Banda do Casaco
Dos benefícios dum vendido no reino dos bonifácios


4.5
superb

Review

by e210013 USER (317 Reviews)
November 24th, 2025 | 14 replies


Release Date: 1975 | Tracklist

Review Summary: This is a great debut. A historical document, an awesome original work.

October 1974. Portugal was in a state of great political upheaval, with the April revolution on 25 still very fresh and with a not yet fully established and stabilised social order after having left 48 years of a dictatorship political regime. It was in this month and in this socio-political troubled context that a new prog group in Portugal named Banda Do Casaco came into the studio to record their debut studio album, “Dos Beneficios Dum Vendido No Reino Dos Bonifácios”.

The final result of the work made by the band was a conceptual album of Portuguese progressive folk music absolutely odd that no one managed to overcome in other subsequent efforts tested in this musical style, and, in my humble opinion, not even the group itself. In reality, it’s, therefore, a musical work of the highest quality level. That is true to the instrumental and composition level, to the level of the concept and lyrics and to the level of the art cover of the album.

From the lyrical point of view, it treats the Portuguese reality, at the time, setting it in a highly intelligent and ruthless political satire. The album develops around the story of a character who sells his soul to the Devil in return, not so much for knowledge or wisdom, but only for money and social prestige. This entire narrative is served to the listener through excellent satiric lyrics, always cared, poetic, corrosive, allegorical and metaphorical, occasionally adorned with inspired puns which, moreover, are perfectly evident even in many of the titles of the tracks such as “Henrique Ser Ou Não Henriquecer”, “Lavados Lavados Sim” and “Horas De Ponta E Mola”. The use of puns is frequently used in Portugal, which is particularly evident in the dialogues of many of the Portuguese films of the 40’s in the 20th century. Moreover, a simple attentive listening to this album is enough for realizing the enormous importance that the lyrics have. They’re at least as important as the instrumental aspects, and, in fact, there are few moments unsung throughout these almost 40 minutes without it. However, this abundance of vocalizations never becomes tiresome. Probably, the fact that the sung parties will be divided by many performers contributes to that. This must be seen in both aspects, in lyrics and music. It’s very difficult for those who don’t know the Portuguese language to have the complete picture of it.

In music and in instrumental terms, the group will drink their musical influences from several different musical sources. The two most important are the intervention political songs and the traditional Portuguese music. To that we can join the jazz, some progressive music, experimentation and boldness, all served by an exemplary implementation. Indeed, we can perfectly find on this album, side by side, the reverence to the tradition of the old time music, and some absolutely revolutionary aspects such as the use of dissonances, some intricate composition or even the use of unconventional instruments like the use of stick and deodorant sprays. In terms of composition, it’s notorious for the richness of new ideas that were put on the album, preventing any possibility of it becoming boring or repetitive, even after several hearings. This richness of ideas is particularly evident on the song “A Cavalo Dado” where, thanks to the constant changes in melody, the band can build an epic track that doesn’t reach more than 3 minutes long. What is impressive is that despite the multiple changes in a short time they never sound forced or seem to be put out of place.

It also highlights the beautiful graphic work of the art cover of the album, courtesy of Carlos Zingaro. He involves the album with a kind of comic that reproduces some of the moments of the narrative presented on the album. Who is lucky to own a copy of the original vinyl disc, which is my case, knows very well what I’m talking about.


Conclusion: I returned to review some more Portuguese progressive albums. After reviewing albums from Quarteto 1111, José Cid and Petrus Castrus, now came the time to review albums from Banda Do Casaco. I decided to begin by their debut. It belongs to one of the few and best Portuguese progressive albums from the 70’s with some others like “Onde, Quando, Como, Porquê, Cantamos Pessoas Vivas” from Quarteto 1111, “10.000 Anos Depois Entre Vénus E Marte” from José Cid, “Mestre” from Petrus Castrus and “Mistérios E Maravilhas” from Tantra. “Dos Beneficios Dum Vendido No Reino Dos Bonifácios” is really an exceptional album from the lyrical, musical and even from the art cover point of view. It’s an entirely acoustic album with lots of instruments performed, which some of them are very unusual, plenty of vocal works and an irreverent musical approach to the composition mixed perfectly with very special lyrics for the concept story. The final result is an incredible and very original album. So, and concluding, if you want to hear a traditional progressive album with long epics and where the use of electric musical instruments is common, stay away from it. However, if you are an open mind and you are looking for something new, strange and original, even if you don’t catch a word of Portuguese, you are in the right place. I really think that you can’t waste your time checking this.


