called “The Virgin Years” of Tangerine Dream. The money received by the band was used to invest in new equipment.

So, “Green Desert” was set aside until Edgar Froese dug it out of the archives in 1984. This reformed version of the original recordings has some polishes added during the remixing for the original 1986 edition. In reality, Edgar Froese couldn’t resist leaving the original tapes the way they were recorded originally. So he added quite a lot of overdubs with some new equipment that wasn’t available yet at the time when it was initially recorded. It would be really interesting to know which parts actually come from 1973. This is especially felt by me with the first two pieces that seem to be from the 70’s. For instance, “Green Desert” was one of the last instances where Christopher Franke would wield his sticks, on the first two pieces on the album, the title track and “White Clouds”. The two other last pieces seem to me definitely from the 80’s, because on them I can hear a lot of sounds that seem to me to belong to a later Tangerine Dream’s phase.

The album opens with the title track which was the A side of the original vinyl record. It’s a broody and atmospheric piece that begins with synthetic humming and shimmering. This merges into an extended and carried guitar solo by Edgar Froese, accompanied by creative and driving drums by Christopher Franke, as well as all sorts of electronic sounds such as strings or choirs. The electric guitar falls silent as the process progresses and you only hear busy drums and floating carpets made of Mellotron and synths, till finally a lyrical melody supported by frugal chords begins. The theme continues in the tighter and compact “White Clouds”. It has an interesting combination of lively drums and a bright synthetic backdrop. It can be seen as the most rhythmic track on the album due to the strong percussion parts. However, this track contains an overall mellow sound. The piece is pervaded by a cautiously optimistic melody, really. “Astral Voyager” is carried by a fast, sequencer-like motif, and with its digital-sounding sounds much like an intensive Edgar Froese post-processing, more after 1984 than after 1973. If one knows Edgar Froese’s pronounced “improvement vein”, this assessment becomes almost certain. You may never know how it sounded in the original version, really. “Indian Summer” offers wave movements and scattered string chords that come across as suspiciously modern. This sound image is interspersed with delicate melody lines. Well, “Astral Voyager” and “Indian Summer” are adorable, but would most likely fit one of Froese’s last two solo albums. So they will have little in common with recordings from 1973.


Conclusion: “Green Desert” is a Tangerine Dream’s album of great historical value. The old master tapes are only used on two tracks, but they’re already very interesting. I cannot say whether the other two pieces were completely re-written or at least partly based on old ideas. However, they convey enough retro feeling to revive the spirit of the 70’s. The old Tangerine Dream’s fans can still marvel at the unadulterated drumming skills of Christopher Franke, otherwise there is again an example of Edgar Froese’s strange handling of old recordings, which in this case has brought quite convincing results. “Green Desert” cannot be a lost masterpiece, but those who appreciate the music of Tangerine Dream recorded in the 70’s and 80’s may find it rewarding. It was historically vital to the music progress of the band.


Music was my first love.
John Miles (Rebel)



Recent reviews by this author
Universal Totem Orchestra Rituale AlienoDavid Bowie The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders From Mars
Banda do Casaco Dos benefícios dum vendido no reino dos bonifáciosPetrus Castrus Mestre
Tangerine Dream Electronic MeditationMostly Autumn Music Inspired by The Lord of the Rings
user ratings (30)
3.6
great

Comments:Add a Comment 
e210013
February 17th 2025


6357 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Somehow this is a strange album in the discography of the band. Technically this is an album that belongs to the classic period of the band, their gloden years, the years with their best line up, Froese, Baumann and Franke. However, this is an album that was recoreded in those years but without Baumman on board. Actualy, it was recorded in 1973 but was only released in 1986.

If you want to know the reason why, I sugest you to read my review to know the motif of that incongruity. Anyway, this is another great work from the band that belongs to their classic golden era.



OmairSh
February 17th 2025


17931 Comments


Nice detailed review e!

e210013
February 17th 2025


6357 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Thanks Omair. Nice to talk with you, pal.

OmairSh
February 17th 2025


17931 Comments


Same here, I see we’re on like 10 threads today haha ;-)

Hyperion1001
Emeritus
February 17th 2025


29678 Comments


never heard this one gotta check. cool review.

trickert
February 18th 2025


626 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Great review, pos'd. I think this is a terrific Dream album, probably their best of the 80s. I play it a lot. I think the addition of the work tapes is helpful--cuts their 80s sensibility and synth sounds, gives it more depth.

e210013
February 18th 2025


6357 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

"I see we’re on like 10 threads today"

Is to compensate our absences, Omair. Lol.

e210013
February 18th 2025


6357 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Thanks, Hyperion, and do that, pal.

e210013
February 18th 2025


6357 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Yeah, maybe this is their best work of them in the 80's. Still, I also like very much of Tangram and Hyperborea.

Thanks, trickert.

Christbait
February 18th 2025


1472 Comments


I pulled up a "Best of" yesterday and enjoyed a lot of what I heard. But those are tracks cherry-picked from a gargantuan discography. Also gave the Sorcerer soundtrack a listen which made me want to find a copy of the film to watch.

e210013
February 18th 2025


6357 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I'm very glad that you like it. Sorcerer is also great, maybe their best soudtrack album.

TheIntruder
February 18th 2025


931 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Whoa, another review of another album of TD and another one I need to check. And according with the comments it is another great too. Let me check and see it reading your review.

e210013
February 18th 2025


6357 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Yeah, true. It was really a coincidence, but it's always a pleasure to published reviews that interest Sputnik members, especially when they're the first reviews in here.

Ambrosian
February 19th 2025


281 Comments


Nice review. I recently revisited Zeit, that's the only Tangerine Dream album I've heard so far, I'll make this the next. I've been on such a psychedelic/krautrock binge lately.

e210013
February 20th 2025


6357 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Nice, Ambrosian. You have a very extensive, but very important road to go through, since this is a band with a very extensive and rich career.

This is a good starting point. But I advise you to check in the next place Phaedra, Rubycon, Stratosfear and Ricochet, which despite is technicaly a live album because was recorded live, is an original work from the band and probably is my favourite.

Thanks, pal.

TheIntruder
February 21st 2025


931 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Great album. Interesting story too. I am very glad that they released it even so many years later. Good work too. Pos.

e210013
February 21st 2025


6357 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I'm very glad that you liked it too. Unfortunately, this a bit obscure work of their golden era, maybe because of the release date.

Thanks, bro.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy