Album Rating: 3.5

what a shitty thing to say on so many levels [2]

will definitely give this a listen or so, I've always liked her singles

this is actually so good

Album Rating: 3.5

Why would Red ever be seen as her best? Wasn't as consistent as Speak Now, didn't dominate the radio like Fearless, generally kind of sucked...

goat-core

Album Rating: 3.5

oh yeah what Sea said too. c'mon man

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

still don't get the fascination with her

Maybe she should look for more than just looks.

and maybe you should attempt not being a cockwad and not judging her as a person based solely off her romantic experiences

Album Rating: 3.5

I really didn't know sput had such an anti-Red stance on things, but I think there's a case to be made for the album even if

you didn't like it. It's her highest charting album (although it'll be topped by this one) and has a number one single

(Fearless does not). The singles were definitely played on the radio a ton. It's her most diverse album, was critically

acclaimed, and has gotten a lot of love in hindsight from P4K and that whole wave of music sites. It's obviously a

subjective choice, and we won't know until later...I was just trying to place the album within the context of her

discography

I think there's a case to be made for the album even if you didn't like it. It's her highest charting album

why does this matter tho

Album Rating: 3.5

Also, i'd love feedback from whoever neg'd...I'm relatively new at this and always looking to improve.

Album Rating: 3.5

Doesn't matter if they hit #1, Fearless had 5 big singles when Taylor Swift wasn't necessarily a name-

brand commodity on pop radio. And You Belong With Me went #2 so apples and oranges.



Oh and for the record she was one of the first artists signed by Big Machine and I'm fairly sure

Taylor Swift was the first album they ever released so she made that label a powerhouse- don't

act like it was a hits factory back in 06 when it was founded in 05

Album Rating: 3.5

It doesn't matter that it's her highest charting album, I was just refuting the weird argument of "It didn't dominate the radio"

word, i gotcha

Album Rating: 3.5

You're totally right about the Big Machine thing, I knew it was a smaller label when she signed there and the wording is misleading, I'll change it.

"and maybe you should attempt not being a cockwad and not judging her as a person based solely off her
romantic experiences"

I'm judging her relationships because she is forcing me to focus on them with nearly every song she writes.
She's had like six two month relationships so I would be willing to bet that she's the problem.

still don't get the fascination with her

Album Rating: 3.5

But, like, Red didn't dominate the radio, at least not in the same way. Fearless (song) was released

as a single 15 months AFTER the album came out and it still hit the Top 10. Red had its moment but

songs from Fearless were in high rotation for around 18 months.

Album Rating: 2.5

i was born in 1989 and that's as much attention i'll be giving this

red was really mediocre man i wish this shit would fucking load already so i can lsiten doe