Music was my first love.
John Miles (Rebel)



Recent reviews by this author
David Bowie The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders From MarsPetrus Castrus Mestre
Tangerine Dream Electronic MeditationMostly Autumn Music Inspired by The Lord of the Rings
Strawbs Acoustic Strawbs: Baroque & RollCamel Stationary Traveller
user ratings (7)
4
excellent

Comments:Add a Comment 
e210013
November 24th 2025


6352 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

After having brought here "Mestre" of Petrus Castrus, it's now time to bring here another Portuguese prog jewel, "Dos Benefícios Dum Vendido No Reino Dos Bonifácios" of Banda Do Casaco.

Banda Do Casaco was a Portuguese band that was formed in 1974, shortly after the revolution of April 25, 1974 in Portugal, often known as the "Carnation Revolution".

In relation to Petrus Castrus, Banda Do Casaco, had a relatively long life, ten years, having released seven albums. "Dos Benefícios Dum Vendido No Reino Dos Bonifácios" is their debut work. It was a breath of fresh air in Portugal in those new times for freedom.

I must confess that I have hesitated in publishing a review of this album despite the fact that I've written it a long time ago. Why? Due to the lyrics. They're in Portuguese, but even if someone knew the language, they would probably have some difficulty capturing the full meaning and richness of the language used throughout the album. The puns and jokes are constant, making them sometimes with nonsense for those who don't have the spirit of being Portuguese. Somehow, and simplifying, the closest thing that comes to mind right now are the jokes and puns used in Mel Brooks movies, despite some clear differences between both styles.

Anyway, since I love the album, it's my favourite of them and is clearly an original piece with a very rich and uncommon sound. I think the band and album deserve to be better known. Here are my feelings about this album. Besides, it has an amazing art cover in its LP version.

Sorry for this long comment but I think it's important to clarify to understand this very original work.



LouBreed
November 25th 2025


256 Comments


Ok, my first impressions are that the violins are great throughout, and the piano-guitar interplay in "Horas De Ponta E Mola" is exceptional. But this is very surface-level, after the first listening session, and I was occupied with translating a presentation on inclusion of persons with disability while listening, so no complete concentration. Obviously, can't comment on the lyrics.

Zig
November 25th 2025


2772 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

my fav Portuguese group. sure, their sound became more rock, but those early 70s records are such a blending of medieval and traditional music into prog. and António Pinho, this guy's a lyrical master!

e210013
November 26th 2025


6352 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Obviously you need some more spins to get into it, Lou. And obviously but unfortunately, you lose half of the album because you cannot get into the lyrics. As I mentioned in my review and my first comment, the lyrics are essential to understand the album. The lyrics are simply amazing. I absolutely agree with Zig. António Pinho, is simply a lyrical master and this album is a proof of that.

Thanks for the comment, bro.

e210013
November 26th 2025


6352 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I absolutely agree with you Zig. This is one of my favorite Portuguese bands and this album is my favorite of them. And like you, I also love the lyrics of Pinho. The guy is simply an amazing lyricist.

Abraço, amigo.



TheIntruder
November 26th 2025


931 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

A review of another obscure album from your country e21. Nice. I hope I can like it too. I am going to listen to it and read your review tonight.

e210013
November 26th 2025


6352 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Yeah, true, Intruder. I really liked to have published it before, as I mentioned.

I hope that you can like it too. Still, it is a bit different work compared with Mistérios e Maravilhas and Mestre. Mistérios e Maravilhas is a symphonic work, Mestre is an eclectic work and this one is a more folk work.



TheIntruder
November 26th 2025


931 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Thanks for the info e21.

TheIntruder
November 28th 2025


931 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Yes I like it. This is a very strange album in terms of music and composition. Very innovative today and even at the time. Original. In terms of lyrics I believe it can be great and linked with the music, but I cannot have an opinion.

So, 4 is my rating. Great reading too. Pos.



e210013
November 28th 2025


6352 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Thanks, Intruder. Nice that you like the album. But, unfortunately, as you said, you don't understand the lyrics. So, you lose half of the album. Anyway, your rating is a very nice rating. Again, thanks.

trickert
November 29th 2025


626 Comments


Will have to check this out!

e210013
November 30th 2025


6352 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Yeah, do that, pal. It would be nice.

TheGamer
November 30th 2025


59 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Amazing original music work. It's a pity I don't understand the lyrics.

e210013
November 30th 2025


6352 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Nice you like it too. And I agree. It's a pity the lyrics.

Thanks, dude.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy