Upon Stone Dead Mother Moon
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
Muzz79
January 30th 2024


3069 Comments


Yeah carl not for me this one. 2 albums I've found that bring the riffs in 24 are Domination Campaign - A Storm of Steel and Blood Red Throne - Nonagon m/

Dedes
Contributing Reviewer
January 30th 2024


10018 Comments


"Gatecreeper covers old In Flames"
Ah, I see you know how to arouse a man.
Sounds wicked shall check

Zac124
January 30th 2024


2701 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Really good album imo. I think this does the Gothenberg Melodeath sound slightly better than the Majesties album from last year.

Flugmorph
January 30th 2024


34274 Comments


still have to find a decent us american mdm band, starting to suspect there is none.

Flugmorph
January 30th 2024


34274 Comments


okay opener slaps

Odal
Staff Reviewer
January 30th 2024


2075 Comments


I sent this to a few of my buddies who were all craving the old gotherberg sound and they are really digging it.

This thing doesn't really blow me away, but I'm really it exists. It's fun. It rips. It isn't criminally overproduced, which is the biggest sin the metal world is committing, so I'm sure it'll be in my rotation for a while

frozencarl
January 30th 2024


1646 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

@Muzz cheers, will give those a spin. I always trust your judgment when it comes to mdm m/



@Flug check their other band, Vaelmyst. way fresher mdm



@Odal my thoughts exactly. its just fun, inoffensive (well maybe not to some...) gothenburg worship





DaveyMonsoon
January 30th 2024


1076 Comments


"still have to find a decent us american mdm band, starting to suspect there is none."

Garden of Shadows? Vehemence? Estuary of Calamity/Estuary? There's more than just 'none' lmao

frozencarl
January 30th 2024


1646 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

to add on to what Davey said, check Idolatrous as well. their debut from last year was massive and Muzz wrote a great review on it

Rowhaus
January 30th 2024


6118 Comments


"still have to find a decent us american mdm band, starting to suspect there is none."
Arsis

DaveyMonsoon
January 30th 2024


1076 Comments


Actually now that I mention Garden of Shadows, all these retro throwback melodeath bands should make more stuff like Oracle Moon instead of trying to rip off Gothenburg bands, that would rule I think

frozencarl
January 30th 2024


1646 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

new Arsis when??



seconded Davey. I need to give that Garden of Shadows album a spin again, it used to not be on Spotify but is now.

DaveyMonsoon
January 30th 2024


1076 Comments


Oracle Moon is one of my favorites in the genre, it’s such a magical album. Check their Heart of the Corona EP as well if it’s there too, it’s just as good.

metalphil
February 1st 2024


730 Comments


Just listened to this album and also binged a bunch of other recommendations from this thread:

Upon Stone - Dead Mother Moon: Decent but fairly forgettable. Will probably give it a 2nd listen and see if it sticks better

Vaelmyst: Bounced off the first few songs I heard pretty hard but will give them another shot

Domination Campaign - A Storm of Steel: Some good to great sections mixed in with some head scratching-ly bad parts

Blood Red Throne - Nonagon: Solid but doesn't really even come close to scratching that gothenberg itch

Garden of Shadows - Oracle Moon: Wow this fucking slaps so far, more of this please. It's almost like old In Flames mixed with Be'lakor


metalphil
February 1st 2024


730 Comments


OK Oracle Moon might legitimately be one of the best melodeath albums I've ever heard. Sincere thanks for that recommendation

frozencarl
February 1st 2024


1646 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Garden of Shadows also rocked Sean Beasley on bass, who went on to play in Dying Fetus. DMV metal scene is lowkey underrated

DaveyMonsoon
February 2nd 2024


1076 Comments


Glad you liked Oracle Moon, it really is a wonderful album.

veninblazer
February 2nd 2024


16839 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I gotta spin Oracle Moon. It's in my backlog.

frozencarl
February 20th 2024


1646 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

so i know i said this sounds like Gatecreeper covering old In Flames but at this point Gatecreeper might be soon approaching doing that themselves lol:



https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-avD7rLjahw



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy