Album Rating: 3.0

Haha oh I get it. Now I see, Placebo went all stylish after hearing some AIR records (probably not) and incoprated some electro infused with sombre goth rock and created a awesome record back in 2003, and I guess Davey jumped on board. But then its just my little story, I know you dont agree. But hey 37mm works for me

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

This album wasn't too bad...

Album Rating: 3.0

Now that I have read the review over and over and over again...I dont like it. I shall write my own!

sing the sorrow and black sails in the sunset are teh pwnage.

this is my opinion.

Album Rating: 3.0

The production of this album is utter s*** and rubbish to be honest. Take 'Love Like Winter' for example. The loud and quiet sections of the song are played at exactly the same volume which results with the songs sounding VERY dull.

Album Rating: 2.5

Well AFI you've done it. Its been a slow progression over the years, but you've worked hard, made your music more and more mild, weeded out most of the stylings that gave you a punk edge, and finally arrived at your goal of bland radio rock.



It's been quite a journey. Ah the memories...

This album is...excellent!

Yea its pretty good.

Album Rating: 2.5

The Art of Drowning > Sing the Sorrow > Black Sails in the Sunset > All Hallows EP >>> DU > Very Proud Of Ya > .....

Album Rating: 3.0

I laughed when you said that Miss Murder was in a compound time signature. I was listening to it, and It's definitely in 4/4.

Nah, AFI is more like this...

Sing the Sorrow>The Art of Drowning>DECEMBERUNDERGROUND>Black Sails in the Sunset>...

their old stuff is so unoriginal and like everything else.

Okay. You most likely enjoy their bland and unoriginal old stuff better, correct?

Well Black Sails and up is good stuff, but before that, it's really shitty repetitive unoriginal punk.

AFI was pretty good before Black Sails. You're pissing me off again trib. I try and be supportive but you don't know anything about pre-Black Sails AFI so shut up.

ATASF and VPoY had great singles.This Message Edited On 10.01.07

Album Rating: 2.5

"Well Black Sails and up is good stuff, but before that, it's really shitty repetitive unoriginal punk."



HAHAHAHA. Decemberunderground is without question the worst releasse by a band that has ben getting steadly worse and worse for almost a decade.

Album Rating: 3.0

I go:



Sing the Sorrow

Art of Drowning

Black Sails

December Underground



Those are only albums I've ever listen by them

Album Rating: 2.5

Wait, they were unoriginal, repetitive, and awesome?

I personally think that Jade's influence was greater in the overall tone and attitude of the music than the song structuring (although some of his songs on BSITS and TAoD are some of my favorites).

For me Answer that and stay fashionable, very proud of ya, and shut your mouth + open your eyes are all great, but albums were good all the way through STS. They've just slowly moved away from the kind of music they used to play. Nothing wrong with that...This Message Edited On 10.02.07

Album Rating: 1.5

I'm sorry, but this album gives me hives to listen to.

All Hallow's EP
Black Sails in the Sunset
The Art of Drowning

Prior to these 3, AFI were average, working their way up.
After these three releases, I lost all respect for AFI.

Decemberunderground is just boring and very unimaginative.

For me it's Black Sails, Sing The Sorrow, Art of Drowning, then DU. Not that AoD and DU are comparable. Let's say there's an inch between Black Sails, sorrow, and drowning. There's 10 miles between drowning and DU.

Their only "unoriginal" work is DU. It's just every other 'scene' band of today. They went from hardcore punk with amazing poetic lyrics and excellent music and energy to shitty pop-rock with horribly cliche lyrics.

This album's okay on it's own, I'd probably give it a 3 or a 3.5. It's only because it's AFI that it's so disappointing.