Girl On Fire
Revenge


3.5
great

Review

by bentheREDfan USER (76 Reviews)
March 12th, 2017 | 8 replies


Release Date: 2012 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Medicate a quick rock fix here.

Anybody remember The Hunger Games? Yes, that horrible YA catastrophe of a film (I know it was based off a book series but for the intents and purposes of this review, we will be looking at the movie) that brought to us what Battle Royale already brought us to a much better degree in early 2000s. I know they’re making another one, but I remember the complete eruption in pop culture when the first one came out. Costumes. Mobile games. Constant quotes. Bickering about how the movie did or did not fit with the book and bustling excitement for the next one. And everybody whistling that unmistakably dreary tune with the strange, half-baked Spock hand single to go with it. The term “girl on fire” also really began to float around at this time. Maybe it’s just me, but it seemed like everyone around me was just flippantly throwing that out there. When I found a rock band that unleashed their EP right around the time of the first film, I was enraged and horrified. Why had this fad found its way into rock music? But I was curious, leading me to venture into Girl On Fire’s Revenge EP.

The Hunger Games was undeniably an attention grabber, I cannot deny that no matter how much I detest the films and books. So then, in the world of heavy, symphonic-tinged rock, does Girl On Fire grab attention? Are any factors working in the group’s favor? Well, for starters, Austin Felder is a delicious blend between Linkin Park’s Chester Bennington (Hybrid Theory) and Egypt Central’s John Falls. If you enjoy alternative metal, then there’s no doubt that you’ll get hooked on his voice easily. And the band has an undeniable energy. Opener “Revenge” is a fantastic example of this. Its fast pacing, melodic lead guitar line, bashed power chord riffs, and the cries of both “Hey!” and “I’m gonna get my revenge and face this now” hook you into at least having a good time for one track, and the piano-dominated outro leads for some intrigue and a bit of a chance to really soak in the 3:20 of fast-paced rock that hits straight in the face. Furthermore, the band understands chemistry. You don’t fall into the habit of one member showing off the whole time, but you also have enough from each to really be sucked in and enjoy more of an experience than simply an EP. Like RED, the band pays attention to the smaller details, and these are some extremely bright moments as well (the sudden whisper of “suffer” in “Tragic Ending”) is brilliant, as is the interlocking of lead and rhythm guitar lines, and the breakdown in third track “Medicate”. But as a heavy rock vocalist, can our friend in Girl On Fire scream? Absolutely, and he unleashes some throat-shredding stuff in “Medicate.” Speaking of vocals, Felder’’s delivery literally makes next track “Secret Lies”, as do the lyrics.

So the band can write some good stuff. But can they do lyrics? Yes and no. The verses of “Secret Lies” are great, but the line “All our secrets are lies” just seems very lazy. “Tragic Ending” has a nice, mysterious sheen, but “Revenge” strips the bones a little too bare with the main line mentioned above. Also, you’re probably wondering how GOF does in the ballad department. I hope that’s not a burning question for you because the group doesn’t really slow down once, and it is a little disappointing. The last song on the album is easily the most generic and boring here, and maybe replacing it with a nice slowdown and ending the EP that way would’ve left more of an impact.

Five songs here, and four out of five are high quality heavy rockers that will please any fan of the genre. But lyrics are a bit too surface level to really stick. The absence of any sort of “breath of air” track hurts the band pretty badly, because it makes them seem very limited. Not to mention the fact this this is only five songs, four of which are truly worth the listen, so I can’t rate this too highly. But I would say it largely holds its weight and is worth checking out if you want some high-octane rock that’s a bit more diverse than many other obscure bands and even some mainstream ones in the pack.



Recent reviews by this author
Palisades Erase the PainSleepwave Broken Compass
XXI Inside OutPowerman 5000 Transform
Powerman 5000 Anyone For Doomsday?Powerman 5000 Tonight the Stars Revolt
user ratings (2)
3
good
related reviews

Not Broken


Comments:Add a Comment 
AsleepInTheBack
Staff Reviewer
March 12th 2017


10086 Comments


Nice review bud, pos'd. I'd say the Hunger Games intro is a bit long, you get your point across quickly so much of it isn't needed, but regardless it doesn't hinder the review much

Satellite
March 12th 2017


26539 Comments


yeah the hunger games bit is pretty dumb. it's like you saw another review where someone compares an album to another ostensibly unrelated book/film and decided to try it yourself, but failed to justify why the two things are being talked about in the same review.

mete0ra
March 12th 2017


212 Comments


"They started a long while ago I think 2007 man , from Seattle they play music! "

mete0ra
March 12th 2017


212 Comments


Not a bad review. The Hunger Games intro feels a little bit odd though, given that you don't mention it again in the review (if you had, it would've seemed more natural)

bentheREDfan
March 12th 2017


502 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Ok couple things. First and foremost is thank you all for the read and Asleep thanks for the pos.



Satellite, I appreciate your input as well, but I do feel that I justified why the two things are being talked about. I'll concede that the first paragraph may be slightly long-winded, but I'll also defend the connotation of the term "girl on fire" and how I referenced both the fad it caused relating it to the possibility of a fad with the album.



Meteora (love that record by the way), I didn't write that summary actually. I may go in and change it though because it's pretty awful. And I'll repeat what I said earlier, Met, I did reference THG after the intro paragraph.

bentheREDfan
March 12th 2017


502 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Also I hope that I still carry at least a semblance of a friendly tone. I stand by my review, but at the same time, I appreciate an open forum of discussion. I don't want to seem like I'm shoving my thoughts and reasonings down everyone's throats. Thanks again.

talktothehead
March 13th 2017


2620 Comments


do you ever feel like subjugating yourself to GOOD music?

bentheREDfan
March 13th 2017


502 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

For me, at least, this is good. Talk I don't like most of the stuff you're into.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy