Cursetheknife, Whirr, Narrow Head, Watertank, Fleshwater, Heavenward, Teenage Wrist, Soul Blind, Hum, Time, Cloakroom, Impure Wilhelmina, Hybrid Forms, Bleed, Hippie Trim, Previous Love, Money, Leaving Time, ASkySoBlack, Chain Gang of 1974, some of Greg Puciato's solo material, a lot of Sunday Drive artists

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

^^ boss shit, imma check some out

Album Rating: 2.0

Much appreciated. Love me some Hum, will check the rest.

Even Empires is bad, the riff is generic and it was crying out to end on a monster riff or to let Chamberlain loose but it just didn't deliver. Instead we got a crap middle 8 and they took the easy route of going back to the chorus after a promising build up at the end. Their creativity is dead.

powering through all three 'parts' of this - have to say part II is twice as good as part I.

not saying much, but if part I was a 1.0 this is maybe a 2.0...will pt III be a 3.0 rating? stay tuned

hmmm, well 'Harmageddon' is prob the most satisfying tune on the whole thing...guess it goes

I = 1.0
II = 2.0
III = 2.5

Album Rating: 2.5

Not gonna listen but im guessing ATUM stands for a tumultuous uninteresting mess.

up and at 'um

Album Rating: 2.0

I pretty much agree with your rating doof, there's maybe 6/7 songs of the 33 that I will come back to, mainly the rockers.



Can't believe that most people on the SP reddit say this whole project is great.

Pitchfork giving this an equivalent 3.0 rating is interesting…plus stating the third act is weakest

Yeah Clay, I’m going to try and make up a 10-12 track version of the trilogy and just listen to that for a while

Album Rating: 2.0

Reddit has never been known for good takes

Album Rating: 2.0

Project as a whole has grown on me, I'd say I like about half the songs now.

Album Rating: 2.0

Strangely, I like some of the ideas on this one. Just a shame it feels so bare-bones and Billy's vocals are so weak on this project. Definitely more listenable than Act 1, the opening song is surprisingly good.

Album Rating: 2.0

This is the best of the 3 for sure. Still sucks though.